Penny: Man what a wild ride! And you also beat up a teacher? What kind of life are you living on that school of yours?
Holly: It's actually a pretty awesome place once you ignore the annual brief periods of bowel-voiding terror. And yes a guy named Quirrel during my first year.*frowns* Unless Dean was refering to Lockhart, that was in my second year.
Penny: o_O What the fuck Holly?
Also, keep in mind this is all coming from a thirteen year old. Reasonably fit I'm sure, but we're still talking about someone about five feet tall and not overly muscular.
 
That Stonewall was in the US, though it is nicely coincidental as a group-name for the queer kids.
Sure, but it's used internationally as a symbol of queer activism and pride. I don't think it's weird to see a group of queer teens named "Stonewall" and assume it's a reference to the pivotal event in the LGBT rights movement.
 
Great chapter, one thing though, most state schools in the UK for ages 11-16 would be a Secondary School, not a high school. Of course exceptions do exist.


EDIT: Nvm canon lol
 
Year Four, Chapter Two
Year Four, Chapter Two

Holly still felt the pain in her scar as the sun crested the horizon, though the bleeding had stopped. She quickly showered, got dressed, and packed her things up to try and distract herself from worrying. She knew that she couldn't get a message to Sirius before he arrived, absent just trying to go to him directly. She, for once, carefully and neatly packed her things in her trunk. Hermione would be proud.

She ate her piece of grapefruit nervously that morning, making sure to keep her wand in her pocket at all times. She knew that Voldemort wasn't going to burst into the Dursleys' living room, but the dream had rattled her. That man's eyes... she shivered, despite the summer heat.

Holly was snapped out of her panic by the sound of a very loud motorcycle outside. As Privet Drive, and really Little Whinging as a whole was not the sort of place one typically encountered a motorbike, Holly looked out the window. There, having somewhat haphazardly parked a large black motorcycle was Sirius Black. Holly's godfather was looking less gaunt than when she had last seen him, and she was so excited she ran out towards him.

"Holly!"

"Sirius!" she said, hugging him fiercely. "It's good to see you. I think I'd have gone crazy if I had to spend any more time with them," Holly continued.

"It's good to see you too, Holly. Go get your stuff - I'll just stand out here and embarrass your aunt," Sirius said with a grin. The leather jacket he was wearing, and his general demeanour would certainly cause the legendary gossips that were the housewives of Privet Drive to go into overdrive.

Holly got her trunk down from her bedroom, along with Hedwig's cage. She'd already let her owl out last night - Hedwig, Holly knew, was more than capable of finding Grimmauld place. Sirius put them into a compartment in the bike's sidecar that seemed to be much larger on the inside than the outside.

"So are we really going to drive on this?" Holly asked.

"I've been waiting to drive this thing again for a decade," Sirius said, and Holly got into the sidecar excitedly. Sirius revved the engine, and then Holly felt a very strange sensation. It was as if someone had cracked an egg on her head, and as she looked around she saw in amazement that she and the bike seemed to have become almost transparent.

"What is this?" Holly asked.

"Disillusionment charm," Sirius said with a grin, and then with one last roar of the engine, the motorcycle took off into the sky. It was great fun, and Holly spent much of the trip flying alongside the motorbike in the air as a raven. It was almost enough to make her forget her dream, as she soared across London,
She transformed back for the last stretch of the journey, and after they landed and came to a stop, she turned to Sirius.

"That was amazing!" she said.

"I thought you'd like it. Happy birthday, Holly," he said, and hugged her.

They had landed in an alley just off a row of large stone townhouses, all of them stately and imposing. Sirius got her stuff from the enchanted compartment, made the motorcycle invisible again, and led Holly around to the street. It was still early in the morning, and there was no one else around. A sign on the corner of the street read 'Grimmauld Place'. A small plaque underneath caught Holly's eye, and she read it quickly.

Due to a bureaucratic mistake at the end of the 17th Century, Grimmauld Place has a number 11 and a number 13, but no number twelve. Locals have resisted all efforts to renumber houses, and so the street's odd quirk of numbering remains.

Sirius saw what she was reading, and chuckled.

