Let's Read: Watch on the Rhine by Tom Kratman

The bits with the loving description of nazis slaughtering the mass of frightened young men made my stomach flip.
I have some things to say about kratman that would definitely get me an infraction...
 
Last edited:
I was wondering when we would see Kratman's creepy "you learn war from mother's milk" rant he shoves into every book. Now I don't have to wonder.
 
The bits with the loving description of nazis slaughtering the mass of frightened young men made my stomach flip.
I have some things to say about kratman that would definitely get me an infraction...
It's one of those times when you realize that the reason Kratman's military reasoning seems so dubious to us. It's a difference of objectives. His goal isn't to defeat the enemy, it's to kill as many people as possible.
 
Believe it or not, shit gets worse. And I left out the lengthy detailed suffering of the hangings.

It's worth noting that this is "justice" in a form that even the 40k Imperial Guard - unenlightened institution that it often is on disciplinary matters - would usually view as grossly ridiculous (hell, even with summary powers, as noted in Gaunt's Ghosts, a Commissar shoots someone, or even orders them flogged, it's the subject of independent review and the Officio Prefectus does not like evidence tampering or whitewash (except for keeping Guard troopers out of trouble)).

EDIT - I mean, I quote Commissar Luna Fazekeil (while she's recording evidence for just such a review board), "Officio Prefectus procedural provision four hundred and fifty-six slash eleven. Independent review of any serious or capital crime." (The Warmaster, pg. 322 (hardcover ed.)).

I wonder how the Tiger III looks. I imagine its like a shit version of the Baneblade.

From what I remember of the descriptions, that's not really far wrong.
 
Last edited:
It's worth noting that this is "justice" in a form that even the 40k Imperial Guard - unenlightened institution that it often is on disciplinary matters - would usually view as grossly ridiculous (hell, even with summary powers, as noted in Gaunt's Ghosts, a Commissar shoots someone, or even orders them flogged, it's the subject of independent review and the Officio Prefectus does not like evidence tampering or whitewash (except for keeping Guard troopers out of trouble)).

EDIT - I mean, I quote Commissar Luna Fazekeil (while she's recording evidence for just such a review board), "Officio Prefectus procedural provision four hundred and fifty-six slash eleven. Independent review of any serious or capital crime." (The Warmaster, pg. 322 (hardcover ed.)).

I'm pretty sure that this book has more soldiers executed than the entire Black Library catalog.
 
Despite all of these giant skyscraper sized weapons batteries, the Posleen have only engaged in unsupported frontal horde attacks for the past two days. Why? Absolutely no reason is given. But now, they're finally coming forth to screw with humanity.
Simply put, the reason is because they're too stupid to do anything else. 9 out of 10 Posleen are about as smart as a pretty smart dog. The remaining 10% typically top out at "Idiot" levels. With very, very few being more intelligent than that. This is revealed in one of the later books to be a result of genetic tinkering as a kind of punishment by the local abusive precursors who are responsible for everyone else's weirdness. Like the Darhel, who are clearly predatory carnivores, but are incapable of inflicting harm or even eating meat without going catatonic.

Edit: Also, the Posleen breed and mature fast enough that losing thousands in a charge isn't that big of a setback for them.
 
Last edited:
Chapter 10: I Am The Bundestag
Chapter 10: I Am The Bundestag

We emerge into June of 2007:
The Kanzler rarely enjoyed games. Especially did he not now, now that his people's future hung in the balance. He said as much, adding, "Germany has enemies, enemies she has nurtured at her own breast. They cannot be allowed to sabotage us any longer.

"No, damn them!" fumed the Kanzler. "Nor will they until about five percent of them are removed from office!"

"Well, Herr Kanzler, surely your precious democratic constitution has provisions . . ."

"Not for this, General. Not for what must be done now."

Take a shot for insidious internal enemies sabotaging Germany, and of course it's our brave Chancellor Palpatine going full Hitler on this one. Also, I'm reasonably certain that the police can in fact arrest traitors with sufficient evidence or an election be called and the other parties have their influence severely curtailed through losing it. But hey, it's not like Kratman was a bar accredited lawyer at the time he wrote this or anything…

Mühlenkampf's smile disappeared for a moment, his face growing as serious as the snows of Russia, as the falling naval gun shells of Normandy.

As Army infantry officer, this is actually an understandable mistake by Tom Kratman, but naval gun shell shells are actually quite comical and happy, gleefully shouting "Weeeeeeee!" on their way down. Both of those locations are notable as serious Nazi defeats of course.

Nothing comes without a price, of course, and so the price of the SS helping Chancellor Palpatine seize complete power is openly bringing back the SS's lightning bolts.

"To give my people back their pride and their dignity, Herr Kanzler? To let them be publicly proud of what they once were, soldiers, and among the best? Yes, sir. The price is fair."

The SS deserve no pride or dignity. They were murderous paramilitary thugs who aped actual soldiers, were never any sort of actual elite, let alone among the best. There's also the political question, which of course Kratman handles in the absolute worst way, of how all of the Slavs, French, and other foreigners would see the open parading of a tyrannical force that butchered their way through their nations.

A month later, Chancellor Palpatine is making his move…

Under a different torchlight from that under which the Posleen had feasted upon French cuisine, under a moving river of fire, gleamed eyes bright and clear. New uniforms, black and forbidding though graced here and there with silver, paraded under the torchlight. No swastikas were to be seen. But other symbols, once forbidden, were there in plenty.

I wish that I had had the foresight to have Leni Rieffenstahl rejuvenated before she passed away in 2003. What a propaganda scene she could have made from this,

Excuse me while I go violently retch into the nearest toilet.

Günter was livid, absolutely livid. These SS bastards must pay, there must be an expiation! It was nothing less than criminal for them to be singled out for praise, to be given back their symbols. He said as much, forcefully, to the Bundeskanzler.

"Fine," answered the Kanzler, calmly, from behind his desk. His fingers rapped out their impatience as he asked, "Why don't you go arrest them? Strip the Sigrunen from their collars with your own hands."

Günter sputtered with outrage. "Don't take that line with me, old man. The Greens who put me on you as a watchdog made you and they can unmake you as well." Günter never mentioned his close connections to the Darhel, of course—those were secret.



"No," answered the Kanzler. "No. That was once true, but no longer. I used to need your Green Korps. But now? Now I have the Black Korps, my green-hued friend."

The Kanzler touched a button on his desk. Instantly his door sprang open and two uniformed men entered, accompanied by one other man in the usual BND trench coat. With wide-eyed horror, Günter saw that the uniforms were midnight black . . . and that they were adorned with certain silver insignia long since forbidden.



