Let Freedom Ring (Alt!American ISOT)

Prologue

Skywalker_T-65

Writer with too many ideas.
Location
United States
Pronouns
Plural/They/He/Her
Prologue

Alternate reality theory. A concept that would have been impossible to even many in the science-fiction community. Certainly, the world of the early 1930s- consumed as it was by the Great Depression -was far more concerned with economic difficulties than flights of fancy. The whimsical tales were a distraction from very real fears. Governments were more interested in fixing their economies or warily looking at their neighbors. The average man on the street in London or Berlin or Rome had much more concern with getting food on the table. Not in fantasy.

This, of course, all changed one bright New Years morning. To this day, those involved report nothing more than a bright light and a sense of 'wrongness' that quickly faded. When it was over, the United States of America was gone and what replaced it...

Well, what replaced it would change the world.

-
Lecture on the transition, University of Oxford.



January 1st, 1932
Off New York coast


"Do you have any idea what that was?"

The command bridge on any modern battleship was always a hive of activity. Men stood at their stations, calling out to each other when something happened. And in this case, something major had just occurred. Something unexplainable to the two men standing at the bridge windows, staring out on the calm waters outside New York harbor. One second there was a brilliant flash of light...the next? The next, everything seemed normal. Civilian traffic moved towards the harbor like nothing had happened.

And yet something felt decidedly wrong.

"Louis, if I knew what that was I would be telling you," a thick Boston accent replied, the voice's owner snorting as he looked at the man beside him. "Since I don't, I can't."

"You are no help at all, Herr Johnson." Even as he said that, Louis' lips twitched.

His friend merely laughed, "Of course not, I'm no scientist! Now, what we should be asking, is what we're going to do now. Head back to port?"

A valid question. Cuba was on her shakedown cruise, and hardly fit for being out at sea after--whatever that was. On the other hand, though, there was another viewpoint to take.

"Nein," Louis shook his head, tugging at the dark fabric of his naval uniform. His bright blue eyes turned from his older friend, and out on the distant form of his own command. "I will likely return to Seydlitz shortly, myself, but not yet. I feel we should at least track down a vessel from further afield. Identify how far this event spread."

"And figure out what the hell we're going to do about it."

The German nodded, sighing softly as he did so.

What we are going to do indeed. I have never seen or heard of anything such as that flash. Was this an act of God? The French? Or even the Confederates?

With no answers forthcoming, Louis walked out onto the bridgewing. The cold air of a winter's day ruffled his pristine uniform, as the tall man held a hand over his eyes. His statuesque form looked almost like something out of a painting. His father would certainly have jumped at the chance to get an image such as this. The princely figure, standing on the bridgewing of the most modern battleship in the world. Staring out at the fleet all around him, ready to bring it to battle!

Truly a perfect chance.

"I would never live it down," Louis snorted softly and lowered his hand. The sun was behind him so there was no need to shield his sharp eyes anyway. And, for that matter, he wasn't the Captain of Cuba or even in the same navy.

Technically speaking, he wasn't even supposed to be aboard. And was restricted to the bridge. Ally or no ally.

"When I accepted this command," Captain Johnson, the true commander, spoke up once more. He had moved to lean against the exit from the bridge, raising a single blonde eyebrow at his friend. "I didn't think I'd be doing something like this."

Louis chuckled lightly, "Oh, I don't imagine anyone would expect something like this."

"Maybe one of those fancy writers. Like Verne." The American shot back, though the smirk on his face was telling.

Rolling his eyes, Louis turned away from the lean lines of the battleship. His blue gaze returned to Seydlitz, streaming smoke from her large stack. The ensign of the Kaiserliche Marine proudly fluttering from her mast. She wasn't as new as Cuba, but Louis wouldn't trade his proud battlecruiser for anything.

"Any luck with the wireless?"

That question was spoken by Louis, but both Captains were thinking much the same. If anything had happened ashore- such as troop movements -then surely it would have been sent out.

All Johnson did was shake his head, "Nothing yet. I figure everyone is about as confused as we ar---"

Before the man could finish his sentence, he was interrupted rather rudely by a member of his- untrained -crew. The young sailor was holding up a wireless report and breathlessly reporting to his Captain. Speak of the devil.

"Cap--captain," the dark-haired officer sucked in a breath, before continuing as if he was being chased by something. "We have a report of a freighter flying the Union Jack. She's broadcasting in the open, requesting that we identify ourselves. And..."

