Am I wrong in hoping someone just refuses to glaze Torius as he does horrible shit, even if he targets bad people when he does it?

Like, I want Boo to look into his soul, and find him lacking.

Karlach: Owes him her life in a meaningful way and has been in Avernus for a decade. She's seen worse.

Wyll: Villains don't have rights, but tries multiple times to nudge him away from doing anything too heinous.

Gale: Shows outright displeasure in the Goblin Temple, and with the soul stuff he's leaning into his Wizard 'ooo magic' plus a grim understanding of the sort of thing that normally drives Torius to do that.

Astarion: Power Good, Power Safe. He might be gently nudged towards altruism, but he's not going to say no to blowing up that stronghold in particular.

Shadowheart: Continuously throws shade. Raised Sharran, and none of his targets have been too impractical. Also unlike almost everyone else, she sees the forming cracks but has no idea how to address them.

Lae'zel: Still a Githyanki. Still a blood knight. Still viciously pragmatic.

Halsin: First it was the Goblins, who hurt him and his. Then he heard about stuff from over eighteen centuries ago. Now it's a Mind Flayer, who as an aberration falls outside Druid 'we like them' regardless of alignment.

Alfira: Very much in over her head and is trying to stay afloat. Also nobody Torius has happened to is an innocent/someone she cares for.

Minthara: Thee Enabler. 'Nuff said.

Godless: Is Viconia. Even chill Viconia isn't going to be upset by all this.

Creccoth: He's trying to be better. He's still The Dark Urge. His method of balancing is basically what Torius does. He's not going to get too upset.

Minsc also is down to clown on bad guys in horrible ways. No, what you want if you want someone with sufficiently practical/moral interests is Jaheira. She has the emotional distance to make the arguments that need making while the ability to get close enough to make them without setting him off.

Also? This is a build-up. Torius is going to Get Worse before he gets better. Especially with his BFF in the Shadowfell.
 
Oh yeah, forgot about that part with Aylin, man, the fireworks are going to be really pretty, still, we are just missing the underdark right? And after that onwards into the shadowlands
 
I would think Halsin would be a bit more upset that Torius just salted the earth for a half mile. Say what you will about the githyanki, the local plants and animals didn't deserve this.

You know what? That's valid. I'm in the process of writing the Underdark and there's definitely going to be time for me to have Halsin take him aside and at least be upfront about that much. I don't intend to cover all the quests, but there will definitely be a 'split the party' time again with a different crew.
 
"I'm sure you've heard this a thousand times and ignored or rationalized it away each time, before so I'll be brief. I don't want to be your enemy, Torius. I know what you do to them. But knowing what you do to them makes me not want to be your friend either."
 
"Was an illithid. By nature, they cannot coexist with sentient beings. Their diet is mandatory, and unlike Astarion they cannot substitute animals. Further, they are abusers, groomers, and tyrants by design." I feel no remorse. "With that thing's soul in hand,

Withers states that Illithids don't have souls in the game, and he's a pretty authoritive source given his actual identity.

Curious if that's a lore change, or if our MC's soul spell is actually doing something different.
 
Withers states that Illithids don't have souls in the game, and he's a pretty authoritive source given his actual identity.

Curious if that's a lore change, or if our MC's soul spell is actually doing something different.

Earlier in the story I made the differentiation that they lack apostolic souls - gods can't be nourished by them and devils have no use, but they exist. Essentially what Torius did was akin to the zaith'isk; he took the memories and story of Emps life and put it in a paperweight. Also it still acts as a battery that can be used up in spells and crafting later on.
 
"Of course they did. Tell me, was it permanent? How did she go? Screaming?" Minthara's eagerness turns your stomach ever so slightly.

Surprise surprise, the drow noble is enthused by violent murder of an enemy.

"I wonder- what place does it hold on the cosmic wheel? Nowhere near Mount Celestia, I'm sure. Elysium is quite out of the question as well. The Abyss, perhaps? Perhaps Pale Night felt generous and decided to sub-let." You cannot see his eyes, but his lips remain a firm line.