Still not quite believing this unfortunate twist of fate, the Kanzler's former aide shook his head. "You planned this," he accused. "From the beginning you planned it. You wanted to resurrect the SS, the whole Nazi apparatus. Admit it!"

"The 'whole Nazi apparatus'? No. I admit only that I wanted to save our people . . . that, and that I would accept no limits on what was permissible to ensure this."

"But don't you see? Can't you see?" Günter insisted, his eyes shining with all the self-righteousness of the true believer. "There were too many of us . . . and we were too greedy. We have a chance, once the Posleen have finished culling us and commenced to fighting among themselves, to build an Ideal Germany. Under the guidance of those who understand we could have saved our planet, eventually, and with fewer humans—and those less greedy and wasteful—we could have maintained our holy mother Earth inviolate forever."

I'm not sure who's crazier: Günter or Tom Kratman for thinking that anyone actually thinks this way or that it makes for a plausible antagonist.

Andreas Schüler, former hippy converted to the cause by the glory of mass brutality, makes a cameo as one of our arresting officers, therefore helpfully preventing Kratman from ever having to expand his cast at all. When questioned, he denies being a Nazi (wow, so convincing) and admits only to a single one, Kreuger, whom he claims everyone hates but is kept around because he's a good tank driver. As the previous chapter established that he's actually pretty terrible at it, let's take this with a bit of salt.



Yeah, that should do the trick.

The shorter but more senior of the two answered, "The general reports that most suspect members of the Federal Legislature are under arrest, along with the A list of suspects within the Bundeswehr higher command echelons. In addition, leaders of the more radically antihuman of the political parties are almost entirely in the bag . . . Though some have already been executed . . . er, shot while escaping. Several dozen appear to have disappeared from Germany entirely, along with their families. The Darhel are not to be found either. Still, isolation of whatever Darhel may remain moves forward apace."

Kratman's wish fulfillment continues its descent into the summary execution of those declared to be traitors, again straight from the Nazi playbook.

Now, one could justly point out that, perhaps I'm reading a bit much into this as actually being what the author desires. Sure, there's his unhealthy obsession with the Nazis in this book, his plans for one of a Nazi takeover of England ("to own the pacifists" somehow), the whole nonsense of Caliphate, and his self-insert "War on Terror IN SPAAAACE!" that makes him one of the greatest mass murderers in human history. Even with all that, it doesn't necessarily mean that it is correct to refer to this as some sort of wish fulfillment, anymore than the fact that I like hamming up the cruelty and evil of the Imperium of Man means I support it or any of its actions. I mean, I wrote a snippet about transhuman space vampires slugging down alien children like a fratboy drinking contest and tossing civilians from trebuchets like Pumpkin Chunkin, but that's not actually representative of my views. That said:





Ok, back to the book. Isabelle remains in her bunker on the Maginot Line, along with 50,000 other people, and life sucks.

Even as dissidents and derelicts poured into holding pens, so too did information, vital information, flow to every nook and cranny of Germany's multifaceted war effort.

Did information flow? It was as nothing compared to the flow of refugees. Did refugees flow? Then so too did power, as Germany acquired, unintentionally, a stranglehold over everything needed by the refugees, and by the remnants of their armed forces. Most of these forces were absorbed by the Bundeswehr. Still, Mühlenkampf and his men had done good service and deserved reward. The Kanzler therefore decreed the expansion of 47th Panzer Korps into what was called "Army Group Reserve." In addition to acquiring another two panzer and four good motorized infantry Korps, as well as the penal division composed of the remnants of the more than decimated 33rd Korps, Mühlenkampf also assumed control of a large number of newly created foreign formations. Division Charlemagne marched again, in lock step with divisions and brigades of Latvians, Estonians, Poles, Spaniards and others.

Of these, Division Charlemagne was an oddity. For it was the only Francophone formation under German control. Unlike the other, overrun, states of Europe, the French resolutely refused to subordinate their interests to anyone else's command. Their army guarding the much reoriented Maginot line, the four or five million remaining French men, women and children huddled either in camps between the Line and the Rhein, or shivered in dank misery in the bowels of the line itself.

Yes, that's right folks, the entire SS and all its collaborator units are being resurrected full scale. Quite how the Latvians, Estonians, and Spaniards are crossing vast amounts of Posleen controlled territory in sufficient numbers as to form these units is rather a mystery.

Division Charlemagne is formed when a French general mutinies against higher command and the French government and brings his forces over to Germany. Kratman refers to it being swollen by numerous volunteers, including members of the original SS Division Charlemagne, which is rather curious since it was almost entirely wiped out by the end of the war and the few survivors who may have still been alive by the time of first contact (quite a number of them having been executed by the post-war French government as traitors) would hardly have been selected for rejuvenation by the French, especially a Darhel controlled government.

But then again, this is the man of upside down Earth "worldbuilding," so we can't expect too much of him.

Losses, of course, had been staggering. By the time Germany was cleared of Posleen infestations, many divisions that had once boasted strengths as high as twenty-four thousand now contained barely half that. Yet there was a new ruthlessness in Germany, a ruthlessness that cared little for the "rights" of individuals, much for the survival of the Volk.

Student deferments? Gone. Alternative service? Gone. Refusal to serve? Conscientious Objector status claimed? The Penal Formation once known as the 33rd Korps grew to meet and then exceed its former strength. And the hangmen were often kept quite busy.

Yeah, this is just straight Nazi at this point.

We have some brief discussion of the new model Tiger III B, which utilizes scavenged railguns from Posleen wrecks.

Prael understood, even agreed. The B model Tiger was a leap ahead of the original, mounting not just a railgun capable of striking the enemy even in space, but also nuclear propulsion, much thickened and enhanced armor, a new AI suite. And these were only the major differences. There were numerous minor ones as well.

Nuclear propulsion doesn't actually offer a benefit and hitting things in space with a railgun from the ground is going to require absolutely absurd amounts of precision that are highly unlikely to be available to a ground vehicle, but there we go.

The real fun is from David Benjamin, resident Israeli tank designer. Jerusalem fell last December, but about 200,000 made it out, mostly on British and German ships. France wouldn't take them of course, because Muslims.

Certainly anti-Semitic France's strong and vocal Muslim minority had put up vigorous protests towards the notion of sheltering the religious and cultural enemy.

This was all, of course, taking place during the period covered by the time skip and is never brought up by anyone prior to this.