"Of course, the end of the seventeenth century is also when the statue of secrecy was passed. My dear old ancestors performed a stupendous number of memory charms to get everyone to buy the mistake story," Sirius said and gestured towards one of the houses. There, looking a little more faded than its neighbours, was Number Twelve Grimmauld Place. It had a high stone fence, topped with iron spikes that looked lethally sharp. Small runes glowed an angry red in lines across the fence, and there was a great iron gate.

"So this is where you lived as a kid?" Holly asked.

"Remus and I have cleaned out most of the tacky decor and dark artifacts, but yes," Sirius said, tapping his wand against the gate. It swung open, and the runes on the fence calmed down to soft blue light. Holly walked through the open gate, and she felt a strange sensation. "Crossing the wardline always did give me a little shiver. Paranoid old bastards, the Blacks. But at least all those wards will be good for something now you're staying here," Sirius said, after seeing Holly's reaction.

"I get the impression you liked them about as much as I like the Dursleys," Holly said, as they walked up to the large wooden door - which was, of course, painted black.

"Worse. They weren't Death Eaters, but my parents thought Voldemort had the right idea - and the less said about most of my cousins, the better," Sirius said and opened the door. Holly thought at once that if this was Grimmauld Place after Sirius and Remus had spent a month taking out all the tacky decor, the Blacks must have been the epitome of pureblood pretentiousness.

"I guess the fact that you're living here with your werewolf boyfriend is pretty good revenge, though," Holly said.

"Oh, my mother's portrait has words to say about that. If people open the curtains, she starts screeching about... well, I'm sure you can imagine," Sirius said, laughing as he led Holly through a tour of the house.

"Happy birthday, Holly," Remus said as they entered the kitchen. He had some toast and rather rubbery looking eggs on a plate, and Holly sighed. She could see a large number of muggle takeaway food boxes too.

"It's good to see you, Remus... maybe I should handle the food from now on," Holly said.

"From what Molly Weasley told me, you'd probably be better than either of us at it. My parent's old house-elf was still around when we got here, but we've always hated each other. I set him free the minute I got here - from what I heard, he managed to get my dear cousin Narcissa Malfoy to take him in," Sirius said.

"Narcissa Malfoy is your cousin?" Holly asked.

"Oh, you haven't heard of the Black sisters? They were infamous enough in their day. Bellatrix is in Azkaban for being a Death Eater, Narcissa married Lucius Malfoy, and Andromeda turned out to be a perfectly nice lady," Sirius explained. "Anyway, let me show you the rest of the house. People are coming round at noon for your birthday party, so you have plenty of time to do that odd teenage girl thing and spend three hours getting dressed," he continued. Holly rolled her eyes at him.

Number Twelve Grimmauld Place had everything from a library to a proper duelling room in its vast warren of wallpapered corridors. It was surely much larger on the inside than the outside, a triumph of expansion charms. Many of the rooms had clashing styles, clearly having been added on as the owners desired it. Sirius pointed out were things he'd removed had been, like the collection of House Elf heads. One room had a huge tapestry with the names of all the various Blacks on it, and Holly could see that work had clearly been done it recently.

"And this is your bedroom," Sirius said, opening the door to show Holly the room. It was large, and done mostly in red and gold. There was a huge four-poster bed, a desk that Holly thought must have belonged to someone important once, and a large window that looked out onto the street. There were cupboards and dressers, a place for her to put her broom, and even a relatively modern-looking radio sitting next to what was clearly a wizard wireless. It struck Holly then that she had somewhere she could leave things behind - that she no longer needed to live out of her trunk.

"This - this is great, Sirius," Holly said and hugged him.

"This used to be my room - I figured you'd like the window. Remus made me take down all the dirty posters, though," Sirius said, and Holly laughed. "I'll let you get your stuff put away - me and Remus's room is down that hall," Sirius said, and then closed the door behind him.

She put her things away, smiling at the Basilisk-skin coat that Hagrid had given her last year. The resizing runes (a simple sizing charm wouldn't take to the magic-resistant basilisk skin) had kept it the right size for her. She found a good hiding place for her little black notebook and made sure it was hidden from anyone who might look for it.