"Wh-what's it to you?" Gut struggles to hold onto some form of control of the situation. Helpless. Terrified. A bloodied rat before a prowling cat, toying with its prey.

Of course you don't have to come up with a coherent religious doctrine that fits into the cosmology when anyone of power in the cult is mind controlled.

"Chk." Lae'zel holsters her hammer. "Is that all?" She scowls in disgust. "Although the hunt was made easier by the bard." She acknowledges Alfira, who has slung her lyre across her back.

Recently started a new playthrough but don't want to get too far until patch 7 drops, given we've had hints with Alfira.

"Yeah. Cazador's pact is with Mephistopheles, not a cut-rate gelugon or pit fiend. Each of the Archdevils I know of has their own 'thing' - Mammon does economics, Glasya is a lawyer, Beelzebub engages in diplomacy. Mephistopheles' focus is research, primarily in hellfire. In a word, he's the hells' premier arcanist and foremost experimenter. Whatever is on offer will be big, unique, and tailored to his client. It will also cost them everything and then some."

Astarion hummed. "I wonder if it would be worth it."

"Doubtful. Aside from the material cost - the participants, willing or otherwise, of the ritual - there's also bound to be side effects. If it's on a metaphysical level, I fully expect some form of soul distortion."

Yeah, no solving this until act 3 and the Czarr palace.

I squinted. "Hm, no? That's the 'if you want to stay a vampire' option. The other is I use more of my stash of diamonds and just make you a normal elf via True Resurrection. It doesn't matter how long you've been one, it's a matter of consent and you'll not have to deal with the stings of vampire life anymore."

Astarion went still. His eyes widened. "That. It's been two hundred years. It's too late."

Yeah, the writers v obviously put his age in like that just so you wouldn't have players going 'oh, you can just cure the vampirism with that one spell' (even though you can't reach the required level in the game regardless)

"I was a monster." Your words are clipped, succinct. "I still am, from these… impulses. Dangerous to you all." You frown. "I lured people in. Had my way with them. Not sexually, at least."

A cold body-

"Or I could be wrong, and that butler was right about me and corpses."

Yeah the devs went full bore with Dark Urge playthroughs. Durge was a monster.

"Aside from having access to knowledge that the target had, I can use their souls to fuel spells I would normally need to sacrifice my own vitality for. Wish, Gate, Miracle, Permanency - each of these would require permanent sacrifices of strength. I could reclaim it, but using them would leave me diminished, even if slightly. Instead I can tap the souls I snare."

Pathfinder otoh making the v good decision imo that spells should never have xp costs.

"So. There are many paths to pseudo-immortality." I ran a hand through my hair, feeling my heart pick up speed. "Who… who knows what a 'Worm That Walks' is?"

It's telling that in Wrath of the Righteous that that is the one path where everyone abandons you.

"Who precisely is this 'Raphael' that he is of concern?" Minthara asked with a scowl.

"A two thousand year old by-blow of Mephistopheles," I grumbled.

For a cambion he has managed to do damned well for himself in that timespan. He's quite the threat, has permanent portals to everywhere of importance, contacts everywhere, and some potent resources. The main thing in his own way is his smug narcissism.

Mol peeked inside, and her visible eye widened. "Well, now. What's all of this?"

"Stealth. I blended invisibility, freedom of movement, and a muffling effect into the rings. A quick twist will turn them on and off for a speedy escape."

Could possibly avoid the Raphael deal, though not for definite, what with Mol being ambitious.

"Well… I was in the Archives for two thousand years. If you tell me your name, I can at least address you by it in private, assuming that's not part of the curse?"