"Yes, I must go," answered the Israeli. "My job is done here . . . but there is more I can do."

Understanding at his core, Breitenbach stepped back, looking Benjamin over from top to bottom. A small silver star of David graced the Israeli's right collar, the four pips of a major his left. Silver buttons held the tunic closed. A silver embroidered armband encircled his left sleeve, at the cuff.

The armband proclaimed, in silver letters, Hebrew and Roman, one above the other, "Judas Maccabeus."

The uniform was midnight black.

I'm gonna need to make an appointment with a hepatologist by the time I'm done with this book. Speaking of which:

The group headquarters had taken possession of an ancient castle as its headquarters. Inauspiciously, the castle had once served as the headquarters of the Prussian Army before its disastrous defeat by Napoleon in the twin battle of Jena-Auerstadt in 1806. Cool and damp it was, made worse by its surrounding moat. It was not convenient, and one had to go outside to use the latrine. Yet it is, for the nonce, home, thought Mühlenkampf. And it is centrally located.

Take a shot for "for the nonce." No idea why Kratman is so in love with that phrase.

There's a discussion of the odds facing them (about a billion Posleen on each front, not counting space landed reinforcements) as well as the German troops available, about 300 divisions for each front. That would give us probably something around twelve million men under arms, or about 25% of the pre-war German population of appropriate age.

Kreuger, the most fanatical Nazi of them all, is somehow put in charge of training the Jewish SS, because of course he is.

Finally, we end the chapter meeting Anna, Hans' old love. He meets her while training Israeli soldiers and learning Hebrew, but though his love for her is obvious, he refrains from acting upon it at all because of he is "unworthy," for once an entirely accurate statement. I leave you all with this amusing and telling statement by Tom Kratman:

Though most of the Israeli girls scorned makeup, Hans noted that Anna seemed to actively despise it. No matter, she was more than beautiful enough without artificial adornment.

Foundation, the true enemy of mankind!
 
On Ks wish fulfilment, wasn't this the man who - when Anders Behring Breivik was brought in was mostly worried police might find one of his books in ABBs possession?
 
So... how did they get rejuvenation serums and antimatter weapons in the early double-oughts?
When was this book written?
 
First contact was made by the Darhel in early 2001 in John Ringo's book A Hymn Before Battle, those techs being part of the payment for humans to help defend against the Posleen.
Also note, most of the best human military units got shipped off to fight the Posleen off world to pay for the GalTech goodies.
So basically everyone of those three hundred German divisions are raised, trained and equipped after first contact.
 
So... how did they get rejuvenation serums and antimatter weapons in the early double-oughts?
When was this book written?

First contact was made by the Darhel in early 2001 in John Ringo's book A Hymn Before Battle, those techs being part of the payment for humans to help defend against the Posleen.
The Rejuvenation treatments being specifically offered to allow maximum number of experienced people for the military effort.
 
Chapter 11: We’re Getting Drunk Tonight
Chapter 11: We're Getting Drunk Tonight
Headquarters, Army Group Reserve, Kapellendorf Castle, Thuringia, 17 December 2007
Hans shuddered with the cold. Though snow lay all around, covering castle, land and ice in the moat, the sky was, for the nonce, clear. Christmas carols—sung by a local group of schoolchildren for the benefit of the headquarters staff—carried far in the dense, icy air, ringing off castle stone and leafless tree.

Take a shot on the second sentence!

Battle cruiser Lütjens, Sol-ward from Pluto's orbit,
17 December 2007

The ship's commander, Kapitän Mölders, could not help but be amused at his ship's station. Being a part of Task Fleet 7.1 was unremarkable. But, along with another battle cruiser, the Almirante Guillermo Brown, and half a dozen of the ad hoc frigates converted out of Galactic courier vessels, being an escort for Supermonitor Moscow certainly was worth a minor chuckle. What would Lindemann or Lütjens have said? he wondered, thinking of those two brave and worthy German seamen who had gone down with the original Bismarck early in World War Two. Mölders would have chuckled too, except that he, Moscow, those half dozen frigates and two more task fleets were racing at breakneck pace into a death absolutely certain.

Take a shot for gratuitous and inappropriate German; Fleet is not part of any national organization and would use Captain. Take another shot for celebrating the Bismarck and her crew despite it being an absolute waste and cockup.

On Lütjens' view-screen Mölders saw a brilliant new sun appear for a long moment. A message from Moscow poured into his ear through an earpiece kept there. Mölders' eyes widened, then turned suddenly soft.

"Gentlemen," he announced in a breaking voice to the bridge crew, "that sun was the Japanese battle cruiser Genjiro Shirakami. It has rammed an enemy globe and detonated itself. Supermonitor Honshu believes that that globe was completely destroyed."

Take a shot for the racist kamikaze attack. Also, good job wasting a battlecruiser escort in that rather than a lighter vessel that would've done the job as well. From a purely literary standpoint, a call back to HMS Glowworm or USS Johnston or USS Samuel B Roberts would've worked a whole hell of a lot better.

Back on Earth, the light show between surface to space railguns and the Posleen reminds Hans of a certain time back during the initial Arab-Israeli wars. The Arabs have managed to penetrate the Israeli lines on a commando raid,

Fierce cries of "Allahu akbar" resounded from a shallow streambed to the north as the volume of fire began to pick up from that direction Not quite sure why, Hans began moving in that direction. Half dressed, more importantly perhaps half undressed, shrieking women began to streak by in their flight. He called out repeatedly, "Anna? Anna?"

One Israeli girl shouted to him, "Anna stayed behind to fight and cover us!" Hans moved out, alone, into the night.

He found her spitting and cursing defiance at the three Arabs who had her pinned and spread-eagled for a fourth crouching between her legs, tugging at whatever covered the lower half of her body. His experienced finger caressed the trigger four times, then a fifth to make sure of one still-twitching, towel-headed form.

Take two shots, one for blatant racism and one for it being in the form of an actual slur. Rape as drama is such utter crap as writing anyhow. Anna bitches him out a bit for never using her name, proclaims that it wouldn't have killed her, and mentions that she was a camp whore for the guards at Ravensbruck. Hans, for his part, states that he always cared for her and that the reason that he couldn't have anything to do with her is that he has an SS tattoo. She doesn't take this well and runs like hell.

Conveniently, the prototype B model Tiger is ready on the night of the renewed Posleen invasion. Inconveniently, there's only the one prototype and no crew available.
The shining behemoth positively gleamed with menace. Where Anna and her sisters dazzled, the new model stunned. From the tip of her railgun to the back of her turret, from the top of that narrow, sharklike turret to the treads resting on the concrete floor, from the twin mounds housing close-in defense weapons on her front glacis to the slanted rear, Tiger III, Ausführung B was a dream come true.

