I can't believe that Holly hasn't put two and two together, she's been consistently written as more intelligent and paranoid than canon, how is she missing this? If there was more time between the two connecting incidents I could believe it, but as written it seems she learned these two things back to back and still failed to make the connection. Pansy's activities should have either shown up a few chapters earlier or a few down the line.
 
Huh, Ron and Hermione aren't a couple or have romantic feelings for one another here; that's new. Or, uh, Hermione doesn't for Ron, at least.

Also surprised to see Hermione's folks attacked. Guess Voldemort knows who Harry's friends are here and actively went after them, whereas I don't recall that as a thing in canon? The Weasley's got attacked, but that wasn't a Harry target in particular iirc.
TBH all we really know is that Ron thinks Hermione doesn't have romantic feelings for Ron. He could be wrong, for all we know. Holly pays a lot more attention to things around her than Book!Harry did, but people still hide feelings particularly if they think they're unrequited. Which would be a good - well, understandable - reason for Ron to have a visceral reaction to going on a fake date with Hermione - he might be worried he'd forget it was fake, or it might dig into a sore spot.

As for Voldemort going after Hermione, we have three possibilities. Possibility A: Locket Tom is in Draco's body, amd spent a bunch of time at Hogwarts, and knows Hermione. He might have gone after her because he knows she's a threat, or petty vengeance. Possibility B: Gilderoy Lockheart just joined the Death Eaters. He has a serious bone to pick with Holly and her friends, which would make this more petty vengeance. Possibility C: Ritual Voldemort has magic that lets him turn wizards and witches into loyal spellcasting weapons, and has doubled down on his anti-Muggleborn stance. Hermione is Muggleborn. This could have been him "recruiting." Or he could just be more active because he's got a lot more expendable pawns.

One last bit to consider: in the books, Umbridge is at Hogwarts because the Ministry wanted to keep Harry from talking about how Voldemort was back. Here? Everyone knows Voldemort is back. Here, Umbridge is at Hogwarts to make Scrimgeour look like he's doing something about Voldemort. Even when he's only making things worse.
 
Really nice updates, Tekomandor! I look forward to seeing whether Holly deems Grimmald as a base of operations for DA should she continue to be under lockdown for long.
 
Year Five, Chapter Thirty Three
Year Five, Chapter Thirty Three

Crookshanks, who had escaped the attack on Hermione's house in her enchanted bag, woke Holly on Christmas morning. She waited, bleary-eyed and hungry, to use the bathroom nearest to her room - a strange experience when she compared it to living at Grimmauld Place before it became Headquarters. That had just been her, Sirius, and Remus - three misfits living it up in a barely habitable warren.

She knew Sirius had hated it, and still did a little, but she had loved having such an obviously wizarding house to herself. It hadn't mattered to her that the wallpaper had faded or that half of the dozen bathrooms were uninhabitable due to extreme doxy infestations. Now all the wallpaper had been repaired or replaced, and there wasn't so much as a whiff of dark magic.

Grimmauld Place was still a dreary, dark house - lit by too-dim lamps and brief shafts of sunlight from tall, narrow windows. Most of the windows looked out onto alleys or the sides of buildings, but the huge window in Holly's room looked out onto London and would have cost a truly immense number of pounds all on its own on the muggle real estate market.

Sirius had gone slightly mad with the Christmas decorations, seemingly determined to beat back the grim news from the outside world with enough tinsel to decorate a house ten times the size of Grimmauld Place. Animated ornaments flitted this way and that all over the house, and overnight the dining room had gained a huge tree. The whole house smelt of fresh pine.

Everyone gathered in the house's largest room, the formal dining room. The table had been put to the side of the room and the chairs stacked, and a massive pile of wrapped presents surrounded the tree. Nothing had happened for a few days now, though Holly knew everyone was nervous about some kind of large-scale attack on Christmas day.

It was an odd collection of people who were clustered around the tree that Christmas morning - Holly, Sirius and Remus, were there of course, along with all of the Weasleys and the Grangers. Tonks and her friend Maya were there, both of them looking exhausted after a long guard shift last night, as well as her parents - Andromeda and Ted Tonks. They were Sirius' last remaining relatives who weren't evil, and it was a little uncanny for Holly to stand so close to someone who looked like a combination of Narcissa Malfoy and Bellatrix Lestrange.

It was, at first, a little awkward but then Dobby started apparating around the room, handing out his gifts; and nobody could really withstand his Christmas cheer. Fred and George led a round of poorly sung carols, and Holly had great fun giving out her gifts. Hermione was nearly in tears, but she was smiling and hugging anyone who got near her. Mr Weasley beamed with delight as Holly handed him a battery-powered muggle radio.

"This is for you," Ginny said, nervously handing Holly a box covered in inexpertly wrapped wrapping paper. Inside was a thin bracelet with a tiny etching of a snake's head on it. As Holly examined it closely, she could see the many tiny runes etched into it. She didn't know what it did, but it looked like an incredibly complicated enchantment.

"Did you make this, Ginny? It's incredible," Holly said, smiling at her girlfriend.

"I had to ask Hermione for help a couple of times," she said, as she showed Holly a matching bracelet on her own wrist. She hissed into it, softly, and Holly heard the quiet hissing echoing from her own bracelet.

"How does it work?"

"You, um, have to tell it to send a message first, and then you say what you want to say. Like this," Ginny said and held up her bracelet to her mouth.