"...'I shall rob you of your 'self', and deprive you of your allies past and present. You will wander a phantom, and I will have my Mother Superior be of better stock.' I have only faith in darkness, now. A heretic cleric, abandoned by all divinity but moving onward. My face, my voice, all taken and given to another. Even my name." She straightened her shoulders. "My trials, my triumphs, my wounds. None of it belongs to me anymore.

Well that's a very Sharran curse for sure.

Qudenos lumbered forth, the rest of the Githyanki patrol scrambling to give him space. "Torius Ancast. You are the same as when you laid us low." His voice was a low rumble, the echo of a mountain's innards. His head hung over us, our entire group well within range of his flames.

One of the strongest npcs that appears in the game! And one the game doesn't really let you fight.

"He is every inch her equal, if not superior. If she faced him alone, only her workings to his – he would survive. She may not."

Of course, not being an idiot, she wouldn't face him alone, but with an army of soul-eaten powerful veterans at minimum.

Gale jolts, clearly remembering something. "Ah! Volo was meant to meet us at camp, but we were in Torius' manor! I hope he's quite alright."

Ach, he'll be fine. Volo inexplicably surviving to be charming annoying later on is part of his archetype.

"And here we have an icon combining all three. And three Chosen for its cult – one for each of the Dead Three." Shadowheart met my eyes with dawning horror. "Oh hells."

Well they've partially figured out some of what is going on with the Absolute! No figuring out the big thing until they actually see the three Chosen with the brain and the Crown down under the colony though. Imagine that will rattle Torius somewhat. Though not as much as the brain having evolved.

Creccoth glanced at me, but I focused on Lae'zel. Detect Magic was slower to grasp psionics, but if I focused enough…

Ah. Ah. I saw it.

I grit my teeth. "No."

"What?" The scientist looked at me in confusion.

"LAE'ZEL! IT'S NOT REMOVING THE PARASITE, IT'S TAKING EVERYTHING ELSE! I CAN SEE IT! GET OUT OF THERE!" I roared, stepping forward.

Githyanki footsoldiers can always be replaced after all. Why try and do the impossible and expensive and remove the parasite, rather than just get an intelligence report?

Githyanki struggled against intellect devourers, fighting with hands and feet against the little monsters. I didn't see any mind flayers, but if these were here then it was all but certain there was at least one.

Mind Blank and True Sight meaning this plays out quite differently and we see Orpheus much earlier.

"So you see, I am an ally. By drawing on this power I stole from Vlaakith, I can protect you while permitting the cult to identify you as their own." The strange drow spreads her palms. "I will protect you as you embrace your poten-"

"HTAK'A!" Lae'zel falls on the stranger, maul leading her plummet. The lightning-wreathed metal impacts the drow's shoulder, and the illusion shatters.

The mind flayer stares back as it reels, pink eyes wide and clutching a shoulder dripping silver.

Ah, Emperor split the party to try and make a play. Only Torius has True Sight, so whilst the others cannot be controlled, non-psychic illusions will work just fine.

"No. Mindflayers lie. It's what they do." Torius raises his sword, head glowing a faint green from his circlet. "They lie, manipulate, omit. Enthrall. The only beings they see as equal are other illithids."

I am approaching you openly, as an equal. Do not do this.

The Emperor is so damned well written as a manipulator. A lot of the playerbase have fallen for his lies as well! You can only see the truth behind what he says across multiple playthoughs where his different responses expose how he will say whatever he thinks will produce his desired result. Plus his turning on a dime to side with the Netherbrain the instant his power through Orpheus is lost.

He was so very tired of being the villain. He had no desire to be a hero. He simply wished to perform his duties in peace.

Wants to be more like Pharasma eh? Would be quite the improvement on the current death system.

"You'll see! From a safe distance." Torius' expression takes on that same vicious cast as when he slaughtered the illithid who dared to try and deceive you all. "I promise, it will be quite the spectacle."

Tragically, this means that we don't get Astarion's hilarious reaction to being immolated by the sunlight trap.