Take a wild guess as to what those mounds get compared to later on in the book. Given that, and the obvious compensation issues with the gun, I'm gonna call this the Futa tank.

"No," corrected Henschel, "for we do not even have a crew for her."

"Be a shame to just let her be captured or destroyed to prevent capture," said Schlüssel. "And it is not entirely true that we do not have a crew. We, ourselves, know her as well as any crew could, and if we alone are not enough to man the secondary weapons . . . well . . . she is much more capable, her AI is much more capable, than the A model's."

"You are suggesting we steal her?" asked Prael.

Mueller smiled. "Not 'steal,' Karl. Just take her out for some combat testing is all. And I used to be a very good driver."

So apparently these few men (and one Indowy, Rinteel having teamed up to help design this for lack of anything better to do after the Darhel bailed) are the sole personnel in the tank factory and they are unable to get any volunteers at all to help man the secondary weapons. Nor could they possibly get a bus or helicopter with an actual crew to come over. Instead, a bunch of engineers, one of whom may have any military experience, are going to go on a joyride through a battlefield with her.

As far as forms of suicide go, this is a fairly elaborate one.

Hans considered some folksy wisdom on the subject: "Quantity has a quality all its own," and Stalin's famous jibe, "Quantity becomes quality at some point in time."

The Communist bastard was right about that one, too, thought Hans, remembering distantly, the sight of burning individual Panthers and Tigers, a collection of half a dozen or more Soviet machines dead before them, while endless columns of Russian T-34s passed the burning German machines by.

Take a shot for Soviet hordes and individual Tiger/Panther stronk. Note that he does not refer to the early war scenes where a solitary KV-1 or KV-2 would force German forces to halt while knocking out every tank thrown at them.

Meanwhile, in France, the Posleen are chomping at the bit to get to them:
The command post shook slightly with the steady vibrations of the fort's three automatic cannon firing from their retractable turrets. On the screen the fire of the short-range guns, short ranged because the turrets were too small to permit much recoil, drew lines of mushrooming black clouds through the enemy host, leaving thousands of destroyed Posleen bodies in their wake. Each gun was capable of sending forth several dozen one-hundred-thirty-five-millimeter shells per minute by virtue of their unique chain-driven feeding system. All of that was done automatically except for feeding of the shells into the conveyor system that hoisted them aloft. That job was done by dozens of sweating, straining men in ammunition chambers far below.

This is like an eldritch abomination for engineers. Seriously, the tubes should be literally melting within a fairly short time frame. Naval guns get around this by using water cooling and also not firing at that high of a rate for a sustained period of time (if for no reason other than the fact that the reason you're firing that quickly means you don't have a sustained period of time left if shooting it doesn't work). There's no reason really for the land based artillery to firing at such a high rate either: ICM shells (cluster bombs, but for artillery) will wreak absolute havoc upon the Posleen. Seriously, this is a red leg's wet dream. A horde of soft targets, packed all close, coming along preregistered paths that you've had months or even years to build up in such a fashion as to channel them precisely where you wish them to go, no need for air space deconfliction, chock full of ammo, and free reign to simply wipe out grid squares? What more could they want?

But alas, both authors were infantry grunts and Kratman shows all the signs of being an incredibly stereotypical one. Thus we are not treated to the glories of artillery, the natural bane of the infantryman, in all of her majestic splendor, but instead have this dreck to wade through. We also have the fascinating logic by Kratman that, despite what is obviously a massive rebuild of the Maginot Line defenses, we remain with the original gun caliber size. Why it is not increased to 155mm or 4.5" or 5" rapid fire guns bought from the British, Americans, or Italians, is unfortunately something that shall remain an eternal mystery. Instead, all of this engineering work is done for the sake of a long obsolete gun caliber.

"And they're working," he said aloud. "Killing the alien bastards in droves. And the damned government just had to throw that away by refusing to cooperate with the Germans."

"Sir?" queried Merle's aide.

"We could have had a couple of Boche armored corps here with us," answered Merle. "We could have had a few score infantry divisions too, to help us hold this line. But, no. Impossible. We would only let them help us if they were willing to let us dictate policy. Tell me, Francois, if you were the Germans, if you were anyone, would you let the government of France, any government of France, dictate policy to you?"

"Certainement pas," answered the captain, with a wry—and very cynically and typically French—grin. "Who could be so foolish?"

Behold the idiot ball! Look upon its crystal surface! Is it not shiny and smooth, free of any perfection?

This does, of course, raise the question of where the French armored corps and infantry divisions are. Presumably they are on the line, which makes the question the question of German ones rather meaningless: There's only so many troops you can put on so much frontage. Also, what are the Germans doing? Are they just sitting back, twiddling their thumbs, or are they occupying defensive works of their own?

This conversation is interrupted by a giant boom, courtesy of Posleen space to surface weapons.

As Francois replaced the ancient telephone on its hook he said, "Battery B. It's . . . gone. The aliens somehow penetrated all the way down to the ammunition storage area. Hardly anyone escaped. The area's been sealed off to prevent fire from spreading."

Now Merle's face paled. "My God, there are twenty thousand civilians down there below the ammunition for that battery."

I swear, this is the engineering equivalent of a toddler putting a fork into an electrical socket to see what it does, except that you've let the toddler loose in a high voltage substation and covered them in grease. Why in the name of all that is good and holy would you put the civilians underneath the magazine rather than literally anywhere else? That's on top of deciding to ignore a century's worth of experience in the need for insensitive munitions because, yes, magazine explosions are a thing and took out several French ships as a result.

This proves the last straw for the French commander, who says to hell with the government, "We haven't had a decent one since Napoleon the First, anyway," prompting De Gaulle to rise from his grave as a revenant bent upon revenge for the slur. They then call the Germans and put them under their command, encouraging local sectors to do the same, in exchange for aid and opening up an evacuation route for the French civilians.

The Germans reaction to this is, of course yes, while showing in the meantime that they have done literally no planning at all. There are in fact no open lanes for French troops or civilians to retire through; they have to be made from scratch and there somehow aren't the engineering assets to close more than two of them again. They also ask for the Division Charlemagne to come to the aid of the French which, if its with the rest of the SS troops, is about 400km away in the middle of Germany. Not sure why the Germans get a pass on piss poor planning while the French don't.