Here, the officer turned his eyes over to Louis, frowning slightly.

"...why we are in company with a ship flying the Imperial German flag. A flag that doesn't have a nation."

Louis and Johnson shared a look at that, while the younger officer stood waiting for a response. The German was confused and a fair bit worried. The American was just puzzled. Cuba was new, sure, but she shouldn't need to identify herself. She was rather distinctive.

"You know, your highness, this is probably something you should be doing from your ship." Even in this situation, though, Johnson managed to smirk at his friend.

A friend who just sighed heavily.

"Don't call me that. When we're at sea, I'm just a Captain. Not a prince."

Say that he may, but Louis Ferdinand von Hohenzollern still frowned deeply at what the British ship had said.

-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-
Staring through a spyglass, David Lewis scowled. The British sailor had seen many ships during his time at sea. He'd fought in the Great War, aboard Iron Duke. The man could say he knew his warships. And what he was seeing, was most assuredly not something he was familiar with. That damnable light had messed with his vision, certainly, but not to the point he'd lost it.

Not to mention those flags.

The larger ship flew a strange flag. Reminiscent of an American flag, but the canton was gone. Stripes or no stripes, having the stars in the center was just wrong.

Not that the ship itself wasn't wrong, of course. The turrets were different, the bridge was more built up, the secondaries were wrong. It wasn't any American that he had seen before.

"That's a Hun, isn't she?"

Lewis could only sigh, "Yeah. It is."

On the other hand, the other ship was very familiar. More advanced than what he remembered, but David Lewis had seen ships like her at Scapa after the War. And her flag was very familiar. An Imperial German war ensign.

"What the bloody hell is a Hun doing out here? Didn't we take all of them away?" His helmsman was a vocal sort. One who asked questions even if he knew the answer.

Like now.

"We did," the Captain nodded absently. His eyes narrowing in thought. "She shouldn't be there, but neither should that other ship. Hm."

The little old Yorkshire was not a fast ship. She was an old tramp freighter, though Lewis was proud of having his own ship all the same. But since she was so slow, he had no real choice here. Couldn't get away from the strange battleships. No one to call for help if they were hostile. So, with nothing else to do, there was only contacting them himself. Hopefully they didn't shoot him.

He got quite enough of that to last a lifetime. Back at Jutland.

"Send a message over to the American," Lewis turned to send that order down to the wireless shack.

At least I assume she's an American...
-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-

"You're not going to let them aboard, are you?" Louis turned back to Johnson, raising an eyebrow at his friend.

A snort answered that question, "Of course I'm not. You're a special guest, I'm not letting some Brits aboard the newest ship in the fleet."

Not a bad idea honestly. Especially since these Englishman didn't seem to recognize Cuba, her flag, or the fact that Seydlitz was part of the Kasierliche Marine's Asian Squadron, temporarily refitting in American yards before rebasing to the joint base at Pearl Harbor. Or rather, coming off her refit. Regardless...both ships were very recognizable. Especially with Louis' own status.

So why don't they recognize us?

Louis had no answer to that thought. None that made any sense, at the least.

"At any rate," Johnson clapped his hand down on the German's shoulder. A wide grin crossing his aged face. "I'm going to send them a message. Let them know that we're the FSS Cuba and SMS Seydlitz. Maybe that'll jog some memories?"

"Perhaps." Louis frowned, deep in thought. His fingers tapped the railing before him, a small rhythm to the movements. "What if they don't know us?"

Johnson laughed, "How couldn't they?"

That was difficult to explain. However, Louis couldn't shake the feeling that something was very wrong. What, he couldn't say. But there was something at the edge of his senses that just seemed wrong.

"I don't know." The German finally replied, rubbing his forehead now. Frustration leaked into his words. "I don't know. If they don't recognize your flag or my ship, though, what else will they not know? The Free States? Germany? They were quite convinced when the message said that the Kaiserreich is no more."

Silence was the only answer Louis would receive.



January 1st, 1932- The United States of America vanishes in a flash of light. Religious leaders across the world declare it an act of God or their chosen diety(ies). Scientists have no counter, the very idea impossible in all measures. The 'how' of the Event may never be found. What matters is the aftermath.