Then she closed the curtains and got ready for her birthday party. She didn't take all that long, but drying her hair was starting to take longer. She wondered idly if there were hair drying charms. Maybe Parvarti or Lavender would know, she thought.

Sirius had evidently invited all her friends and then some more for her birthday party. All the Weasleys in the country came, and Molly Weasley stepped out of the fireplace holding a very large cake. Hermione was there, of course, but unlike all the other guests she'd been dropped of by her parents in a car. Hagrid had to stoop to get through the fireplace. Neville Longbottom came as well as Parvati Patil and Lavender Brown (It turned out that there were several types of hair-drying charms). Even Luna Lovegood came, and Holly smiled as she saw her step out of the living room fireplace. She was an odd one, but Holly thought Luna was quite nice and often a lot of fun.

She managed not to cry this time, but Holly's fourteenth birthday was just as good as her thirteenth. Not only was there Mrs Weasley's huge cake but Holly and Sirius got to delight in introducing their mostly wizard-raised guests to pizza. Even Hermione found it amusing, but it soon won over all those present.

Sirius, Remus, Hagrid, and Mr and Mrs Weasley mostly stayed in the living room, whilst Holly and her friends had the run of the house. Fred and George continued their streak of second secret gifts, though this one wasn't as interesting as the Marauder's Map - just a bottle of firewhiskey that Holly dutifully hid.

After everyone had gone home, Holly sat in the kitchen with Sirius and Remus. Everyone had no real desire to do anything else that day, but Holly knew she had to tell them about her dream.

"Last night I had, um, I guess you could call it a dream. But I think it was real? Let me start again..." Holly began, and she explained what she had seen in the dream. She couldn't identify anyone other than Voldemort, but both Sirius's and Remus's eyes narrowed at the Death Eater's story as Holly retold it.

"It couldn't be..." Remus said slowly.

"I saw them carry his body away myself, Remus. Holly, what did he look like again?" Sirius asked.

"He had black hair, tall - he'd be handsome if he didn't have this look to him..." she said, trailing off at the end. She didn't really know how to describe it.

"The bastard really did it," Sirius said, his voice more than a whisper.

"It could be someone else, Sirius," Remus said.

"No... I'll remember those eys until the day I die. He seemed so... broken in Azkaban I even felt a little sorry for him despite what he did. I guess the joke's on me," Sirius said.

"Who do you think he is?" Holly asked, confused.

"Barty Crouch... Junior," Sirius said, pausing for a moment before adding the 'Junior'.

"You mean the same Barty Crouch that sent you to Azkaban without a trial had a Death Eater for a son?" Holly said.

"The very same. I think we need to tell Dumbledore about his - I'll go write to him," Sirius said. Dumbledore came to Grimmauld Place that evening, and he had a strange look in his eyes as Holly finished telling him about her dream.

"I think we must start on at least Occlumency before the school year. Sirius, Remus - I trust the two of you can handle teaching Holly the basics?" Dumbledore said. They nodded.

"What's Occlumency?" Holly asked.

"The art of shielding one's mind against intrusion. I do not think that Voldemort can reverse your connection yet, but if he grows stronger..." Dumbledore said.

"It could be bad. He'd be able to, what, read my mind?"

"Or use you to influence the minds of others. It is lucky we discovered this connection whilst he was still so weak - and a pity it should cast a pall over today. Happy Birthday, by the way, Holly," Dumbledore said, smiling at her.

"Thanks, Professor," Holly said.

"Well, we're all too full of cake to do it today, but tomorrow we're starting you on Occlumency... and I think we should put that duelling room my granduncle installed to some use," Sirius said, after Dumbledore had gone. Holly grinned - if Sirius was anywhere near as good as Remus, she'd learn a lot from both of them.
 