The men in the dank and malodorous depths of the fortress still noticed her, even under the pale, flickering light. Though well past the bloom of youth, and despite the deprivations and terrors of the last nine months, Isabelle De Gaullejac was still quite a fine-looking woman beneath her grimy, unwashed face. Cleaned up, and when she could clean herself Isabelle was fastidious, those men would have called her "pretty"—if not beautiful.

Still, there was beauty and then there was beauty. Standing, Isabelle had a bearing and obvious dignity that was proud, even almost regal. Whatever she lacked in classic line of features her girlish shape and posture up made for, and more.

The pride was personal. The regality was perhaps the result of genetics, for she came from a family ennobled for over five hundred years.

Again, Kratman can only think to describe women in terms of their physical appearance. And look, while I might be a monarchist, the Baen love affair with monarchy is just a bit weird and creepy. I'm not sure how genetics are really supposed to play a role in this either, much less draw "the confused, the lost, the helpless and hopeless to her as if she were a magnet" as Kratman writes, given that the nobility had been abolished for several generations at this point. But hey, somehow our viewpoint French character is a member of the extreme upper class, descendant of 1% of the 1%, and grew up in medieval castles, with her childhood home being, of course, being a millennia old "hunting castle" belonging to King Henry the Fowler, founding of the German Ottonian dynasty. Why this Frenchwoman would've been growing up in a German castle is an excellent question, but of course geography and sensible worldbuilding are very difficult topics for Kratman, so perhaps we should cut him some slack.

Division Charlemagne arrives, somehow managing to make a division move in only a single day (Kratman showing, once again, that logistics is not only not his strong point, it's not his anything), and like any right thinking person, she wants to spit on such horrid abominations of humanity. She manages to restrain herself and takes her children and herself on what is supposed to be a twelve mile hike to German lines.

Finally, we have the continual end of chapter Posleen viewpoint:
"It is their blasted fortifications," Ro'moloristen said, bitter, helpless fury boiling in his heart. "From this miserable hole called Liege, to another place they call Eben Emael, to here facing this Maginot line, we are trying to break their weapons by hurling bodies at them."

"Can we get through? In the end, can we beat our way through?" asked Athenalras.

The young God King's crest erected. "We can, my lord; we must! For something is becoming ever more clear. If we do not exterminate this species it will exterminate us! They are too good, too brave and above all too clever. With fewer numbers and worse weapons, infiltrated and betrayed by their political leadership, attacked with devastating power from space, they are still nearly a match for us. I have some sympathy for these thresh, yes, a degree of admiration, too. But give them as little as ten years of peace and the existence of these thresh dooms our people."

Seriously? First the Maginot Line, now Liege and Eben Emael? Is this supposed to be World War II in reverse or something? How can Kratman have absolutely no creativity whatsoever on this? It's almost obscene just how bad the worldbuilding and whatnot are in this. And of course we have the annoying and terrible Baen staple trope of humanity as magical science nerds, rapidly catching up to and overpassing everyone effortlessly in all matters scientific. Yawn.

On a housekeeping note, this will be going on hiatus the 16th as I move cross country. I may or may not have another chapter before then, but it will be a couple weeks after that most likely as I drive a couple thousand miles and get settled in to a new job and city.
 
Regarding the fortress artillery...

Sweden used to field the 12/80 and the 12/70. Coastal artillery guns. The 70 was the gun in the ERSTA forts, and the 80 the mobile gun. 12 cm.
The 80 was essentially a FH77 (155 mm howitzer of the Swedish army) bored only to 12 cm, so a Heavy Barrel, used as a cannon. 16 rounds per minute sustained, reach out to 30+ km, or 26+ km with HE.

The 70s in the forts are water cooled, and manage a 25 round per minute sustained.
Gun crew is 12, three in turret rest in magazine.

The 70s were designed in the seventies and built between the seventies and the nineties. Turret ring was 4 meters, depth including mag was 25 m for the 9101 model and less for the 9102 (which instead is spread out horizontally).
They're designed to run for 30 days without contact with the outside, and grouped in batteries alongside fire control centers, air defenses and sensors, equally fortified.

So, by the data given, the Maginot turrets are restored historical pieces rather than new builds, but with...
Belt fed autoloaders? Rather than gun crews (because magazine explosions aren't a thing apparently - safety by design that is not). Yet the magazine crews are doing sweaty manual hauling into the belt rather than fairly comfortable shirt sleeve prepping and loading with assist of tools and cranes and air cushion carts...
All to achieve a belt fed rate of fire of about half of what I'd expect for a fortress gun of that size.

And why the fuck is the turret still retractable? Why? If they're placed as historically, they don't have LOS on their targets, and if they do get LOS on Posleen they're in trouble. The scrap metal should've been torn out and replaced wholesale and the hydraulics for turret elevation discarded completely.

Compare contrast the Finnish 130/53 TK - which is a contemporary with the 12/80, also an automatic but not a Bofors automatic, coastal arty fortress gun - 130 mm, 6 rounds per minute sustained, though burst capable for 3 rounds in 20 sec (ie 50% higher), 32 km range. Gun crew of 10, total.

If rate of fire was priority, license Bofors.
Hell, the LVAKAN 4501 was a 12 cm prototype AAA gun (ie high velocity HE spitter) with an 80 round per minute mechanical rate of fire, limited only by having 54 round magazines. Later used as a naval gun (TAP 120), only reason it wasn't procured was 40 and 57 mm filled the low altitude bracket satisfactory, and SAM was coming. If you want a fixed gun, you can probably get rate of fire as high as that or better with less crew.

BKan 1 was a mobile 155 mm gun that emptied 14 round magazine in 45 seconds. FH 77A could fire 7 rounds in 21 seconds. That's a towed gun with a gun crew of 10-14.
Those are not designed for sustained fire - but burst. But a fixed system not needing to be mobile to evade counter battery, you can turn burst rof to sustained with automatic systems.

Edit edit
Further

The limiting factor for arty, particularly fortress art ROF isn't bringing shells to the guns (though bringing shells to the gun safely can be), but loading them into the guns (also safely)

The Swedish guns achieve rate of fire largely by using either unitary shells (ie one unit is loaded into the gun to fire) with preset charge options, or (for the FH77A) simple preloaded powder cartridges that are prepared ahead of time for the desired charge and loaded along with the shell as two units. Basically, by design, you sacrifice flexibility (and a measure of precision) for rate of fire and simplicity (thus ease of handling).

Swedish guns also preferentially use a wedge mechanism rather than a screw.