New York Harbor- The British freighter Yorkshire pulls into a New York harbor devoid of the Statue of Liberty. Unfamiliar flags flew from the warships that greeted her, lead by the FSS Cuba and SMS Seydlitz. The crew of the freighter, none more so than Captain Lewis, are shocked to find out that the country they docked in was not the United States. The United States, it was claimed, had been defunct for decades. New York was the largest city of the Free States of America.

Charleston- Further to the south, a Norwegian transport pulls into dock past Fort Sumter---flying the flag of the Confederate States. Much as in the North, confusion runs rampant. The world has seemingly been turned on its head.
 
Information 1
So. This idea.

I've been tempted by the idea of an ISOT at several points, with several different ideas. There's something about the idea of throwing history completely off the rails that appeals to me a bit more than a traditional timeline. Because there's so much variation, so much head-scratching, so much historical figures wondering what the hell is going on...yeah. It appeals to me more.

My problem has been exactly what to do. I ran through several ideas, before finally settling on this one. One that requires ASBs to justify even before the ISOT.

Because this is based on a (modded) Victoria II run.


I bring up the ASB thing, because there is flat-out no other justification for the FSA existing. It just wouldn't happen. The North was not seriously secessionist. And while I can't say there is any specific PoD in this- the FSA requires the USA to go all-in on Slavery to an extreme -it would require so many it isn't even funny. But then, that's half the fun in an ISOT that doesn't involve stuff from the future. The world the FSA+CSA come from is also from 1932 (I just got bored with the gameplay before reaching that point).

Facts of Interest:

1. Population

FSA: 75 million
CSA: 20 million

2. Alliances


The FSA was notably allied with two major powers. One of which is obvious, that being Imperial Germany. This was the longest lasting alliance I had, which is reflected in Louis. The FSA and Germany were very close, economically/politically/militarily. Very close. Expect fun to happen because of this.

Alliance No.2 will be placed here when it comes up in story.

CSA alliances will be:

Here


3. Territory

FSA: Continental holdings pictured above. Hawaii. Alaska. Cuba. Others not shown or hinted at yet.

CSA: Only land shown


4. Military

FSA: With no Washington Treaty in the world the FSA comes from, expect a larger navy. Army is also larger for fairly obvious reasons to the South. Details will be added as needed.

Navy: FSS Cuba

CSA:
Smaller than the FSA. Further details as needed.

Army:

Navy:

Imperial Germany: Forces transferred in the Event.

Navy: SMS Seydlitz

5. Leadership

FSA: Republican Party

CSA: Whig Party

Imperial Germany: Louis Ferdinand von Hohenzollern- currently commands only forces transferred in the Event.



Transferred by Event:

Free States of America and dependent territories and overseas forces

Confederate States of America

Imperial German forces stationed in FSA territory
 
Last edited:
I am hyped for your brand new ISOT story, Sky, and I cannot wait to see the tsunamis that the arrival of the FSA, Imperial Germans and CSA kicks up in OTL.
 
Well, if the American Civil war went cold instead of hot, I could see the North renaming itself FSA for propaganda reasons. It would take quite the demagogue to get the move passed through congress, but Its something in the realm of possibility.
 
Hold up, is that really the population of the South? Only 20 million? if that's so then that means that they only have 5 million adult males which seems WAY too small for a immigrant country in Vic 2, especially by the 1920s.
 
That's a suitably Dreadnought, Teutonic design. Did you make it yourself?

Nope, Imperial German design. Just one of the GK series, though admittedly one of my favorites. And I don't know how to do the shipbucket style drawings :V

So, when does Saratoga show up?

>.>

Well, if the American Civil war went cold instead of hot, I could see the North renaming itself FSA for propaganda reasons. It would take quite the demagogue to get the move passed through congress, but Its something in the realm of possibility.

Possibly. Though, at least in this case, the FSA is the secessionist group so the point is a bit redundant. Though, that's due to the mod more than anything else.

Hold up, is that really the population of the South? Only 20 million? if that's so then that means that they only have 5 million adult males which seems WAY too small for a immigrant country in Vic 2, especially by the 1920s.

One would think so. But, well...



Not actually the case.



At any rate, don't know exactly when I'll update here. We'll see on that front.

(don't seem to have picked up much interest from the exodus our new members. Hm)
 
It's definitely an interesting idea and I look forward to see what you do with it.

...from the exodus our new members.