Moron. He'd better hope Kreacher didn't take that damn locket with him.
Kreacher's genuine loyalty to the... traditional values of House Black, along with the unethical nature of owning a House Elf in general means there aren't really many alternative ways to deal with him, no palatable ones anyway
His early dismissal from Sirius also limits the valuable info he was able to give away, unlike canon
The Order of the Pheonix is not using Grimmauld 12 as a base yet since Voldy's still without a permanent body and the Death Eaters are still a fractured group (The Fidelius Charm meant Kreacher couldn't actually give them the location or get them inside, but still better that he does not know of it at all)​
He hasn't seen Holly and Sirius interact, and is therefore not aware of how close they are and how that can be used to manipulate her​
He in fact, has no sensitive information to give them at all, as far as I'm aware

The Locket is a genuine issue, assuming Kreacher could and did take it with him somewhere, which is probable
But his orders were to hide and destroy it I believe, so he's not going to be handing it over to the Death Eaters anytime soon, his loyalty to Regulus trumps his loyalty to them
This isn't really any different from canon either, as Kreacher hid the Locket away from the Order once they started setting up base there

Ultimately Sirius's decision to just free Kreacher and let him leave to serve the Malfoys instead does not make matters appreciably worse, and could probably be considered an improvement if anything
It's not like anyone had any way of knowing at the time that Kreacher was in the possession of one of Voldy's Horcruxes
 
Last edited:
Moron. He'd better hope Kreacher didn't take that damn locket with him.

To be fair, this actually makes more sense than keeping Kreacher on. Why would Sirius ever suspect that Kreacher is important, at all, to Voldemort outside of the tangential connection via Regulus? How could Sirius know that Kreacher has one of Voldemort's Horcruxes, when the only ones to even suspect those are in play are Dumbledore and possibly Bill Weasley, a sentence that's actually kind of shocking. What would make Sirius even think that Regulus was anything but a good little pet Death Eater up until his death and not secretly one of the two greatest traitors to betray the Dark Lord?

Add in that Kreacher...was always an unpleasant character who took to many of the Black family's beliefs, and with Sirius dating his werewolf boyfriend... let's be honest he probably said something horrible about or to Lupin, and Sirius, who's willing and able to take hits and insults to himself but is fiercely protective of those close to him and is no longer forced to keep himself and any clues where he might be secret lest he be arrested and sent to Azkaban, put his foot down.
 
I think the more interesting aspect of the thing is that, while Voldemort would not recognize an House Elf, as he thinks they're beneath him, Kreacher would certainly recognize Voldemort as the one who almost caused his death and, most importantly, is ultimately responsible for Regulus' death, should he ever be in his presence again - which, if he's now working for Malfoy, is very likely to eventually happen. That might end up having unexpected consequences down the line, and I'm curious to see what those might be.

And of course, morally speaking, freeing Kreacher was absolutely the right thing to do, so it's good that Sirius did so. The fact that in canon Kreacher wasn't freed always let me disappointed, since there's a substantial difference between Harry not taking direct action to free the elves (since Hermione's crusade proves the situation is not that easily solved), and Harry keeping a personal House Elf of his own. But then, plenty of things about Deathly Hollows were disappointing - it's not a bad book in an absolute sense, but relatively to the rest of the series, I still think it's the worst of the lot.
 
The Locket is a genuine issue, assuming Kreacher could and did take it with him somewhere, which is probable
But his orders were to hide and destroy it I believe, so he's not going to be handing it over to the Death Eaters anytime soon, his loyalty to Regulus trumps his loyalty to them
See I'm not sure this is true. In canon he was never actually re-bound, he just was still serving Sirius because he was a scion of the Blacks. If he was properly freed... would his loyalty to Regulus trump his new masters? I'm not sure it would.
 
See I'm not sure this is true. In canon he was never actually re-bound, he just was still serving Sirius because he was a scion of the Blacks. If he was properly freed... would his loyalty to Regulus trump his new masters? I'm not sure it would.
Probably. House-elves are hardly mindlessly loyal even if they are loyal in general. Dobby was an extreme case, but it shows it's perfectly possible for House-elves to prioritize someone outside the family over the family, to hide things from their family and even to dislike their family. Regulus was Kreacher's 100% adoration human who he was basically super-mega-ultra loyal to compared to the regular Black family loyalty. I don't see that going away. Or being superseded, unless the new family treats him just as well as Regulus did. (And we know how the Malfoys treat their House-elves)
He might be unable to disobey orders if they're given, but there's no reason for him to bring up 'hey I have an artefact from the Dark Lord' so it might not come up. He might even lie - 'Master Regulus, loyal servant of the Dark Lord, ordered this destroyed but Kreacher couldn't do it couldn't ask Sirius (bc he's on anti-voldemort side) please help destroy this thing the master wanted destroyed'. (Though whether they actually would - it's a fairly obvious slytherin artefact so they'd investigate. Risky play.)
Still, ultimately no reason to believe he'd be dumb about it or would lose his desire to destroy the locket.
 