This as opposed to NATO standard of bagged charges and screw mechanisms. Better precision and flexibility, and sustain is somewhat easier due to the lower overall ROF.

Given the nature of the Posleen hordes, and limits of training, simplicity seems a a reasonable trade off for the bulk of the artillery, and rate of fire. And many of your arty NCOs and officers probably won't master the nuances to exploit the extra precision of bagged charges to the point it'd be a statistical advantage over higher rate of fire.

This also reduces the need for manpower in the magazines since you're moving less units belowdecks per shot.
 
Last edited:
Somewhere in my desktop there's a write up for the first two chapters of my planned let's read of this book and I'd like to share some observations I made while making it:

Hans was born exactly in 1920 and Mulhenkampf was born in exactly 1900, making their ages the current year or minus 20. How lazy.

The FRG and GDR both had huge militaries during the cold war and should be more than sufficient to rebuild the bundswehr.

The foreign members of the waffen SS were segregated into separate divisions that hardly intermingled with each other regularly. There was no need for SS members to have some great solidarity with each other. It was also purely for bureaucratic purposes that they were part of the Waffen SS at all.

By the time the novel takes place there probably were only a literal handful of living SS veterans that had held any command above the platoon level, how the heck are they able to staff 5 divisions?

The Tiger III is in practical terms a super heavy AAASPG that has nothing in common in role or handling with a WWII tank. Why would the SS do any better with it than anyone else.
 
Somewhere in my desktop there's a write up for the first two chapters of my planned let's read of this book and I'd like to share some observations I made while making it:

Hans was born exactly in 1920 and Mulhenkampf was born in exactly 1900, making their ages the current year or minus 20. How lazy.

The FRG and GDR both had huge militaries during the cold war and should be more than sufficient to rebuild the bundswehr.

The foreign members of the waffen SS were segregated into separate divisions that hardly intermingled with each other regularly. There was no need for SS members to have some great solidarity with each other. It was also purely for bureaucratic purposes that they were part of the Waffen SS at all.

By the time the novel takes place there probably were only a literal handful of living SS veterans that had held any command above the platoon level, how the heck are they able to staff 5 divisions?

The Tiger III is in practical terms a super heavy AAASPG that has nothing in common in role or handling with a WWII tank. Why would the SS do any better with it than anyone else.
Because Kratman is an American Right Winger. That's why. How dare you question why Nazis are better than those cucked modern liberals!
 
Because Kratman is an American Right Winger. That's why. How dare you question why Nazis are better than those cucked modern liberals!
I'm an American right-winger. And if the Nazis had had their way they would have killed my brother for his mental illness. So needless to say I'm insulted by the comparison. What Kratman is is a psychotic loon.
 
Chapter 12: I Like Big Bombs and I Cannot Lie
2200 miles of driving is incredibly suck. I do not recommend it. Also, holy shit the Midwest is batshit insane on their roads.

Chapter 12: I Like Big Bombs and I Cannot Deny

Headquarters, Army Group Reserve, Kapellendorf Castle, Thuringia, 20 December 2007

Afraid even to whisper it, Mühlenkampf could not help but think, We're doomed.

In the end, though they had hurt the Posleen fleet badly, the Planetary Defense Batteries, even supplemented by salvaged railguns, had failed. Mühlenkampf had known they would. Their presumptive failure had be the major reason behind the creation of Army Group Reserve in the first place.

The landings had begun. Reports came of at least fifteen apparently major landings across Germany and Poland, along with hundreds of minor ones. The total numbers of enemy on the ground was staggering. Mühlenkampf's intelligence officer estimated that the total numbers were in the scores of millions.

This is the sort of attack that should lead to the loss of all resistance within days at the most, hours most likely. It doesn't matter how stupid the average Posleen is, a vertical envelopment that outnumbers all of your forces by at least an order of magnitude, and they're all hardier and better armed to boot, is simply a game over scenario.

In some places that flood was being controlled. Newly developed weapons had their influence, chief among them the neutron bombs that the extreme left would never have permitted had they been allowed continued influence. And, though there were never enough of them—there had not been time to build enough of them—and though they were not always in the right place to be used, even so, the enhanced radiation weapons left whole swathes of the enemy puking and dying at many of the landing sites.

The enhanced radiation weapons, "neutron bombs" they were often called, were actually a regressive technological step in weapons development. They differed from more usual nuclear weapons only in not having the heavy uranium shell fitted around the central fissile core that made the nukes so much more powerful, blast-wise, than their predecessors. The uranium shell enhanced this blast by containing and harnessing the neutron emissions of that core.

But the neutrons, unharnessed, were deadly enough in their own right. Emerging from the relatively small blast they acted like tiny bits of shrapnel, passing through bodies and killing the cells they passed through. Enough of them passing through a healthy human would kill within minutes. Moreover the death was miserably demoralizing to any who saw it and lived. Even at a considerable distance they would kill in anything from hours to days. Those deaths were more wretched still.

Best of all, the smaller blast did less physical damage and left comparatively little residual radiation. Indeed, only where it struck steel or a steel alloy did the neutrons create a long-term radiation hazard, by making the metal itself give off gamma radiation.

One bomb—a single one-hundred-fifty-five-millimeter shell—used timely, was said to have killed as many as one hundred thousand Posleen within twenty minutes of its detonation. Scores of ships had been captured intact, though highly radioactive, at that one site. Moreover, casualties in the nearby civilian towns had been negligible, as had environmental damage.

Real talk: Enhanced radiation weapons, or neutron bombs, are useless in this scenario. They were developed as anti-tank weapons because tanks are highly resistant to blast and thermal effects, but steel and radiation are a bad combo for the crew, and had a modicum of utility for the couple of years it took for enhanced NBC countermeasures to be put in place. Against what are essentially unprotected horses? Lethal and incapacitating thermal effects, even from low yield weapons, will far outrange those from ionizing radiation.

As with other rants by Kratman, this isn't "The left is evil," this is "The left isn't pants on head stupid, unlike you."

"Well, first things first," he announced to his staff. "And the first thing is to smash through to Berlin to relieve both its defenders and its people. On the way I want to eliminate the alien infestation between Magdeberg, Dessau and Halle. Then we'll spread out to clear up the area behind the Vistula line. There's not much between Berlin and Schleswig-Holstein, so the Berliners should be able to make out on their own if they have to withdraw later."

Coordination with others, what's that? Also, if there's not much between Berlin and Schleswig-Hostein, that would imply that you have tens of millions of enemies between you and Berlin, so how're you going to actually get there and relieve them?