"I found a tir'su slate I managed to translate with my enchantments. I'm getting the hang of the language." I waved the disc at her. "Sounds like Gith got traded by Vlaakith the original for the red dragon contract. Which given the latest one is a millennium lich sounds part and parcel for the position."

I doubt the current Vlaakith even knows the truth of what happened with Tiamat, the contract, and Gith.

"I did what was asked of me." She stared straight ahead.

I nodded.

"I believed. I followed the scriptures. I was loyal, faithful. Every act was in accordance with the law. If I am to believe this… then… I have not sinned against Vlaakith. I was true."

I nodded again.

"If this is so, then perhaps… perhaps Vlaakith has sinned against me."

Lae'zel storyline so, so, damned good. Her value system was brutal, but had a kind of fairness to it, and when that promise was betrayed, and the proof repeatedly shoved in her face, then there were only two ways it could go. It's tragic that in the Vlaakith route ending you can see her performing the role, despite very clearly knowing on some level that it's all a lie. She can see the other 'ascended', and yet carries on anyway as if she can escape that fate by just following the rules as hard as possible.
 
He's rather sweet, isn't he? Utterly harmless, unless you decide to actively be an utter ass whilst in striking range."

On a less funny follow-up.

Halsin: [Looks at the devastation wrought upon the landscape with all the plants and animals destroyed by the Erupt spell] ...Yes. Truly the plants and animals of the land deserved this for their collaboration with the Githyanki. Perhaps we can bind their spirits as well as punishment.
 
Alright, look. Bringing up Halsin being rightfully angry is one thing, but I'd prefer if you'd stop putting words in his mouth that I'm certainly not going to use.

Torius is a 20 year old who was effectively frozen in time. In age terms he's a dumbass college student with divine power, and it shows.

In maturity terms? He had parents for eight years, then effectively went feral. All of his teen years he raised himself while being the librarian equivalent of Indiana Jones. Aylin was close enough to his age that she was a friend and not a mentor or parent. It's implied she tempered him, or he'd be a lot worse.

Torius continuously shows signs of stress and pain because he is traumatized. He's going to be careless, going to overreact, and when Shadowheart calls him a manchild she is justified.

Halsin will definitely let him know he's on thin ice, but he has enough life experience to know exactly what he's working with. If he can talk Oliver down after being a murderous undead shadow fey for a century, he can have enough compassion to balance his anger to sit Torius down and have a constructive discussion.

Unlike him snapping at Shadowheart in the Cursed Lands, Torius isn't intentionally going out of his way to be horrible in the face of tragedy. It might not be with kid gloves, but Halsin is capable of handling this without sending the overpowered trauma victim into a mental spiral that could and would take the surrounding area with him.
 
Alright, look. Bringing up Halsin being rightfully angry is one thing, but I'd prefer if you'd stop putting words in his mouth that I'm certainly not going to use.

I never thought he would use that in-universe. But I had thought about Astarion's line about him being utterly harmless unless you deserve it, and I would think Halsin would see what Torius did and highly disagree.
 
I never thought he would use that in-universe. But I had thought about Astarion's line about him being utterly harmless unless you deserve it, and I would think Halsin would see what Torius did and highly disagree.

Well, yes. Because it's Astarion saying it and he's going to seduce the hell out of that twink to stay out of the blast radius. In his view Torius is a perfectly lovely person and has done nothing wrong ever.

Act 1 Astarion should be approximately no one's moral yardstick.
 
Asterion's primary priority is getting the living WMD between him and Cazador.

Can't blame him but he's not going to do anything that might jeopardize that.
 
Yeah, Asterion only truly felt even a smidgen of remorse when he was confronted by exactly what his actions in the name of cazador(not starving and punishing him) led to.
 
Yeah, Asterion only truly felt even a smidgen of remorse when he was confronted by exactly what his actions in the name of cazador(not starving and punishing him) led to.
Well, yes. Because it's Astarion saying it and he's going to seduce the hell out of that twink to stay out of the blast radius. In his view Torius is a perfectly lovely person and has done nothing wrong ever.

