Gentle Blade
Preview:
Charity knew she was dreaming.
It was a familiar dream, a scene her sleeping mind had showed her a hundred times, and would probably show her a million more. She recognised it at the first sight of pink and blue hair. Roughly dyed strands framing a face that was part Michael, and part her, and entirely her daughter's.
Just like every other time she'd seen it in her dreams, Charity savoured the sight of her daughter's face. The only time she could see her daughter as she had been, instead of staring into photographs of a younger girl and trying to find the woman that she had been growing into. Even if it meant driving the stab of guilt even deeper into her guts.
Molly had been beautiful. Perfect. Her little girl, face streaked with thick makeup ruined by her tears, piercings gleaming in a dozen places, and still smiling that same tremulous little smile. As unsure and hopeful as she had been when a fat fisted toddler handed Charity her very best drawing. As fragile as the girl, right on the cusp of womanhood, who had shown her mother an unexpected gift, vanishing and reappearing and never for a moment deserving…
She embraced the guilt. It was just, right, and proper. A mother who drove away her daughter for her own insecurities had no business searching for forgiveness, but Molly's hopeful little smile had offered it all the same.
Then it happened. She knew it would happen. She knew what came next in the dream, had known from the very first time she dreamt it.
Yet Charity still screamed. Still begged and pleaded and ached to throw herself to the ground to better accomplish the task...or at least avoid the sight that was coming.
It was a dream though. Just a dream, where she couldn't move, couldn't speak. All she could do was watch.
Watch the smile fall from her daughter's face.
Watch fear open her little girl's mouth, to free a scream that would never come.
Watch the jolt…and pick out, with perfect clarity, the moment that life faded from Molly's eyes.
Blood washed across Charity's body. Hot horror clinging to her skin, tainting her.
Molly's body fell away, crumpling to the floor as a dim and distant corner of Charity's mind screamed that it hadn't happened this way. She'd been knocked out when Molly died. She hadn't seen it happen.
But the words could not reach her. Reality had no hold on Charity Carpenter. Not when her daughters severed head hung in the air before her, hollow gaze fixed on her mother.
The mother that abandoned her.
The mother that failed her.
The mother that let her d-
Charity did not wake with a scream.
Just a sigh. Exhausted and sad, a breath away from weeping. She didn't allow herself the release of tears. She couldn't.
Harry was in his cot at the foot of the bed, sleeping peacefully, and she couldn't wake him. Though an absurd urge to do just that struck her when she patted Michael's side of the bed, finding it cold and empty and far too familiar for that.
Loneliness had lost its unfamiliar sting, but that didn't mean it had stopped hurting. It didn't make her long any less for a warm body against her, whether her husband's or one of her children, Charity longed for the comfort of her family.
A comfort she denied herself as coldly as she had the day before, and the day before that, and the day before that.
Her children were mourning their sister just as much as she was, Hope still woke herself up crying some nights, and Amanda would go off the moment she saw tears. As for Alicia and Matthew, her third and fourth children were both trying so hard to put a brave face on it all.
And Daniel…
Charity closed her eyes and put that problem aside. Out of them all, it was perhaps the only one that could truly wait until morning. In the meantime she had a task to attend to. A task that had her rising, plucking the baby monitor's receiver up from her nightstand, and creeping out into the hall.
The various doors to her children's rooms called to her, but she was a mother. It was her task, her duty, to comfort and protect her children. Not to seek comfort from them.
She'd already let her inner struggles poison her relationship with one of her children. A sin for which she could not imagine being forgiven, if she had ever wanted to be. Charity had no intention of making the same mistake twice. So she walked on past the doors, stopping only to listen at each one and reassure herself that the various Carpenter children were sleeping peacefully.
Soon enough she came to the stairs, and despite everything she felt a smile tweak the sad edges of her face. Michael's creaky masterpiece had been one of the first things he replaced when they moved in so many years ago, and each of his updates since had maintained the same pattern of creaks, though born out of skill rather than the inexperience that first created them.
There was a very specific sequence of steps that would get someone up and down without alerting everyone in the house, and...only Michael and her knew it now…
Her mirth slain, Charity picked her way down to the downstairs hallway and turned to enter the living room. Of course it was empty, clean and as tidy as it ever got with so many children to spill their toys over every inch of the place, but she hadn't expected to find Michael there.