Meanwhile, the French refugees:
Any refugee that was hit was left for dead; the enemy's railguns destroyed mere flesh beyond hope of recovery. An occasional pistol shot sounding from the rear announced those few occasions when a straggler, or a wounded refugee, was given a final mercy.

These are predominantly 1mm railgun rounds, which, while fast, impose tissue damage similar to flechettes. This was in fact pointed out in earlier books. Destroying flesh beyond hope of recovery isn't something that's really going to happen.

Captain Hennessey led the way, one of his sergeants bringing up the rear of the column. Isabelle's long, child-dragging strides would have placed her beside him if she had permitted it. Even the desire to get herself and her boys safely away from even random enemy fire was not great enough to make her willing to foul herself by proximity to the French SS man, however. She did find she was close enough to hear him speak into the radio from time to time, and even to hear what was said to him.

The news from that radio was frightening: reports of death, destruction and defeat as the covering battalion from Division Charlemagne was decimated and driven back, again and again, by the massive alien assault. Some of the news made Hennessey stiffen with pain, she could see. Some made his chest swell with pride and his bearing assume a regal posture to match her own.

Once, perhaps, she saw him reach up to wipe something from the general vicinity of his eyes.

Aww, the poor SS man is crying for his lost troops. To hell with the traitor and his men and this horrendous posturing prose by Kratman.

Indowy Rinteel, who was not a member of the crew, felt a strange sadness, and—more than a sense of loss—a sense of something missing from his own makeup. These humans were so strange. They had treated him very kindly from the beginning. No, "kind" was not all. They had been tactful, enough so that he was sometimes almost comfortable among them, despite their size and flashing canines.

Kind and tactful, both, they had been; gentle almost as the Indowy themselves were gentle. Yet, apparently gleefully, they were preparing to go forth to kill and, likely, to die. Rinteel could understand the willingness to die for one's people. He had come to Earth knowing that, in attempting to sabotage Darhel plans he might well be caught and killed.

What he didn't understand was this ability to kill. Alone among the known denizens of the galaxy only the humans and the Posleen shared this unfortunate ability. Didn't they see how it imperiled their souls as individuals?

Or, perhaps, did the humans see? Did they see and decide that, some things were not only worth dying for, they were worth damnation for? It had to be thought on.

The obvious answer is no, that's not what we see or decide. While put in the mouth of the Indowy, this is a question, with implied answer, from Kratman, he of the "I want to literally murder, enslave, and genocide anyone who I don't particularly like" War on Terror self-insert. It is, potentially, an interesting question for Warhammer 40,000, what with radical Inquisitors, the Kryptman Gambit, and a full on sect of the Inquisition which embraces their own known damnation (as opposed to radicals who think that they're still ok, even while doing horrible things). It is not here. It is hubris of the highest degree to make oneself into some sort of Messianic figure and a horrible perversion of the Catholicism that Kratman claimed to follow (last I saw, he's since gone Protestant over Pope Francis not being alt-right). Christ took on the sins that man created to save them from damnation; Kratman wants to revel in sin for some sort of materialistic salvation.

The ammunition hoppers were full. Where Tigers like Anna and her sisters carried a mere fifty rounds, the comparatively infinitesimal bulk of this tank's magnetically propelled projectiles allowed the portage of no less than 442 mixed rounds. The range on its gun would allow taking out Posleen ships even in fairly high orbit.

Tiger IIB vs Tiger III and Kratman once again shows his ignorance. The shell bulk shouldn't change terribly much, it's the propellant that'll allow for greater quantities. Why you'd use the volume and weight savings for more ammunition rather than armor or reducing the absurd size of the tank is a question that we are left to ponder. Aside from the fact that this tank would never live long enough to fire off that much ammunition, there's also the problem that putting that much anti-matter together in one spot is…hmmm…what's a good non-expletive ridden rant way of putting it?

Foolhardy. Yes, let's go with foolhardy for that one.

Fuel was obviously not going to be a problem.

"You know, gentlemen," observed Prael, "this tank needs a name."

"Pamela?" queried Mueller, thinking of his wife.

"Deutschland?" offered Schlüssel, thinking of the ship.

"Bayern," asked Breitenbach, "for where she was built?"

Prael laughed. "You louts have no culture. Have you never attended the opera? Bah! 'Louts,' I say! Think, men. What is she but a Valkyrie, a chooser of the slain? What are those Mauserwerke bulbs on front but a Valkyrie's tits? And what are we but men on a death ride? No, no. This tank must be 'Brünnhilde'!"

Yeah, no, breasts and penis compensation make this Futatank, not Brünnhilde.

Rinteel ends up tagging along for the ride.

Vicinity Objective Alfa, between Dessau and Halle, Germany, 21 December 2007

What the Posleen thought about the megadecibel playing of "Ride of the Valkyries" as the 47th Panzer Korps smashed into them, Hans had no idea. But he figured it couldn't hurt anything.

Megadecibel isn't a word for a very good reason: It's a logarithmic measurement. The maximum possible sound is 194 decibels at sea level and it isn't physically possible for it to get louder in air (through denser materials is a different story). If megadecibels were somehow a real thing, the entire German army would pulp itself trying to play it. Also, what sort of idiot are you to advertise your presence so obviously and idiotically on the attack?

The Korps advanced with, as usual, Panzeraufklärungsbrigade (Armored Reconnaissance Brigade) Florian Geyer in the lead. At a high price in blood and steel, this group had mapped out the enemy's posture, running rings around them and determining that this was by no means a single landing, but gave every indication that it was composed of no less than three different, apparently noncooperating, groups. In any case, the daring men of Florian Geyer got away with things during their reconnaissance that they never should have had the Posleen worked together.

Hans was quite certain that Army Group Reserve could simply roll over the enemy. But he saw Mühlenkampf's cleverness. If they were noncooperating, as the Posleen often—usually—were, then they might well be reduced one at a time rather than all at once. It would cost a little more time but was very likely to save precious blood and steel. Hans wholly approved of saving both, where possible.

Defeat in detail is now a revolutionary tactic of cleverness rather than basic military strategy since ever.

With his panzers spread out over thirty kilometers, behind and covering Divisions Hohenstauffen and Frundsberg, Hans awaiting the rising of the Posleen ships to meet the armored spear even now plunging through their collective skin in search of the vitals.

But not one Posleen ship arose from this group to contest with the humans. So fast was the thrust, so apparently unexpected, that the enemy were simply crushed asunder with frightful haste. Having a little time for himself, Hans stroked his left breast pocket.