"Your dress looks cute," Ginny hissed in parseltongue. Holly grinned and kissed her on the lips, and then the two of them fell off the couch to a chorus of laughter and only mildly disapproving looks.

The vague sense of order Mrs Weasley and Sirius - having formed some kind of unholy alliance for the day - had managed to impose soon broke down into a whirlwind of bad signing and gift-giving, and Holly could do nothing but smile.

She was soon roped into helping Mrs Weasley and Dobby with Christmas lunch. However, Holly thought her mastery of household charms was clearly lacking - Mrs Weasley and Dobby could control a half dozen knives like a conductor controlling a symphony. In contrast, Holly was still stuck chopping things up by hand. It was a very ordinary sort of magic, but Holly knew how hard animating charms were - to control a half dozen of them at once to so fine a standard was an outstanding piece of magic.

The wizarding wireless sat resolutely off, though Holly knew that someone was upstairs waiting for any reports. Despite the good cheer of the day, there was still an undercurrent of tension running through the house - had Voldemort only backed off for a few days, or was he lying in wait until he could retrieve the complete prophecy?

In the end, there was no great Christmas day attack or even a small Christmas day skirmish. Holly still woke the next day with a feeling of cold dread in her stomach. Her conversation with Dumbledore today was a long time coming, and Holly knew deep down that once she stepped through the fireplace to Hogwarts she would not be able to take it back.

She had worked out that Dumbledore did not want to tell her the truth about whatever Horcruxes were long ago, that there was some secret more awful than Voldemort's immortality. She could hear the whispers, now, promising to tell her the truth. Promising to reveal the secrets others would keep from her.

Holly looked down at the bracelet around her wrist, the faint etching of the snake seeming to move in the half-light seeping past the drawn curtains of her bedroom window. It felt warm around her wrist, the faint trace of magic already a comforting sensation. She looked over to Ginny, still sleeping in her camp bed across from Holly. Her girlfriend's hair was a mess, splayed across her freckled face in bright-red strands.

Holly's hands were still, despite the dread seeping into her. Despite the nightmare she had just left behind, despite the sweat still clinging to her brow. She looked into the carving of the snake, looked at the dozens of tiny runes that linked it with its twin - that would carry her voice to Ginny over any distance.

She rose from her warm, comfortable bed before her courage could desert her. She was up and fully awake whilst most of the house was still asleep, and with only a quick word to Sirius she stepped through the fireplace to the Headmaster's office.

Dumbledore's office was the same as Holly remembered it. A constant out-of-tune symphony of ticking and hissing from a hundred different devices, Fawkes on his perch in the corner, a fire that always crackled just right. Despite the early hour, Dumbledore was sitting behind his desk and dressed as he usually was - in robes exploding with bizarre colours and patterns.

"Good morning, Miss Potter. I was not expecting you for some time, but if you are quite recovered from your Christmas celebrations..." Dumbledore said, and as he spoke he drew his wand and conjured a plush armchair opposite his desk.

"Better to have it over and done with it. Like ripping off a plaster," Holly said as she sunk into the armchair. Despite the warmth of the fire, she pulled her jumper tight around herself as she sat down.

"If only we could be done with this sordid business in one conversation. But I promised to tell you what I knew of Horcruxes, and the hour is late enough for it as it is. As ever regarding you, Miss Potter, my sentimentality has gotten the better of me," Dumbledore said.

"I know the diary was a Horcrux, and so was the locket - the Riddle in the DIary told me he was a memory. But he could cast spells, do magic, even before he had a body. A memory can't do that," Holly said.

"Indeed. No mere memory could have forced its will upon Ginny Weasley, nor cast magic of its own. No mere memory could return itself to life by taking the body of another. What did the Riddle you faced in the chamber possess beyond memory, beyond an imprint of personality like a ghost or a portrait?" Dumbledore asked her, his expression unreadable. Holly's mind raced down the path his question had laid out, and she felt dryness in her mouth; felt her heart beat each slow, deliberate beat like a crash of thunder.

"He could cast magic of his own - real magic that had nothing to do with the diary... and he could change. He changed his mind about his plan to kill all the muggleborns. He could learn. He was... was like a person without a body," she said, and she knew what the answer must be then; though she could see no way for it to occur. How could a soul be in two places at once?

"The thing that separates such a creature from a ghost or a portrait is the presence of a soul, as I am sure you have realised. Now we are faced with a far more disturbing question - how is it that Lord Voldemort's soul was in multiple places at once?"

"It wasn't, was it? The Riddle in the diary was exactly as he was when he made it."

"No. That is the nature of a Horcrux. It contains a part of a soul, split apart from the rest. Whilst even the smallest portion of the soul remains intact, the creator of the Horcrux cannot truly die," Dumbledore said.

"Split apart... how?" Holly asked, her eyes wide. She felt her mind race, felt sick to her stomach as she began to see the puzzle pieces fit together.

"A ritual, the first component of which is murder. Premeditated, purposeful, murder. It is that act which rends the soul, and the ritual that bisects it. Then, using the life of the victim, the soul fragment is bound to an object of particular emotional or symbolic resonance. Thus the Horcrux is rendered nigh-indestructible, and the creator as close to immortal as any wizard has come," Dumbledore said.

"It's the stolen life that makes them... independent, isn't it sir?"

"Ah, I see you have spotted the flaw Voldemort is no doubt rueing at this moment. Yes, a Horcrux has some semblance of a life of its own, and more than one dark wizard or witch has met their downfall at the hands of their own Horcrux," Dumbledore said. Holly could hear the whispers between his words, in the wind rattling the windows and in the crackling of the fire. She tried to put them out of her mind.