What do you mean by this? I saw the banner about this new forum being created because of, apparently, a notable amount of of AH-goers, but the "exodus" strike-through, unless it was a joke, makes it seem like there is a reason for that.
 
What do you mean by this? I saw the banner about this new forum being created because of, apparently, a notable amount of of AH-goers, but the "exodus" strike-through, unless it was a joke, makes it seem like there is a reason for that.
There was a reason. To make a long story short and a biased story unbiased, the administrator over there (Ian) went a bit haywire and started banning people. This caused the second(or maybe third) great migration.
 
It will certainly be fun. Especially since this is very late-period Weimar that just got a loaded grenade tossed into the system.

Anywho, I will attempt to update this weekend now that I can finally breathe after the first week of work.
 
Just to double check... But the USA that was transferred over... Was it only the actual USA/FSA territories, by which I mean that the part of the US that is part of the Confederate States of America wasn't swapped, or is it IRL 'American' territory was swapped with equivalent alternate timeline territory?
 
Last edited:
Was pretty sure you'd answered, but was a be busy and it was bugging me :p So thanks for answering.

Very eagerly the next chapter. Oh, and important question. Does the FSA have/will have an aircraft carrier named Saratoga?
 
Chapter 1
The first days after the Event were chaotic, to put the situation very delicately. The sudden and complete substitution of the United States of America would have been more than enough all on its own for that. If it had been replaced by virgin territory or a United States from a world where Germany had won the Great War, that would at least have been familiar. The impossibility of it all would remain, of course, but at least one could point and say 'this is recognizable'. What replaced the Americans was not logical or recognizable. A nation divided, where the North had rebelled against a slave power? Where the nations were bitter enemies turned trading partners? It was as if one could expect Scotland to leave Britain and turn around to sell resources to the rump remaining.

And then there is the alliance with Germany. Even in those early days, a man would have to be blind to not see how much of a powderkeg this would make the Germans. Bloody hell, even I knew that. Though good luck getting anyone in government to listen!

-Winston Churchill, Politics Post-Event



Chapter 1

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, Free States of America
Five days, post event.


"It is an honor to see you, Your Highness."

Louis nodded at those words, even as he held up a hand. "Please, no need for formalities. Certainly not now."

He didn't really expect the man in front of him to listen, honestly. Standing at the entrance to the home of the American President, with the junior Ambassador of the Kaiserreich. A young man who had a bit too much idealism in him for Louis' tastes. Alas, the proper Ambassador had been on a business trip back in the Fatherland during...whatever had happened. And--

Well.

The Germany I know is gone, isn't it?

Sighing, the Hohenzollern prince rubbed his face. If this situation was stressful on the Americans- suddenly torn from their world, and placed in one they didn't recognize -it was worse on him and those under his command. The Germany they knew was gone, replaced by a--a--broken caricature of the homeland they all loved. It would be enough to drive most men mad. Louis had no choice but to bear the burdens, to ensure his men had a home to return to. No matter what.

"I apologize, Your Highness." The junior Ambassador, whom Louis had never met before now, at least sounded repentant. Still, his wide eyes had not turned away. "But it's true, isn't it? Germany is gone?"

"Germany has not vanished," Louis corrected him, continuing to rub his brow. It almost would be easier if it had vanished completely. At least then they wouldn't have what was left. "Though it may have been better if it had. I don't know how to make sense of what replaced our home."

Whatever the Ambassador may have been planning to say in reply was lost to history, as the door in front of the men swung open. A harried looking secretary, her red hair frazzled and falling from its bun, waved them inside. "Come on in now! The meeting will start soon."

Louis inclined his head in a polite bow, that the man by his side more clumsily repeated. Following the secretary into the large home, Louis reflected that he would never have been in this position otherwise. He wasn't the heir to the Throne. He took great pains to be seen as nothing but a, talented, naval officer. And here he was, the closest thing to a leader- to a Kaiser -that the Germans in America had. Quite a responsibility.

He only hoped he was prepared for it.

-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-

Free American President Charles Curtis was not a man prone to fits of stress. Even in this nation, so much more accepting of minorities than the Confederates to the South, his election had still been a contentious one. A man of Native American ancestry- when a large portion of that population was still isolated in Confederate territory -would never find it easy to reach any office. His election, propelled on the back of popular discontent with Democratic policies, was a shock to many pundits. Curtis had made his name in being a consummate negotiator and a progressive in social issues.