See I'm not sure this is true. In canon he was never actually re-bound, he just was still serving Sirius because he was a scion of the Blacks. If he was properly freed... would his loyalty to Regulus trump his new masters? I'm not sure it would.
Several points to address in response to this query

If we assume Kreacher is "rebound" to the Malfoys (more on that later) they would have to actually order him to hand over the Locket, which they have absolutely no reason to do
Voldemort fully believes the Locket to still be safely stowed away in his cave and he never told anyone about the nature of his Horcruxes, as he's far too paranoid to give entrust anyone with the knowledge of how he avoids death, the thing that frightens him more than anything
Lucious Malfoy, for instance, was told to keep his Diary safe so that one day it might be planted back at Hogwarts to finish what his 16 year old self started, but was wholly unaware that it contained a fragment of his master's soul
Similarly Bellatrix was given the Hufflepuff Cup to store in her Vault, but likewise was not aware of its nature as a Horcrux, though she inferred it was important enough to him to guard with her life
The Malfoys are both unaware that Kreacher has the Locket to begin with, and why it would be vitally important that he does

We also know for a fact that whatever magic binds House Elves to their masters doesn't automatically win their loyalty, it merely forces them to obey their commands, Kreacher was bound to Sirius and then to Harry, yet he hated them
And he proved repeatedly capable of circumventing direct orders by willfully misinterpreting them or exploiting loopholes
When told to "Get out" of the kitchen he immediately seized the order as an allowance to leave the house, went to the Malfoys, and proceeded to betray every useful bit of information that he was capable of giving​
When told to discreetly tail Draco without alerting him at Hogwarts and inform Harry of what he was up to Kreacher discreetly tailed Draco... and informed Harry of all his completely mundane activities while purposefully ommitting the suspicious stuff that Harry actually wanted to hear about​
Kreacher isn't loyal to Regulus because he's bound to him, he's loyal to Regulus because Regulus treated him kindly, he's loyal to Regulus out of his own free will
Obedience is enforced, not loyalty

And considering how quickly he abandoned the whole Pure Blood diatribe the moment Harry and Co started treating him kindly, it's highly likely that Kreacher was never truly a believer of the philosophy at heart
I mean... why would he be? It's not like he has any reason to actually buy what Death Eaters sell
No, Kreacher expoused the beliefs of House Black because they were the beliefs that the people who treated him kindly, namely Regulus, held
And because they pissed off Harry and Sirius, who he hated
And because they were the beliefs that he was presumably exposed to his whole life
Which is all to say that he has no reason to offer the Locket of his own initiative when Regulus, whose memory he cherishes, wanted it hidden from Voldy and destroyed

This sums it up pretty well:
Deathly Hallows said:
Harry Potter: "I don't understand you, Kreacher. Voldemort tried to kill you, Regulus died to bring Voldemort down, but you were still happy to betray Sirius to Voldemort? You were happy to go to Narcissa and Bellatrix, and pass information to Voldemort through them…"
Hermione Granger: "Harry, Kreacher doesn't think like that. He's a slave; house-elves are used to bad, even brutal treatment; what Voldemort did to Kreacher wasn't that far out of the common way. What do wizard wars mean to an elf like Kreacher? He's loyal to people who are kind to him… I've said all along that wizards would pay for how they treat house-elves. Well, Voldemort did… and so did Sirius."