"You said 'bisect' the soul, professor. But Voldemort has at least two Horcruxes. Does that mean that the locket Riddle is only a quarter of Voldemort's soul?" Holly asked.

Dumbledore nodded gravely.

"Does that... matter?" she asked him. It did not seem possible to her to split a soul in the first place - even cold-blooded murder, even the darkest magic did not seem capable of such a thing.

"It does. You saw for yourself how weak Voldemort's wraith was. Herpo the Foul, who most scholars believe invented the Horcrux, was said to be able to stride from one body to the next as if he was changing clothes. It does not make him any weaker once he has a body, however," Dumbledore said.

"So we just need to kill the second Riddle, and Voldemort will be mortal again?" Holly asked. It seemed too... neat to her. To easy.

"Ah, if only it were so. No - I suspect Voldemort has made more than two Horcruxes, potentially many more. He has always eschewed the soul for material power and considers his weakness as a wraith unimportant in comparison to a more secure immortality. Indeed, the piece of information I require from Professor Slughorn's memory is the number of Horcruxes Voldemort planned on making. My hope is that he has made three, my fear is seven, and I occasionally wake at night dreading thirteen. Though I do not think that last scenario is possible - the soul can only be divided so far if it is to anchor Voldemort to life," Dumbledore said.

"How much worse would seven be compared to three, sir?"

"If he has truly made three Horcruxes and no more, I believe the war may yet be ended before it can truly begin. Seven... seven would require extensive investigation. In many ways, the true number of Horcruxes made by Voldemort is our equivalent to the Prophecy - we must have it before we can truly commit to a strategy," Dumbledore said, and Holly nodded.

"I'll have it from Professor Slughorn when term resumes. I - I'll try talking to him when he's good and drunk, and I'll have it for you one way or the other," Holly said. She looked down at Dumbledore's desk for a moment, as if she found the grain of the wood fascinating.

"I would prefer Horace give up the memory willingly, but I am well aware you are a capable obliviator. If you think it would help, I enlist the aid of the house elves," Dumbledore said, and Holly blinked.

"That would be brilliant, professor. They'd have to be subtle about it, though," she replied.

"I shall not enlist Dobby, then. Regardless, I think it best if you take this with you when you return to Grimmauld Place," Dumbledore said, and removed a thin, leather-bound volume from a drawer of his desk. Holly took it carefully and examined the first page.

She shut it quickly and looked away, the moving sketch disgusting enough to make her grateful she had not yet eaten breakfast.

"I - Sir, I shouldn't have this. I've... I'm not sure I can be trusted with magic like this," Holly said, her voice hoarse and barely above a whisper as she put the book back down on his desk.

"None can be truly trusted with the dark arts. I trust in your nature. Whatever similarities you may have to a young Tom Riddle, whatever power he may have left you - these things cannot erase your choices. They cannot erase your selfless courage, your compassion - they cannot erase the girl who faced the Basilisk of Slytherin with a sword, who chose mercy for Peter Pettigrew," Dumbledore said, and as he spoke Fawkes let out a few strains of phoenix song. Holly felt the clammy cold gripping her disappear for just a moment, heard the whispers go silent.

"I'm not sure I made the right choice, sparing Pettigrew," Holly admitted, looking down at her hands. He had surely escaped Azkaban with the rest of the Death Eaters.

"Peter Pettigrew, I think, has a part to play in this yet. The power of a life debt is a deep, ancient magic - one we ignore at our peril. Whatever lies in his future, mercy does not spare only the receiver. Take the book, because there is every chance that this most vital task may be left to you alone. Take the book and know that you have more than earnt my trust," Dumbledore said, offering her the book once more.

Holly took the book in one unsteady hand and returned to Grimmauld Place through the fire.
 
Last edited:
Horcruxes don't protect against old age, but that doesn't really help when one of them is in a teenage body such as Draco's. Even if only the main body has to die of old age to drag the Horcruxes with it, that's still at least 40 years Voldemort and Dracomort have to take as many lives with them as they can.
 
That's Fanon, and very strange Fanon too.
Its Fanon based on assumptions. Look at Voldemort as Riddle, and then after killing the Potters. He's visibly aged (Even after becoming an noseless abomination after his resurrection). Hell just look at him while on Quirrell's head, he looks near identical after resurrecting, only losing his nose, so he likely actually looked like that before he died.
 
So long as the Ministry doesn't confiscate Ginny's gift to Holly (the item I feel being a madly inventive approach to running a bit of a gumshoe operation), this story is about to go places.
 
"I would prefer Horace give up the memory willingly, but I am well aware you are a capable obliviator. If you think it would help, I enlist the aid of the house elves," Dumbledore said, and Holly blinked.
Legilimens, I would assume? We've seen Holly mind-read for years now, but Obliviator would be memory-charming, and I don't remember seeing her do that at all.
 
Year Five, Chapter Thirty Four
Year Five, Chapter Thirty Four

Holly read the book Dumbledore had handed her - the book on Horcruxes and all other sorts of dark magic - only by moonlight when everyone else was asleep. There were simply too many other people at Number Twelve Grimmauld Place to hide what she was reading during the day, and if the roof at night was not the warmest place to read, it was at least private.

She could only stomach so much at a time - the pictures alone were enough to turn her stomach. Shifting, moving images of horror carved from demented strokes of a quill. Worse were the whispers, which told her all about whatever dark ritual she read about. Told her all the secrets to it, all the ways she could use such a ritual.