He had expected that to be his legacy. A man who worked with both parties, to push forward social reforms for those looked down on in the primarily white FSA. It had been his every intention to not seek renomination, feeling his age crawling up on him. It would have been irresponsible to run when he was not confident he would see the end of the decade.

And yet, here I am. My term soon to end...as the President who has to preside over something that has never happened in the annals of Human history.

Curtis spread his hands on his desk, pushing those thoughts to the back of his mind. Across from him, Secretary of State Kennedy stared right back. And next to him, the new German Ambassador, and the Prince-Captain. It had been considered for the best to keep this meeting relatively small and personal.

"Welcome, gentleman." Curtis forced a smile onto his face, despite the misgivings he felt. "I understand this is all sudden."

"Extremely." That was Louis Ferdinand. A man known for speaking his mind.

It was hard to blame him, in this case. "You want to return home, am I correct?"

"We do," the Ambassador was the one to speak this time. "But our home is..."

"Gone?" Curtis raised an eyebrow, before gesturing at the map he had placed in his office. The map given to them by that British freighter.

It was strange enough for Curtis to see a United States on the map, instead of the divided land he had always known. It had to be much worse to see a country you had lived in torn apart. Such as Germany.

Louis sighed deeply. "I attempted to stay above politics. With the fact I was never the heir, there was no reason to get involved. And now, I may not have a choice." Tapping the map, the Prince frowned at the President. "Do you realize how much work it will take to restore Germany from this?"

"Better than you realize," Curtis held up his hands in a familiar gesture. Helplessness in the face of something he just couldn't handle on his own. "Uniting our states behind policies many considered useless at best and a betrayal of the white race at worst..." Hands falling down, the President showed every bit of his years. "I'm known as a moderate negotiator, gentleman, and I can confidently say- with that in mind -that you will not find it easy to restore Germany."

"Do---do you think it's possible at all?"

In a way, President Curtis couldn't blame the young Ambassador for asking that question. Or sounding uncomfortably worried as he did. He was young and inexperienced, tossed into a role he had never imagined.

Was it really possible to blame him for this reaction?

As such, Curtis spread his hands and stared both German men in their eyes, "It may not be easy. It will not be fast, if what I understand about Germany in this world is true. And, for that matter, the British Empire and French Republic."

Emphasis was placed heavily on that word. The France they remembered had been a Communist dictatorship.

"But, rest assured gentleman, that the Free States of America remember our friends. You will have our full support, and, should it be necessary...homes here for you and your men."

The President made that promise, knowing that it was possible his successor may not feel the same. He didn't worry, though. In a new and possibly hostile world, old friends would be needed. And with the large German contingent here and in Hawaii, there was no closer friend than the German people.

It would take a madman to not want to foster relations with this Germany. Come hell, or high water.

-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-

Only a few rooms away from where the President and Prince met, another meeting was taking place. For if the practice of keeping your friends close was a valid one, it was even more important to keep your family closer.

"I'm sure you understand why this is difficult for me."

A snort.

"If you find this difficult, imagine how it feels on my side. The very idea is madness, a betrayal of everything we stand for!"

Though one could be forgiven for forgetting that the Free States and Confederate States were brothers. Americans alike, perhaps, but decades of separation and occasional warfare had left bitter scars. The divisions that had lead to the former breaking off from the old United States had only gotten worse. It was fair to say that a Free Stater and a Confederate Stater, on average, would not like one another at best and at worst---well, it was better left unsaid.

And yet...

"Look," Ambassador Jacob Franklin of the Free States was a patient man. Even he had his limits. "We are both aware that we have no choice. Business relations and trade were already taking off right after the Civil War, and it's only gotten bigger since. There's no reason we shouldn't formalize trade deals now that we find ourselves bereft of all our old partners. Unless you seriously believe that this world will be as tolerable of your policies as---"

Slapping his hand on the table, the Confederate Ambassador rose to his feet. "Let me get one thing straight here. We are not going to discuss the policies of my government in regards to our citizens. Slavery was abolished twenty years ago."

"So you say, though I imagine that the average Negro would disagree." Franklin didn't rise to the bait, merely raising a hand to try and calm the situation. "Now, I was only bringing that up as it is highly likely that your government will have a hard time convincing Britain or France or even Mexico of your honesty in regards to your...special beliefs."

