Okay, this is my first attempt at doing something like this, so if I mess up in some way please...
User | Total |
---|---|
Juubi-K | 23 |
It's coming. Juubi just needs to post the prologue. It will comeWell... It sounds interesting, so watched for now, I guess?
One piece of advice I usually give in these situations, though. You only get one new thread alert, so make it a good one; there needs to be a hook in the first chapter. There also needs to be a first chapter, as most people won't hit 'watch' off promise alone.
...God damn it, Saitou.
You know he couldn't resist
This, very much.Right, okay, I've decided to read this since @Zaru mentioned it in his thread, so I can, at the very least, leave a comment. However, while the writing is good, I sincerely can't for the life of me tell what is the point of this prologue other than a rehash of canon. There's a different dialogue, a different narration, but ultimately there is little, if any, change to the plot-line of the original LN.
Admittedly, this is only the prologue, but as is established to be the rule of fictional written works, a prologue is a very important aspect that is supposed to grip your readers and make them willing to go along with the ride. In fanfiction, this means introducing the new idea, a plot-point, a change from canon, that is gonna be a staple in the chapters to come. And I honestly cannot see what it is from this prologue.
And I appreciate this, but... yeah. The majority of that prologue was unnecessary; really, it could probably have been cut down to a few paragraphs to establish where we were in the story before moving into the bit with Arysians.I suppose that's a fair point Since you mention it, I shall add something a little extra from the first chapter.
This, very much.
And I appreciate this, but... yeah. The majority of that prologue was unnecessary; really, it could probably have been cut down to a few paragraphs to establish where we were in the story before moving into the bit with Arysians.
That being said, I'm interested in where this is going.
Prologue has been fixed up. Or were you referring to the first half of the prologue? Hey, got to have some tidbit with the canon characters, and showing what's going on rather than telling I believe is stronger no?This, very much.
And I appreciate this, but... yeah. The majority of that prologue was unnecessary; really, it could probably have been cut down to a few paragraphs to establish where we were in the story before moving into the bit with Arysians.
That being said, I'm interested in where this is going.
Ahh, now that is better. Much better.
Also, if this Suleiman is an expy of Sulaiman/Sulayman (or Solomon, as people in the West know him), things are certainly gonna be interesting in the future. Oh fuck hell, I wanna some Djinn!
... Okay, let's break this down. I'm going to speak about this in relation to the anime, because I haven't read the light novels.Prologue has been fixed up. Or were you referring to the first half of the prologue? Hey, got to have some tidbit with the canon characters, and showing what's going on rather than telling I believe is stronger no?
Not... Okay. The problem here is that this addresses a very different topic than what I'm talking about.and showing what's going on rather than telling I believe is stronger no?
is inferior to
It's a prose issue: it is better to let your reader infer things about a character's mental and emotional state, or a situation, than to just flat-out tell them. It's about the difference between the characters communicating what's going on and the narrator/author doing so. Readers aren't geniuses--they can't magically intuit what's going on in your head--but they aren't idiots either.Harry stomped down the hall, muttering imprecations under his breath.
... Okay, let's break this down. I'm going to speak about this in relation to the anime, because I haven't read the light novels.
The prologue is 4,430 words long. Of that, 3,489 of them are devoted to covering material that everyone who has watched the anime already knows. I went back and rewatched the scene in question: 3,188 of those words are an almost direct translation of the fight, with some added time in Saito's head. The other 301 are the Tiffania scene, which is also covered in the anime. Seeing it from Saito's viewpoint is interesting, but nothing stuck out as particularly relevant to the story going forward. Seventy-nine percent of your prologue is telling us that we're at the point in canon where Saito meets and is healed by Tiffania, and that is all it's really communicating.
If there was something new here, well... Honestly, I'd probably still be complaining about the rehashing, unless the divergence happened early on, but it would be less of an issue, because at least then you would be setting us up for a "and instead of what you were expecting, this happened."
Not... Okay. The problem here is that this addresses a very different topic than what I'm talking about.
What I'm going on about? It's all structural. What do the first three-quarters of the prologue add to your story? If you take all of that away, what's missing? Can you convey the important parts more concisely, or in a better place? Because right now, as best as I can tell, you're starting your story with three-thousand plus words of "Previously, on Zero no Tsukaima: Futatsuki no Kishi..."
tl;dr: I'm not saying that your prose is bad. I'm saying that it appears to be unnecessary.
Mate, I am a big fan of Final Fantasy, and one of my most favorite summons (other than good ol' Bahamut) in that series is Ifrit, who is inspired from the Djinn in the legend of Sulayman (IIRC, anyway). I mean, how wicked it would be if they bring this guy:
To the world of Zero no Tsukaima?!
I admit, I have no idea what the crossover-elements are in this story, or who the non-FoZ characters are, etc. It'd be easier if it were made more clear. So far, I have no idea where this story is going, or even what its premise really is. It was beautifully written, but I'm still left with a giant question mark instead of a premise or an idea of what to expect.
There we go. Looks nice! Feel free to update the FF.net version with this prologue as well.I decided to rehash the prologue after all. I think this version is more concise, and gets both of the principal characters introduced. It also gave me an opportunity to go into how airships work; something I've been wondering about for a while. I don't remember finding any info on it in the Light Novels, aside from using windstones to levitate the ships.
I hope this will just about resolve this issue. I really want to get on to the first chapter.