If Ginny and Hermione, who shared Holly's room when all three of them were at Headquarters, noticed Holly's midnight jaunts, they didn't confront her about them. None of them had time during the day for something like that, anyway. The whole house was always wound tight with tension, the wizard wireless droning from half a dozen rooms as everyone tried to busy themselves.

Holly led her friends in duelling practice, and a few of the Order members were game to try their luck between whatever missions they had been assigned by Dumbledore. Holly found out that Mrs Weasley was actually a ferocious duellist, slinging hexes with the speed and precision of formal training - only she mixed up the very recognisable style with conjuring and animation charms.

Ron, who seemed to have been holding back against his mother in the opening moments of the duel, had to admit defeat after he was chased all around the duelling room by a cloud of conjured meat cleavers. He had blasted a half dozen away with each curse, but Mrs Weasley would have already conjured and animated a dozen more.

"Your mum's kind of a badass, Ginny," Holly said.

"Where do you think I get it from?" she said with a smirk.

The first loss was reported a day after Boxing Day. Hestia Jones had been killed at her home just before she was due to take a shift serving as a lookout at the Department of Mysteries. There had been no Dark Mark, but the Hit Wizards had arrived to find her dead of a Killing Curse and signs of a significant battle.

All the older Order members - those who had fought in the First War - told stories about her late into the evening. Tonks sat at the long dinner table with a haunted look in her eyes, their usual neon-bright colour fading to a dull black. Mad-Eye said something to her quietly, his words too low for Holly to hear, and then he offered Tonk's something strong enough Holly could definitely smell it from the other end of the table.

Soon enough the Christmas break was over, and Holly found herself at the centre of another tense convoy of enchanted cars heading towards King's Cross. These weren't the sleek Ministry cars she had seen before, though. They were a mishmash of second-hand muggle vehicles that seemed to have been selected for their utterly ordinary appearance.

"Enchanted them myself, after the unpleasantness between the Minister and Dumbledore. Not, ah, technically legal - but so long as I don't ask myself any questions, nobody will take any issue with it," Mr Weasley said, and Holly found she could still laugh after all.

King's Cross was even more fortified than the last time Holly had been here, with teams of barely disguised Hit-Wizards standing menacingly around the muggle portion of the station alongside dozens of muggle police officers. All of them carried guns, and Holly saw a lot of nervous glances on the faces of the muggles passing through the station.

She occasionally wondered what the Ministry used as a cover story for them, or what orders the muggle government had given them. Shoot anyone in a skull mask?

Holly rubbed the enchanted wand holster hidden up her sleeve as she pushed her cart through the station. Dumbledore thought that once they'd gotten to the station itself, they would be safe enough - Voldemort wasn't likely to make an attack this major before he retrieved the prophecy, especially if Holly was going to be there.

It didn't make her any less nervous, or any less inclined to seek the comforting warmth of her wand against her arm.

The train ride back to Hogwarts was unusually quiet and grim, the Azkaban breakout casting a pall over everyone but a few of the more odious Slytherins. Pansy Parkinson practically strutted past Holly's compartment, followed by a half dozen pureblood hangers-on.

"It's started," Hermione said as she watched them walk past.

"What?" Ron said, looking up from his chess game with Luna Lovegood. Luna was one of the few people in the school who could match Ron. She didn't have his technical mastery, nor his uncanny ability to see a dozen moves ahead, but her strategies were so unorthodox that they forced even Ron to think on his feet rather than use his massive mental stockpile of openings and gambits.

"They're choosing sides. Making sure everyone knows they supported Voldemort, without doing anything that could land them in legal trouble," Hermione said.

"Well, if Pansy Parkinson is all he can get to lead his Junior Death Eaters, it's probably a good sign," Holly said.

"Enough about Pansy bloody Parkinson. Who're you taking to Slughorn's party, Hermione?" Ginny asked. Hermione flushed a deep red and it took a moment of flustered sputtering before she was coherent enough to answer.
"I - um, that is, I asked Micheal Corner from the DA by owl," Hermione said.

"Oooh, he's fit. I didn't know the two of you got along," Ginny said. Ron looked faintly disgusted at the idea.

"He's in my arithmancy study group," Hermione said, defensively.

"Oh do stop gagging, Ronald. He's not that bad," Ginny said. She rolled her eyes at her brother as she spoke, and Holly found it incredibly cute.

"I don't find Hermione taking a date to Slughorn's shitty party gag-worthy. I bloody told her to, if you'll remember. What I object to is Micheal Corner, who's a right wanker and has always been one," Ron said, putting Luna into checkmate. His tiny black knight physically leapt up into the air and smashed down onto Luna's king, like one of Dudley's video games.

"I've never really had much interaction with him, but I suppose he does have high levels of wrackspurts," she said, resetting the enchanted chessboard with a tap of her wand.

"I'm sure it'll be fine," Holly said, though she knew she sounded as uncertain as she felt.

The mood in the compartment slowly backed away from the edge of the argument it had been teetering over, though Holly could tell there was a note of tension all the way to school.

By the time the train pulled up at Hogsmeade station, it was already dark - six o'clock by the station clock. Watches were never very reliable on the train, which Holly thought was probably part of the complex unplottable charms that protected Hogwarts' location from mapping. It was a surprisingly common topic of academic conversation because it made Britain's ley lines uniquely difficult to track.