Act 1 Astarion should be approximately no one's moral yardstick.
It's almost as if their relationship might not be entirely healthy!
 
I have my laptop so I can be a bit more comprehensive in replies!

Surprise surprise, the drow noble is enthused by violent murder of an enemy.

I have an image in my head of Minthara and Lae'zel being the devil on Torius' shoulder while Wyll, Halsin, and Jaheira compete to be the angel. (Somehow Creccoth is in the lead without trying. Fear the power of Dargon Tiddie.)

Yeah, no solving this until act 3 and the Czarr palace.

Raphael will of course have his day in Act 2, and this will tip Torius' reaction from 'no' to 'FUCK no'. Act 3 quest will be interesting because Astarion will probably still want the ritual, but after seeing just what Torius can do he might listen to the alternative he cooks up before they fight Cazador. It'll require seeing what's under the palace, but there's a chance.

Yeah, the writers v obviously put his age in like that just so you wouldn't have players going 'oh, you can just cure the vampirism with that one spell' (even though you can't reach the required level in the game regardless)

Yeah. Same reason you can't just hire Ommeluum to do the crystals and either need someone to SQUID or Gale to explode in an Orpheus run.
Its for ~tension~. Also, Gale has the scroll of said spell and that's probably another reason they need to set that.

Old Spell Supremacy GO.

Pathfinder otoh making the v good decision imo that spells should never have xp costs.

And then 5e comes along and instead of making the costs high to compensate for giving you reality-warping BS they just hard-limit you to one a day, max. Still not balanced.

It's telling that in Wrath of the Righteous that that is the one path where everyone abandons you.

Worm That Walks is horrifying in concept and execution. Putting someone else through that For Science is Tuesday in Magic Fascist Land. (This probably also applies to Thay from what I heard, to be honest.)

For a cambion he has managed to do damned well for himself in that timespan. He's quite the threat, has permanent portals to everywhere of importance, contacts everywhere, and some potent resources. The main thing in his own way is his smug narcissism.

Is this true? Yes. Will Torius ever admit it? No. Will it stop him from queuing up that one song from the opening of 'Legally Blonde' and going on a joyride through the House of Hope speedrunning the death of Raphael's actually loyal servants, jailbreaking the prisoner, and stealing everything nailed down or not? Also no.

Could possibly avoid the Raphael deal, though not for definite, what with Mol being ambitious.

I had Torius engage with Mol for a reason. That reason will be made clear through Act 2.

Well that's a very Sharran curse for sure.

Don't worry Viconia, you'll get your good looks back! Even if someone has to rip that faker's face off! (Note: I do not intend for that to be the solution at this time.)

Of course, not being an idiot, she wouldn't face him alone, but with an army of soul-eaten powerful veterans at minimum.

Exactly. Especially after it's stated she knows who he is and is already nervous when she is about to send him into the prism. Him teaming up with Orpheus is her Nightmare Scenario and she just made it happen because her options were limited.

Ach, he'll be fine. Volo inexplicably surviving to be charming annoying later on is part of his archetype.

Like he just doesn't have anything to do? If I add him to camp when I already have plans for at least one other extra party member that's just begging for Cast Bloat. At least pre-Act 3. Volo can't fight and I made Alfira semi-competent so he can't bard that way, any lore he can offer can immediately be trumped by Halsin, Godless, Gale, or Torius, and I have Astarion and Torius to bully for fun.

Well they've partially figured out some of what is going on with the Absolute! No figuring out the big thing until they actually see the three Chosen with the brain and the Crown down under the colony though. Imagine that will rattle Torius somewhat. Though not as much as the brain having evolved.

And they know all this before meeting Florrick in Last Light, too.

Mind Blank and True Sight meaning this plays out quite differently and we see Orpheus much earlier.