Lastly near as I am aware "binding" or "rebinding" a House Elf never comes up
Consider Winky, who was very, very unhappy to be freed, and yet apparently never got herself rebound to Hogwarts, keep in mind that the books portray House Elves being bound as a good thing (gonna talk about that in a bit believe me)
It's never presented as an option, and the concept is never discussed at all
The implication, especially with Hermoine's shortlived S.P.E.W. campaign being presented as being in the wrong, is that House Elves being bound to a master is just a natural state of being, and rather than an unnatural force that is pressed upon them
I hate this and would vastly prefer if this isn't the case in this fic mind you, but that is the implication of canon
And if this hopefully isn't the case in this fic, Kreacher would still not give up the Locket if rebound for all the reasons listed above

It probably isn't the case for this fic as an aside, as here it was mentioned that Hogwarts actually employs a great deal of Freed House Elves, which is very much not the case in Canon

Right and now that I've talked about all that time for another rant
Rowling's portrayal of House Elves is just... it's bad
According to her, Hermoine's outrage and attempts to fight against literal slavery are supposed to satirize the people obsessed with helping minority groups without actually thinking of what the people they are trying to help actually want
Because according to Rowling, literal slavery where the victims have no ability to disobey and are forced to harm themselves, defiling their autonomy, is perfectly fine... because they like being enslaved
It's just their natural state of being
To the point where they take immense pride in the fact that they wear shifts fashioned from dirty rags, sacks and pillowcases rather than proper clothes, as it expresses the fact they have no needs not specifically commanded of them

The closest things get to decrying the House Elf mess is saying it's wrong to abuse your slaves, but apparently not wrong to own them in the first place

I get on some level, that a lot of this is likely a hold over from the inspiration behind House Elves, folklore about little Elves or Brownies or Farfadets
Little fae creatures that are said to help with menial work
But see, the thing is those creatures are actually paid for doing that
Brownies and Farfadets clean the house in exchange for an offering, usually milk or cream, and will explicitly leave a house if they feel insulted or taken advantage of, they leave when given clothes because they feel insulted by the insinuation that they need the charity
 
Last edited:
Moron. He'd better hope Kreacher didn't take that damn locket with him.

Frankly if a character is going to make a mistake that may or may not cause complications and dramatic tension further down the road I prefer for those mistakes to be the logical consequence of a character reacting in-character to situations and limited knowledge presented and available to them. To me, such is a sign of good writing and infinitely preferable to randomly handing people the proverbial idiot ball to brute force events down whatever path one demands.

Lastly near as I am aware "binding" or "rebinding" a House Elf never comes up

Does it ever even come up what this supposed bond even does, anyway? Dobby was able to effectively act contrary to his master's wishes. While he did not outright reveal who was behind the plot he acted without orders on several occasions in order to prevent his master's plans from achieving success. More to the point, he was able to loophole Lucius tossing aside a crusty sock belonging to someone else into "being given clothes" so one wonders: how do elves not escape their bindings all the time? How do they even do laundry of any kind of the binding is apparently so very flimsy and fickle?

Do we even have any canon verification of the elf servant "bond" being magical in nature rather than cultural? From the looks of it, the only thing that was killing Winky after she was freed....was Winky. And last I checked, being a depressed alcoholic didn't require being magically cursed or otherwise affected.
 
Mine is that they were created as/turned into a servant race, since being bound to obey another species is not something they'd come up with on their own.
I was more thinking 'house elves were similar to Brownies/Farfadets and wizards figured out how to take advantage of them and corrupted their culture for their own ends'. So turned into a servant race by twisting a pre-existing trait.
 
Huh, I don't know why it is that I've been finding so many good Transgender fics recently but this is another excellent one for the watchlist!
 
Changeling and Vegas Rules are the two main ones, both Ranma 1/2 fics with excellent Trans!Ranma (Ranko) depictions and struggles, even if I felt that Changeling dealt with some parts of it a little bit oddly.
If you like Trans Ranma, can I interest you in Stop!! Ranma-kun! by Beedok? A crossover of Ranma and a fantastic short series called Stop Hibari Kun about an assertive trans gal?
 
If you like Trans Ranma, can I interest you in Stop!! Ranma-kun! by Beedok? A crossover of Ranma and a fantastic short series called Stop Hibari Kun about an assertive trans gal?

Honestly two Ranma stories are enough for me, I'm poking around to see if I can find any well-written Trans fics in other fandoms though, so if you have any recommendations I will happily take them.

(Genderbend fics that deal with the consequences of such appropriately are also worth reading in my books, so I'll take recommendations for those too.)
 
Back
Top