It was also, of course, raining and so Holly rushed to a carriage; holding her wand aloft with a shield charm acting as an improvised umbrella. She had Slughorn's party to attend instead of dinner, and this one would require fancier dress than usual. She definitely didn't want to get rained on.

Holly had outgrown her dress robes from last year, but as she only had the one set and couldn't exactly go out and shop for more, Mrs Weasly had kindly shown her how to tailor them with magic. Magical tailoring could accomplish far more than the muggle equivalent, using spells to do a day's mundane tailoring in an instant - and without needing any extra cloth.

Walking through the halls in her dress robes, hand in hand with Ginny, while they were so empty was on odd experience. Everyone else was at dinner, giving the still well-lit halls an eerie quality, but soon Holly and Ginny met up with other members of the Slug Club. Hermione and her date, Micheal Corner, were the first pair they encountered.

Regrettably, the next pair was Cormac McLaggen and a seventh-year Hufflepuff Holly didn't know. From the vaguely disgusted looks she gave Holly and Hermione, Holly guessed she was another stuck-up pureblood.

"Wow, he's found a date as unpleasant as he is," Holly whispered to Ginny, who tried very hard not to giggle and failed.

Slughorn's office had been transformed as usual, changing the spacious office into a much longer dining room. The huge hardwood dining table was intricately carved, and the purple tablecloth seemed to shimmer in the light descending from the massive golden chandelier overhead. Pipe smoke wafted from one corner, whilst from another came the soft sounds of mandolins accompanying a gentle voice. The extension charm was, to Holly's eyes, beautiful - far more so than the expensive decorations. To work such magic, especially in only one dimension, on a building as magical as Hogwarts would have required the most delicate of touches.

"Miss Potter, Holly my dear - I've someone I'd like to introduce you to!" Slughorn said, raising his voice slightly to be heard over the mass of people in attendance, very few of whom Holly recognised. She silently cursed her short height as she and Ginny made their way through the press of people towards Slughorn.

He was standing next to a pair of men, who seemed almost designed as a contrast. One was the epitome of tall, dark, and handsome whilst the other was portly, middle-aged, and possessed of a truly unfortunate set of mutton chops. The handsome man had several girls - and an adult witch or two - standing around him; all trying to catch his attention.

"Hello, Professor. Thank you for inviting me," Holly said.

"Not a chance I'd let you miss this, my dear. Not a chance. This is my friend Eldred Worple, author of Blood Brothers: My Life with the Vampires. A bestseller in twenty-seven countries now, was it?"

"Thirty-one, as of the last count. A pleasure to meet you, Miss Potter, a real pleasure - and your lovely date, of course. This is Sanguini, my friend whose story comprises much of the book," Worple said, his voice aristocratic and slightly slurred - from alcohol if the redness in his cheeks was any indication.

"It is my most exciting to meet you, Miss Potter," Sanguini said, giving Holly a short bow.

"This is Ginny Weasley, my girlfriend," Holly said, and she tried not to grin when she saw Ginny looking at Sanguini too. He really was extremely good-looking, with features so defined that they appeared to have been chiselled from stone.

"Ah, I thought I recognised you, Miss Weasley - I believe I've met your father a few times. I must say, Miss Potter - I really am delighted to see you. Why, I was just saying to Horace that I simply can't believe no one has written the Holly Potter biography yet!" Worple said.

"You were?"

"So modest! But seriously, my dear, I am simply craving to write it myself. A few four or five-hour sessions - say over a month - and the two of us could be positively drowning in galleons."

"It's really quite a painless process, Miss Potter," Sanguini said. He flashed her a smile, and Holly saw his elongated - and very, very white - canines.

"I'm... I'm sure. So nice to meet you, but I think I see a friend over there," Holly said. She felt her cheeks flush and made her escape with Ginny into the crowd. Just before she lost sight of Professor Slughorn she saw a House Elf silently appear and refill his drink. The elf gave Holly a wink and disappeared without a sound.

Holly had to dodge several other conversations along the same lines as the party went on, while she waited for her opportunity. She couldn't exactly ransack Slughorn's mind in the middle of the party - she needed to get him somewhere where they wouldn't be seen. Her plan rested in a special commission from the Weasly twins - the active ingredient in a Puking Pastille, ground to a very fine powder and absent any colourings or flavourings (the actual Skiving Snackbox had a surprisingly pleasant mango flavour).

Her opportunity came halfway through the party, though she winced when she realised which couple was shouting at each other.

"All I said was-" Micheal Corner said, his hands raised.

"All you said was a crock of blood supremacist shit!" Hermione shouted.

Holly made her move, slipping the powder into Slughorn's drink as he turned to look at the argument.

"All I said was Muggleborns need to better respect Wizarding culture!" he shouted back.

"Oh, like that's not the first line out of every blood supremacist's mouth whenever they're called out for their bigotry."

"My bigotry? You were the one who denigrated wizarding traditions first. If you like muggles so much, go live with them!" Micheal shouted. Hermione withdrew his wand and made to hex him, but he had his wand out in time to deflect it into the ceiling.

Before they could hex one another, Slughorn began violently vomiting. Sick spewed all over Mrs Zabini's expensive gown, and one gnarled warlock slipped as he tried to get out of the way.

"I think Professor Slughorn has had a bit too much fun tonight. I'll get him to the hospital wing," Holly said as she guided Slughorn out of the office whilst attempting to avoid being vomited on.

"Thank... thank you, my dear," Slughorn said as they left his office.