Ah, Emperor split the party to try and make a play. Only Torius has True Sight, so whilst the others cannot be controlled, non-psychic illusions will work just fine.

The Emperor is so damned well written as a manipulator. A lot of the playerbase have fallen for his lies as well! You can only see the truth behind what he says across multiple playthoughs where his different responses expose how he will say whatever he thinks will produce his desired result. Plus his turning on a dime to side with the Netherbrain the instant his power through Orpheus is lost.

And all of this is why it played out the way it did. Torius spent almost two thousand years as a semi well-kept prisoner, so of course he's going to empathize with Orpheus. Even at his angriest, Orpheus is still genteel and straightforward, and those are qualities Torius really appreciates. Emps trying to be a snake oil salesman reminds him of home in all the worst ways. Behold: a Trauma Survivor reacting in a semi-realistic manner! (Disclaimer: Most Trauma Survivors will not freeze people acting like part of their abusive environment or stick their souls in a paperweight. Torius is SpecialTM.)

Wants to be more like Pharasma eh? Would be quite the improvement on the current death system.

Behold, Withers' goal in the long game with taking Torius. Have one worshipper for over a thousand years, have them shape an idea of you in their head, and let yourself be modified according to that idea. Be the exhausted social worker you were always meant to be.

Tragically, this means that we don't get Astarion's hilarious reaction to being immolated by the sunlight trap.

True. I've been very nice to him this whole fic. I need to bully him to compensate. Can't let Torius have all the fun. ...where though, is the question...

Lae'zel storyline so, so, damned good. Her value system was brutal, but had a kind of fairness to it, and when that promise was betrayed, and the proof repeatedly shoved in her face, then there were only two ways it could go. It's tragic that in the Vlaakith route ending you can see her performing the role, despite very clearly knowing on some level that it's all a lie. She can see the other 'ascended', and yet carries on anyway as if she can escape that fate by just following the rules as hard as possible.

And I could not let her go down the Vlaakith path, especially not in a 'fix fic'. Also now Orpheus has a chance to show his chops, even if he's stuck in the magic spiky d20. Actually earn her fealty, rather than just get it as an alternative to Vlaakith.

It's almost as if their relationship might not be entirely healthy!

Remember when Astarion has a mini episode in the tub with Torius at the idea of everything on offer for mostly free? Normally he wouldn't care about taking advantage of people. Torius reminds him of the one he let get away and got locked in a coffin for a year for. Torius has super powers. He has Feelings and does not know how to deal with them.

The healthiest relationship Torius has is with Creccoth because he's willing to set boundaries and give him some modicum of guidance.

Wyll infantilizes him, Gale thinks he's more adult than he is, Karlach does not have the tools or awareness to help. Minthara still lionizes him. Shadowheart has a good picture of who he is, but thanks to the Sharran-ing she can't/doesn't do much with it. Halsin is still new enough and observing, and picking up on things. Lae'zel is Lae'zel, and Alfira is along for the ride/just happy to be here and not dead.

When I say Astarion inserted himself in there and accidentally an OT3, I mean it. Both he and Torius are incredibly dependent on Creccoth, and that only works because the man got his brain scooped out by a spoon dagger so he got a hard reset from MurderBonersRUs. I repeat: of this trio, the emotionally competent one is the Super-Bhaalspawn.
 
Remember when Astarion has a mini episode in the tub with Torius at the idea of everything on offer for mostly free? Normally he wouldn't care about taking advantage of people. Torius reminds him of the one he let get away and got locked in a coffin for a year for. Torius has super powers. He has Feelings and does not know how to deal with them.

The healthiest relationship Torius has is with Creccoth because he's willing to set boundaries and give him some modicum of guidance.

Wyll infantilizes him, Gale thinks he's more adult than he is, Karlach does not have the tools or awareness to help. Minthara still lionizes him. Shadowheart has a good picture of who he is, but thanks to the Sharran-ing she can't/doesn't do much with it. Halsin is still new enough and observing, and picking up on things. Lae'zel is Lae'zel, and Alfira is along for the ride/just happy to be here and not dead.