Instead she headed for the basement door that he had hidden in the wood panelling of the walls, twisting a recessed handle and entering a far homier basement staircase than the barebones concrete and wood of most households. These steps not releasing a single sound as she descended into Michael's den.
Here, as she had every time she descended in recent months, Charity was struck by the transformation.
Once it had been a combination of the typical manly cave and something out of a middle earth comic book. Half leather armchairs and a pool table, half training mats and knightly accoutrements. With her workshop too distant, and the garage too accessible by the children, it had been here that Michael always stored his armour, his weapons, and the sword.
A part of Charity that she had kept mostly buried since becoming a mother, a side that she knew a certain vanished Wizard would have been shocked by, had always loved the wall of medieval weapons. Partially because of her pride as a smith, but mostly because it resembled one of her favourite album covers and she'd never been sure if Michael had built it that way on purpose or not.
Either way, it was gone now.
The walls had been stripped of weaponry, her lovingly crafted armoury piled in a corner instead, and in its place had grown a dense network of information. Like something out of a conspiracy film, her husband had even made use of different colours of string to denote connections between data points.
As meticulous and factually grounded as it all was, Charity had never been able to argue against it with any real strength. It was enough to make her long for her Michael's courageous idiot of a best friend, because the Wizard would surely have been able to mock Michael's wall of information in a way she simply couldn't bring herself to.
Just like she couldn't bring herself to look at a certain armchair. Not yet.
Instead she crossed the room to the pile of weapons and armour. Finding it neat and well kept and even freshly oiled. Charity still couldn't help the pang of resentment, of anger at how he was treating her gifts to him. Irrational as it was, when he was still caring for them as diligently as ever, more so even, now that he wasn't being called away and leaving the task to her for the duration.
A thought that called her attention assuredly to the bare concrete that had once been covered by training mats, the part of the room where she and Michael had danced together so many times, in so many ways.
Instead her eyes found concrete, with an ugly patch of far newer material at the centre. Michael's promise to blend the colours having slipped another day. Leaving it abundantly clear where he had gone at the floor with sledgehammer and pickaxe for the better part of two days, locking himself in the den while she had held her children and struggled through the organisation of a closed casket funeral.
The patch was a reminder of those days. Of what had been left beneath the weight of them, just as he had left something beneath the weight of fresh concrete.
It hurt to look at it. It hurt so much that she found the strength to look at her husband, escaping one pain for another.
The scattered paperwork he had buried himself in for most of the previous evening did not hold her attention long. The flourishing of his business ever since he had put down the sword did not bring Charity any particular feeling, for good or for ill.
Instead she looked straight to the rough beginnings of a beard that her husband had left unshaven for the third day running. Then to the shirt and sweatpants that failed to hide how his build was shifting, growing heavier, towards a state that most men his age would have considered incredibly healthy. Most.
Finally, with nothing left to distract her, Charity looked to the bottle still clutched loosely in his sleeping hand. The neck was hidden by his hand, the glass too dark to see whether it was empty or full, but when she peered closely, so closely her breath played across the fine hair at the back of his hand, Charity could see the seal at the top of the bottle of whiskey.
Unbroken.
She did not sigh. The kind of sigh she wanted to release would have woken him for sure, and Michael was already suffering enough without the kind of guilt he'd feel at being found in such a state.
Unbelievable Catholic that he was, her husband didn't need any more guilt, no matter how a tiny spiteful part of Charity wanted to add to his burdens.
She was the one who deserved to be punished. Not him.
They'd both abandoned their family, but he'd at least had a good reason for it, and he'd thought she would take care of them in his absence. That was what she was meant to do.
She was the failure. Selfish unworthy creature that she was, it was a wonder he hadn't cast her out already. She'd half expected him to: in the days after Molly's death; in the drive home from the funeral; in the early hours of morning after they'd finally gotten a houseful of weeping black clad children to go to sleep, when he'd asked her to meet him downstairs to talk about something important.
Charity had almost expected him to hit her. Perhaps she had wanted him to.
Instead he had embraced her, as good a man as he had ever been, and no less forgiving of all her many flaws.
Instead he had shown her where he had buried the sword, and began to speak of things that she couldn't argue with. Couldn't find her voice to deny.
Of guilt.
Of duty.
Of failure.
And of revenge…