"Not a problem, sir," Holly said.

She was about to make her move, but the sound of some truly awful singing stopped her. She rounded the next corner and saw Ron and Luna sitting on a small raised balcony. With the extension charm, they could actually see into Slughorn's office through a small window from the balcony. A bottle of something rainbow-hued and strong lay half-drunk between them.

"MICHEAL CORNER'S A GIT!"

"I HOPE HE GETS BIT!"

"ON HIS - oh, hello Holly," Luna said, her words sounding only slightly slurred.

"What are you two doing?" Holly asked.

"Having a better time than you, mate," Ron said, as he drank some more of the rainbow-hued alcohol (Dirgibile Plum Gin, according to the label).

"Can't argue with you there," Holly said.

"I - I think I should... take points?" Slughorn said, but he was so drunk from the constant top-offs and so out of sorts from the snackbox powder that it came out more like a question.

"Not to worry sir, there's a prefect here," Holly said.

"Yes? Yes! Do... do... do handle this, Mr Weatherby," Slughorn said, and then he vomited a little on Ron's shoe.

"Let's keep going, sir," Holly said, whilst Ron and Luna cackled behind her.

After they'd made it a decent distance, Holly looked around a final time, judged they were alone, and silently withdrew her wand from the long sleeves of her dress robes. Her body bind curse hit Slughorn in the back, snapping his arms to his side and preventing him from doing anything more than moving his eyes around. Holly caught him as he fell, laying the portly Professor down inside a classroom with significant effort.

"I really am sorry about this, Professor," Holly said as she fed him the antidote to the Puking Pastille, so he wouldn't choke on his own vomit, and then she set to work. Slughorn's eyes were darting around wildly, but Holly knew her curse would hold.

She placed her wand to Slughorn's temple, and as her eyes caught his for a moment she extended a probe to examine his mental defences. Strong. Much too strong for even Dumbledore to fish the real memory of Slughorn's conversation with Tom Riddle about Horcruxes from his mind with but a glance.

Nowhere near strong enough to stop Holly with a wand to his head and all the time in the world.

"Legilimens," she whispered and threw her full might into the mental attack. Slughorn was a master Occlumens, better than Holly was at Legillimancy, but he was also extremely drunk. In less than a minute, she had seen through all seven of his fake copies and found the real memory.

She withdrew a glass vial from her robes and then, with a twist of her wand, she withdrew a copy of the real memory from Slughorn's mind. He fought her - even then - but the strand of silverly light took only moments to transfer to the vial, which she stoppered with a special stopper of alchemical silver.

"Obliviate," Holly said, her voice calm and cold, and a grey light washed over Slughorn taking with it any memory he had of the encounter.
 
Holly's increasing ruthlessness feels empowering and earned, but it also feels quite sinister, well done. Also the little bit with Luna and Ron at the end was cute.
 
That's definitely one way to get the Horcrux memory from Slughorn, and I guess she doesn't much have time to win his trust like Harry. Wonder how Slughorn shall rationalise this? If he wakes up in the hospital wing and Holly only took the memory-extraction and stunning bits of memory, could be he'll just assume he drank too much and fainted partway to the nurse.
 
Is "Sanguini" someone from other HP media? Because if not I really need to congratulate you, that's a fantastic Rowling-brand name.
 
Year Five, Chapter Thirty-Five
Year Five, Chapter Thirty-Five

Tom Riddle was still as handsome and as cold as Holly remembered. He looked only a little younger than he had been in the Diary, and as he walked towards her - or rather right through her, the memory undisturbed by her presence - she felt a faint tremor in her wand hand. The memory of pain racing through her every nerve on the Chamber floor bubbled up in her mind. Dumbledore gave her a look of concern, but only for a moment. They couldn't be distracted from the contents of the memory.

"Sir, is it true Professor Merrythought is retiring?" Tom Riddle said, and Holly turned to look at the conversation. Professor Slughorn, his hair fair and belly not quite so portly, was sitting in an armchair in his old office. Pipe smoke wafted throughout the room, a glass of blood-dark wine in Slughorn's hand.

"If I knew I couldn't possibly say so one way or the other, my boy. Though I do find your network ever so impressive," Slughorn said.

"Thank you, sir," Tom replied. Holly had expected his smile not to reach his eyes, to be able to see the monster beneath the handsome facade now that she was expecting it. No matter how hard she looked, all she could see was genuine warmth and amusement on Riddle's face.

"Shall I pour you a glass - just the one - Tom?"

"That's very kind, sir, but I fear I have a transfiguration essay to write after our chat tonight."

"Well, you always were very responsible - it's why I appointed you as a Prefect, of course. Still, if you won't take a glass of this fine bordeaux, at least help yourself to a piece of that delicious candied pineapple you got me for Christmas."

Tom nodded and deftly picked up and ate a tiny bit of candied fruit. He sat in the seat across from Slughorn and his eyes seemed to dance in the light of the fire behind them both. He was handsome, she thought. She wondered why he had let himself become so hideous - so outwardly twisted. Tom Riddle's good looks had surely served him well back when he'd employed deceit and guile instead of brute force.

"If you keep slipping me that pineapple, my boy, you'll be the Minister for Magic in fifteen years, not twenty," Slughorn said as he chuckled at his own joke. His face was flushed from the wine and his eyes seemed slightly unfocused. Holly tried not to think about how similar her own approach to getting this memory had been,

"Minister? Thank you for the compliment, sir, but I've hardly the pedigree to attain such a post," Tom said.