When I say Astarion inserted himself in there and accidentally an OT3, I mean it. Both he and Torius are incredibly dependent on Creccoth, and that only works because the man got his brain scooped out by a spoon dagger so he got a hard reset from MurderBonersRUs. I repeat: of this trio, the emotionally competent one is the Super-Bhaalspawn.
Godless/Viconia is mentally casting him as Imoen equivalent isn't she?

Since Creccoth is CHARNAME?

Also she's probably not a picture of mental health herself, and would be a lot more of a mess if she couldn't use her excessive power level as a safety blanket I wager.
 
Volo can't fight and I made Alfira semi-competent so he can't bard that way, any lore he can offer can immediately be trumped by Halsin, Godless, Gale, or Torius, and I have Astarion and Torius to bully for fun.
Well, the thing is, Volo isn't a bard, canonically. He's a wizard who's cosplaying as a bard. Although, despite not being a bard, he's had relationships with the daughter of a Waterdhavian noble house, a steel dragon pretending to be a Waterdhavian merchant, and a yuan-ti priestess.

Volo's also one of Mystra's Weave Anchors, like Elminster, Halaster, Storm Silverhand, the Simbul, and Manshoon, although he's completely unaware of that fact. You'd think Volo would wonder why anti-magic fields and disjunction spells fail in his presence...
 
Godless/Viconia is mentally casting him as Imoen equivalent isn't she?

Since Creccoth is CHARNAME?

Also she's probably not a picture of mental health herself, and would be a lot more of a mess if she couldn't use her excessive power level as a safety blanket I wager.

I had to look her up, but honestly? Not far off. Though the romance angle does make for a large margin of difference.

And I did have her have a bit of a break during the post Goblin party - that was the most she emoted in the fic thus far. She simultaneously sees Torius as the strongest materially and the weakest in terms of composure. She could also handle things with him but she has no desire to play mummy dearest to a physically adult human male, regardless of how many biggatons he can fling around.
 
I have an image in my head of Minthara and Lae'zel being the devil on Torius' shoulder while Wyll, Halsin, and Jaheira compete to be the angel. (Somehow Creccoth is in the lead without trying. Fear the power of Dargon Tiddie.)

It's kind of funny to think about that Lae'zel would only be standing on the devil shoulder for Act 1, and on average, stand on the side of angels from act 2 onward.
 
Shadowheart's choice regarding Aylin... honestly, the hardest part here is having her make the choice without the influence of Torius, as in choosing to do the right thing because it's the right thing, instead of doing the right thing out of any measure of self-preservation. He has mentioned Aylin many times and should he conviniently be away from the party the moment Shadowheart has to make the choice, and they mention him or she does, the party will undoubtedly know who they're meeting. But if she turns away from Shar from her own will, and learns that the one she spared and freed was Torius' closest friend? Shadowheart will definitely get to his Top 2 of Best Girl Friend list, right below Aylin.
 
Shadowheart's choice regarding Aylin... honestly, the hardest part here is having her make the choice without the influence of Torius, as in choosing to do the right thing because it's the right thing, instead of doing the right thing out of any measure of self-preservation. He has mentioned Aylin many times and should he conviniently be away from the party the moment Shadowheart has to make the choice, and they mention him or she does, the party will undoubtedly know who they're meeting. But if she turns away from Shar from her own will, and learns that the one she spared and freed was Torius' closest friend? Shadowheart will definitely get to his Top 2 of Best Girl Friend list, right below Aylin.

This would be a harder choice if they weren't in the Shadowfell - where Shar's power is greatest. Torius managed to punk slap Lolth and run; in a protracted fight he'd be way worse off. And Lolth is way weaker than Shar.

Shar has a vested interest in Shadowheart making that choice herself too, so... I'd expect some interference.
 
Back
Top