Once again, the fearsome enemy are simply fodder for the SS rather than actually posing an actual threat.

For what's advertised as a mil-scifi book, this is terribly light on any sort of combat.

Hans reminisces on him and Anna

He had been trying to forget Anna, and the sins inflicted on her, but without success. She filled his mind and his heart, yes and also his desires, more profoundly than any woman he had ever even imagined. Walking from the training field to the little hut, he was awash in emotions he had never really believed existed before.

Alright, so we have him falling in love for the first time in his late 20s with a woman he doesn't really know at all or have any substantial connection to. Seems more stalker than love to me, but hey, you do you Kratman.

"Did you kill Jews?" she asked, expanding her interrogation.

"If so, and it is very likely," he admitted, "not because they were Jews, but because they were armed partisans trying to kill me. That, or Soviet soldiers."

Oh, how noble. He only ever killed armed partisans or soldiers. Unlike the rest of the German military, he never murdered entire villages and called them partisans after the fact. Unlike the rest of his soldiers in arms, he never participated in the summary executions of civilians on flimsy pretexts. Unlike everyone else who spent most of their lives under Nazi indoctrination, he never hated the Jews. How convenient that our main viewpoint character is the one "noble" member of the SS.

There was a long silence as the girl digested the information. Finally, she announced, simply, "Fair enough."

Again the hut was filled with emptiness for long moments. With eyes adjusting to the dim light, Hans saw Anna place a pistol on his makeshift nightstand.

Hans asked, "What was that for?"

"To kill you, if you had been one of them. And then to do the same to myself, for having to live in a world without you."

This is disgustingly sappy and stupid for a couple that literally doesn't know each other.

There follows a confession by her of how she was gang raped in Ravensbruck, starting when she entered the camp at age 13.

His own nose running slightly, Hans muffled back, "Now that I know what? That you were raped? That you survived? Thank God you survived, my love. You did nothing wrong and I could not love you more if you were as much a physical virgin as I hold you to be a spiritual one."

Relieved beyond measure, Anna melted into him then. But almost immediately stiffened again. "There is another thing. Something else you must know. I got pregnant, more than once. The first time I was not quite fifteen. The last time I was a bit over seventeen. It was an inconvenience to them, having to take me to the doctor and bribe him to abort me and keep quiet about it. So they bribed the doctor to . . . 'fix' . . . me. I say 'fix.' They said, 'spay.' Hans, I can never have children."

Beyond guilt and even beyond pity, Hans felt an indescribable sense of personal desolation. Nonetheless, he answered, "No matter, Anna. Please . . . believe, that doesn't matter to me."

With a last sniffle and a long, quiet pause, Anna came to a sudden, but long contemplated, decision. She stood up, drawing Hans upward with her. She forced a smile and looked deeply into his eyes and said, "I asked Sol to make sure we would not be disturbed; not for all night. I am twenty-three years old." She began to lead him to his bed, a smile appearing on her face for the first time that night. "That is too old to be any kind of a virgin, don't you think?"

So this is supposedly taking place during the 1948 Arab-Israeli War, which means that if she's 23 now, she entered Ravensbruck in 1938, before it even opened. As with Hans, its amazing how these characters manage to survive spending the entire war in terrible locales without much happening to them. These are the 1%ers of mortality.

The first of the three Posleen landing areas was cleansed before midday on the twenty-second. The second, having more warning, took longer. Not only did it take longer, but this time the Posleen did manage to loft a number of their ships. Hans' brigade went into action then, his forty Tigers ripping into the newly arrived Posleen. These died, but they died hard, taking seven of Hans' precious tanks to hell with them. Losses among the rest of the Korps were likewise not trivial.

The third landing south of Berlin was ready when the 47th Panzer Korps met them on Christmas Day.

So, the "Heavy Tanks" are apparently just SPAAGs that just dick around whenever there isn't anything flying around to shoot at, unless of course when the plot demands that it is convenient for them to go murderball concentrated masses of Posleen. As always, this begs the question of why they are designed the way they are and not like a roid raging M36 if that's their intended role.

"Maybe so," said Athenalras, indifferently. "What news of the front?"

"Not good, my lord," admitted Ro'moloristen. "In the north and south there is no progress. The People have run into the great ditch the thresh call the 'Rhein' and found no crossings. They shudder under the lash of the thresh's artillery on the near bank. In the center, news is somewhat better. Only a few of the forts of the string of defenses they call 'Maginot' still hold out. In some places, those where there is more than one such fort close together, the People suffer fearfully from the fire of nearby fortresses. But that is only in a few places. The other forts are all being reduced or already have been."

"Good," grunted the senior God King.

"Yes . . . well, yes and no, lord. Most of the thresh seem to have escaped through the next line of defenses in the center area. We have little more than our own dead to feed the host, though there are enough of those to feed them for some time. And the People attacking those other defenses, the line they call 'Siegfried,' are being chewed up rather badly. In is the same story in the east. Between rivers and fortifications we are paying a fearful price with little to show for it."

"What of the space-to-surface bombardment?" asked Athenalras.

"Less effective against the line 'Siegfried' than it was against the line 'Maginot,' lord. This second line is built differently; smaller fortifications, and nearer to the surface. On the whole it has been a waste to risk a ship to come low enough to fire on single, small bunkers. There is some . . . thing out there which has been picking off the lower orbit vessels of the People; picking them off and then moving to a new firing position. The firing signature of this thing is the same as for one of our own ship-borne, kinetic energy weapons."

Of course its called the Siegfried line, which was never the German name anyhow. Of course its better protected than the French Maginot Line for some inscrutable reason. Of course there's surface to space defenses protecting the German lines but not the French ones. Of course the ships need to get into combat range of the surface to space defenses despite chucking dumb munitions down a gravity well. Of course they can't target or make out the German surface to space defenses. Because naturally everything German is magically better.
 
Oh, how noble. He only ever killed armed partisans or soldiers. Unlike the rest of the German military, he never murdered entire villages and called them partisans after the fact. Unlike the rest of his soldiers in arms, he never participated in the summary executions of civilians on flimsy pretexts. Unlike everyone else who spent most of their lives under Nazi indoctrination, he never hated the Jews. How convenient that our main viewpoint character is the one "noble" member of the SS.

And they were only "partisans" who dared to fight back the Nazis invading their homeland, and thus clearly had it coming.
 
Wait, Hennessey?

Wasn't that a character - hell, wasn't that Kratmans self insert - in ADCP?
 
Back
Top