"Nonsense, nonsense my boy - I think it's clear that you're from good wizarding stock. Being a half-blood isn't the barrier it once was these days - at least this side of the Atlantic. I have a few contacts at the Blood Status Office who might look into the matter for you..." Slughorn said.

"Perhaps another time, sir. I appreciate the hospitality and conversation, but I had a few questions of a more academic nature before I popped off to bed. Advanced defence, if you like," Tom said. The fire seemed to lower itself as Tom spoke, slipping the room further into murky shadow. The soft orange light of the dying flames played across the faces of the two wizards. Slughorn's wand lay to one side of him on the same small table he'd rested his wine glass on, but it seemed forgotten as Tom drew him into the conversation.

"Oh, of course. What's gnawing at you, my boy?"

"Well, sir, I've come across a few references I don't really understand," Tom said. Holly couldn't find a fault in his acting, though she was sure he was.

"That strikes me as unlikely - I dare say there's much of magic you know far better than I. Still, if I can help - though surely others might be more useful?"

"Thank you, sir. It's just, I wasn't sure if the other teachers would give me an answer. I know you'd give me the truth, sir," Tom said and at last Holly could see the faintest crack in his facade. A hint, just a hint, of too much eagerness.

Slughorn missed it and the fleeting moment vanished into could-have-beens and what-ifs. He bought Riddle's act, and Holly felt a growing horror as she watched the conversation. To have guarded this so jealously, she knew, Slughorn had to have revealed something - or learnt something - truly awful.

"Well, I know you can handle this sort of material. I'm sure if they knew as well as I did..."

"I'm sure, sir. I was doing some reading for Defence and I noticed a reference to a term I didn't understand - and I couldn't find anything in the library about it other than innuendoes and reffernces, which is why I came to you. Sir, what is a Horcrux, exactly?"

"A Horcrux... Tom, you must understand that this is the darkest of magics. The very darkest - why, we shouldn't even be having this conversation. It is a banned topic at Hogwarts, you know - Dumbledore convinced Dippet to scour any explanation of such things from the restricted section years ago," Slughorn said.

"If you think we shouldn't discuss it, sir, I don't mind. But... I've only an academic interest, sir, and it seems dreadfully unfair to me that we could not discuss something at that level."

"No, no Tom you're quite right - I trust you to be responsible with this. A Horcrux... a Horcrux is a term for an object where a person has concealed a part of their soul," Slughorn said. The fire had died almost completely by that point, leaving the room illuminated by distant candles and a few flickering embers.

"A part of their soul? I had gathered something along those lines, but I've no idea how such a thing could even be possible," Tom said.

"There is a ritual - do not ask me about it, for I do not know the exact steps - that uses cold-blooded murder to split apart the soul. When one's soul is split... even if they were to be struck by the killing curse, some measure of their soul would remain here and they would be unable to truly die," Slughorn explained.

"Unable to die? They would be immortal?" Tom asked. Holly could what the hunger in his voice. She could hear the whispers in the crackle of the embers.

"Perhaps, but it would be a fate worse than death. Forever torn in two... I should not like to think what such a state would be like. Few would want it, Tom."

"Of course, sir. One would be rather like a ghost, in such a state. Tethered and stuck."

"Oh, no. As foul as such a state would be, do not mistake it for the unchanging abyss that a ghost endures. A wizard who splits his soul in two may still learn, may still change. He is not rendered a ghost at all... though I suppose one who is so afraid of death that they would split apart their very soul stands a good chance of remaining as a spectre after their inevitable death," Slughorn said.

"Their inevitable death?" Tom asked.

"A Horcrux may be amongst the most protected of all magical artefacts, but it can still be destroyed, Tom. A killing curse, fiendfyre - some say the venom of a basilisk. All the great dark lords who have made such an item have perished after it was destroyed, Tom," Slughorn said.

"It sounds like the height of folly to do such evil to make one, sir. But... what if one split their soul more than once? To guard against such an eventuality? Could that be done?"

"Perhaps, but the soul would grow weaker with each attempt, you understand. And there is the threat of the Horcrux finding a host for its fragment of soul..." Slughorn said.

"How far could a dark wizard push his soul, sir? It would have to be a magically powerful number, to stabilise the array and empower the soul," Tom said.

"There are... legends of a warlock from the Orient who had a three-part soul, though I do not know if they are true."

"Only three? Wouldn't seven, or even thirteen be more powerful, sir?"

"To split one's soul into three is no small matter, Tom! But - and this is only academic, yes?" Slughorn asked.
"Of course, sir. I... I must admit that the possibility occurred to me, and I've had some trouble sleeping, imagining that the war with Grindlewald might go on forever if he has done such a thing," Tom said.

"I should have known from the start that was your concern, my boy. If it brings you some measure of comfort, I do not think Grindlewald has even a single Horcrux. He is known to think such things are beneath him. But, as to your question, I do not think a thirteen-part soul is possible. Seven, however... if the rituals were completed within a certain period of time, might be possible," Slughorn said.

Holly's eyes went wide just as Tom's did. She had Dumbledore's answer. He stood utterly still beside her.

Seven Horcruxes. Seven splinters of Voldermort, each capable of anchoring him to life - or of overtaking a host of its own. Each with his earthly power, once they had done so. Seven Voldemorts was almost too awful to think of.

"Thank you for the answer, sir. I... I appreciate you hearing me out when others would not have," Tom said as he stood.