As his counterpart sat down, Franklin sighed softly. His hands falling back on the desk, resting against a stack of documents that had been quickly prepared for this meeting. If only the stubborn Confederate would listen.

"My own government is still convinced that you should move with the times and give proper rights to all of your citizens. However, we are equally aware that with the loss of Germany our major trading partner is gone as well. Increasing trade between our nations is only beneficial to both of us. Confederate labor and Free State resources."

As it was polite company, neither man bothered to mention- again -that said labor was hardly free. The Confederates could put as much shine on their servitude as they wanted, it was indisputable that the African-Americans continued to suffer.

Visibly calming himself, the Confederate Ambassador brought a hand up to his face and rubbed at his greying brow. "What do you suggest next, then? That these trade deals be expanded to an alliance? A reunification?"

"Hardly!" Even Franklin couldn't help but laugh at the very idea.

While an Alliance was not out of the question, should the British Empire or some other nation attempt to drive a wedge between the Americans- who had existed in an uneasy state of peace for decades now -any reunification was impossible. It had been too many years and there had been too much drift between the two nations. No Free Stater would willingly live in a nation that treated Negro's as if slavery was still in force. And no Confederate would give up his lofty position at the top of the social ladder.

No, the United States was dead and buried. For the best, really, if one asked both of the men in that room.

"Very well, then," the Confederate pulled himself back to his feet and picked up the stack of documents. His face set in a thin line of annoyance. "I will bring these to my government. Should I expect further correspondence in relation to the rest of the world?"

Franklin nodded, getting to his own feet. He had to report to President Curtis, sooner rather than later. "Of course. I imagine our governments will have much to talk about, in the next little while."



London: Early reports of the Event reach the British Parliament. There is some panic, at the realization that the entire United States of America has been replaced by two unfamiliar nations. This panic is only increased when reports from Canada arrive of German warships sailing off the American shores- Imperial German warships. As near as can be seen, the 'Free States of America' that had replaced the United States was allied with the Germany they had known. Relations with Britain were unknown, and this level of uncertainty caused enough consternation in London that a diplomatic party would be assembled to visit America and ascertain exactly what was going on and where the Americans stood.


Paris: The reaction in France is much more subdued. The replacement of America has less impact on a nation much more focused on the nation at their immediate border. The rise of the Nazi Party continues apace, and there was little question that the Nazis were ultranationalist. Potential conflict could arise, and it was this potential conflict that had certain corners of the French government concerned by the Event. Where would the sympathies of these new Americans lay? A public party would be sent to the Free States--and a more secretive to the Confederates.

Berlin: The reaction in Germany could best be summed up as a 'bull in the china shop'. The Weimar government realized, very quickly, what the reports of Imperial warships could mean. Before the news had dried on the Event, attempts were begun to reach out to the Americans...





This was difficult. Not used to writing what feels like an AAR to me, but isn't.

Anyway, if it seems like there's a high focus on the Germans, that's intentional. Mostly because the biggest hand grenade, at the moment, isn't in relations with Britain or in social issues. It's the alliance with Germany, and what Louis and friends mean for Weimar. Fun times.
 
Probably the other biggest potential flashpoint then Germany is Japan, whose already started their descent into militaristic madness (the occupation of Manchuria is a year old) and may take the appearance of a divided America as a signal to make a beeline for the Phillipines and other (former?) American possessions in the Pacific.

The Soviets for their part are gonna be thoroughly disgusted by the CSA, even if their too far away at the moment for Stalin to really care. Speaking of which, what is the status of the IATL's Russia? Given the competence of Vicky II's AI it probably is much less powerful then OTL's USSR and there are good odds that it is still Tsarist...
 
Last edited:
Regarding your idea that the North wasn't secessionist and would not have left the USA, all it really would have taken was one or more of the various early Nineteenth Century Compeomises to go more towards the South than in OTL, though the borders being exactly the same as OTL puts a secession post-1853's Gadsden Purchase, which puts the FSA, as you said, into a more ROB/ASB territory.

A more realistic PoD would, perhaps, have Missouri and Kansas, and some of the former Spanish possessions in the Caribbean, in the CSA, while the FSA might not have Tucson but instead have the 54°40' border to Columbia/Oregon Country. It becomes much more interesting with territorial changes beyond the OTL borders.
 
The borders are an impact of me fighting multiple wars with the CSA. They used to have much more land.
 
Back
Top