"Of course, my boy. But, ah, best keep this between us?" Slughorn said, and Tom smiled slightly.

"Of course, sir," he said as he left the room and the memory ended. The darkened room dissolved away, and Holly found herself back in Dumbledore's office, her face faintly damp from the waters of the pensieve. He stood beside her and Holly couldn't help but note how strongly he held onto the edge of the pensieve.

"It is seven, then. More than I had hoped, but less than I had feared," Dumbledore said.

"Seven Horcruxes? No, six - right, sir?" Holly asked.

"Yes, Miss Potter. Six horcruxes for a seven-part soul. Although we have already destroyed the diary and the ring, leaving three unknown horcruxes and the locket incarnation of Riddle," Dumbledore said.

"He'd anchor the other Voldemort still?"

"Oh yes. I suspect they plan to imprison the other, though I have extensively investigated that option and found it... unsuitable," Dumbledore said.

"Do you know what the other three are, sir?" Holly asked.

"I have suspicions. The objects would have to have great emotional resonance with Voldemort to contain his soul, and he would have to consider them worthy. Apart from his own diary, I suspect they are all artefacts of the Founders. The ring and the locket were Slytherin's, but I have connected a younger Riddle to the disappearance of Hufflepuff's cup. I suspect you can make the inference as well as I can," Dumbledore said.

"Three remaining Horcuxes and three remaining Founders. Hufflepuff's cup, something of Gryffindor's, and something of Ravenclaw's. I didn't know Gryffindor had anything other than the sword," Holly said. A question had been gnawing at her, but it could not fit with Dumbledore's theory - and it was all the better that she had not asked it. If she asked it, she could not take it back.

The whispers spoke to her in the quiet clicks and hisses of the machinery in the office.

"There are a few items attributed to him that have been lost over the years. Voldemort once came back to Hogwarts, before he began his campaign of terror, and asked for the post of Professor of Defence Against the Dark Arts. I believe when I refused him that he laid the curse on the position, but now I must wonder if he came here looking for something," Dumbledore said.

"The sword was hidden here, Professor. It makes sense that other artefacts of the Founders might be," Holly said.

"Very good. I think we shall leave it there for tonight, Miss Potter. I have something of a lead regarding a cave near the sea that Voldemort may have used to hide a Horcrux - I shall inform you when I have located it. Now, unless you have any questions, best off to bed," Dumbledore said.

"No, no questions, sir," Holly said as she tried to ignore the question gnawing inside her head. The idea that had made her sick to her stomach and stunk of being all too true.

She walked through the deserted halls, populated only by patrols of Prefects and Inquisitorial Squad members, and returned to her dormitory. She walked up the staircase to the Girl's Dormitory, and even the flash of validation that gave her did nothing to lighten her mood. She was being irrational, she knew.

Surely the possibility had occurred to Dumbledore. Surely he would have calmed her fears and answered her question in the negative. Surely, she thought, he would not have lied to her so boldly.

Then she remembered he had allowed her to draw her own inference, and how he had told her again and again how he felt himself too considerate of her feelings. Dumbledore would lie indirectly to salve her feelings if the truth was awful enough. She did not think he would flatly lie to her about something this important now after she had been let in on the deepest secret of the Order. She knew that if she asked him directly, he would tell her the truth.

So she did not ask Dumbledore her question and instead withdrew the bottle of firewhiskey hidden in her trunk. The painful warmth and sleep-inducing dullness of mind let the question slide away and let her slide into sleep.

When she woke the next morning, she was left with a hangover and the same gnawing question in her gut. Was she a Horcrux? Was she even Holly Potter at all?
 
Given that Horcrux shards are seemingly both unable to heal, and unable to simply animate random corpses on their own power, the general assumption would be that Holly is in fact majority Potter. At most she's one part in eight Voldemort, possibly less depending on the number of horcruxes, since if she's not an intentional horcrux (and I don't see why Voldy would want a baby corpse as a horcrux) then he might have split his soul more than intended.

The bigger worry is really if she's some sort of magical foci he can use to scry or influence events at a distance.

Everyone has a few mass murderers in the family tree.
 
Protected by a mother's love, arguably the most powerful magic, it would be an ill fated or outright failed Horcrux attempt similar to the number of tries to make a working Philosopher's stone.
 
Protected by a mother's love, arguably the most powerful magic, it would be an ill fated or outright failed Horcrux attempt similar to the number of tries to make a working Philosopher's stone.

That's pretty much what happened in canon? Voldemort accidentally turned Harry into a horcrux when he killed Lilly, hence their connection and why Harry needed to temporarily die at the end of the last book. While the specifics are likely slightly different here, it stands to reason that something similar is true for Holly.

With that said, between the sacrificial wards, the depleted state of Voldemort's soul by the time of the murder, and all the years it spent connected to Holly, it wouldn't surprise me if her piece of Riddle isn't really Riddle any more. After all, if a horcrux can takeover and subsume a host, why couldn't a host do the reverse, under the right conditions?
 
The question to me is if the soul was split evenly or if every subsequent horcrux took half of the remaining soul.
 
and I don't see why Voldy would want a baby corpse as a horcrux

Because that's ironic and twisted, fits the necessary conditions for turning an object into a horcrux, nobody would suspect it, any signs of dark magic would be waved off as consequences of the killing curse, and if someone does cotton up to the fact it's a horcrux, they'd have real trouble convincing people to let them exhume a child corpse to burn it with fiendfire.

Also, it's funny.
 
Back
Top