Conclusion, huh? Annette closed her eyes. Shaped her anger into cold disdain, the remnants going into the furnace with the rest. "I think I've drawn the only conclusion I need to, Alan."
Zoe looked to Annette, questioning.
"You know, I don't blame you, not really. I can't hold you responsible for the actions of others." Alan's eyes turned calculating, trying to see what Annette was constructing. "No one could have seen it coming, and it's not right to lay the fault on you." Zoe frowned, clearly not sure where Annette was going. "It wasn't your fault. You missed something, made an honest mistake. You were busy with work. A thousand little things added up, until something slipped the net."
"That's…" he frowned, trying to see the trap. A car started in the driveway. He was still looking in the direction of the receding sound when he answered. "Ah… that's right. What matters now is how we move for–"
"It wasn't your fault that you forgot about our daughters until it was too late. It wasn't your fault that, when you gave him a call explaining things, Danny went to pick them up instead of you." Zoe's eyes widened. Alan's filled with a dawning horror. "That was how he was. Always willing to go out on a limb for you, for people he loved."
"Annette–" Alan began. She fixed him with her stare, with the full force of her disdain.
"It wasn't your fault. But we'd all be better off if you'd been the one in the car that day."
Alan, for the first time that night, had no response. No immediate, pat answer. She'd finally hit him where it hurt.
It should have been satisfying.
If it wasn't for the look on Zoe's face, it would have been.
Amazing how someone can have all the cards and then blow them to shit on a scorched earth jab.
A really good one, but still, the winning move is rarely "use husband's death as a right hook against his guilty friend to imply he should be dead while his wife and your own good friend who'd been on your side prior watches."
Now, I want to say I've been captured by this fic, it's just a solid, intelligent and characterful setting fusion throughout, and the mysteries of exactly what worldbuilding details have been folded into each other and what's still separately in existence is an fascinating thread to pull.
It's been too long to save my initial thoughts for the earlier chapters, but it's been interesting to see how strong and in character a presence Kiana's POV has been through the story, only for, as of 5 chapters in, Taylor to still be someone talked around rather than directly present as the other series' primary protagonist. The build up of tension and intrigue has been too well constructed to be anything but deliberate, and it's reminding me of something specific I've been working over in my head–
She grabbed the padlock, squeezing and twisting in opposite directions, and it snapped with a squeal of protest. The locker's built-in combination lock gave her no more trouble… though the finger-marks would probably get reported to the PRT. She set that thought aside – tomorrow's problems could come after today's – and wrenched the locker open, only to be startled as a body fell out, accompanied by a scattering of foul objects and liquids. She caught the falling figure, dimly recognizing her through the filth all over her – it was that withdrawn girl who was being bullied by the local queen bees, what was her name, Taylor? – and breathed a sigh of relief as she confirmed that the girl, while unconscious, still had a pulse. For the moment.
"Right. So, three girls have been bullying her this whole time. Well, I say three, but…" she shrugged. "It's more like two and various levels of minion. I have no idea why, if there's even a reason, but they'd be the most likely suspects, and they've done some pretty demented things… but I haven't heard of anything this bad before."
"Hm. Thank you for bringing this to my attention. And who are the ringleaders you mentioned?"
"Right. A tall redheaded girl named Emma Barnes, and a sort of average height track team member, Sophia Hess. And their like… third wheel? Madison Clements." Armsmaster went still. Was that a surprise? Did he know one of them, or something? "They're like, basically queen bees of the school." Kiana let her eyes widen like she'd just realized something. "Please don't let them know who told you this, I don't want to be their next punching bag." It wasn't that Kiana cared, really – worst came to worst she'd just leave – but it would be very inconvenient.
–Which is that Kiana starts the story by being her usual white knight self, getting stuck in shit to help a random girl she barely knows, but it always piqued my attention that Kiana's had awareness of the generalities of this mean girl clique vs mousey girl business and hasn't stuck her nose in already when it's already been implied that this is taking after the version of the backstory she knew Mei prior to the Third Eruption:
Only two points of warmth remained. Two who continued to trust her, who refused to believe what was being said about her. About her father. Two girls who were blind to what she truly was. Two girls who she would be forever grateful to. The family she had thought she would be forever denied.
But family was not enough to keep her whole. It never had been; why would it be any different now? And in the end, she broke. Two pairs of hands could not hold up what hundreds sought to tear down.
(Also awwww Bronya was part of the friendship squad before Nagazora went to hell, that's almost warm enough to preserve against the many leagues of agony)
So we're still in the general neighborhood of Kiana's anti-bullying tendencies, so it's a minor mystery as to why it hasn't come out beforehand, though, I should acknowledge that we haven't actually gotten that far into the circumstances of this last year, and she could've been involved in some degree that she doesn't consciously register as important, but Taylor and others might.
But for the time being, the main leads probably center around what's expressed here:
While the mystery of Madison might have been interesting, class was decidedly not. Nor were any of the two other classes before lunch. It was almost impossible to keep her mind from wandering, and eventually she simply gave up, letting her thoughts go where they would as she doodled.
And where they went, over and over, was superheroes. She'd met capes before, even before Nagazora, but those had been… different. In Old Russia, capes were volatile, avoided by everyone who could manage it. Anyone who chose to put on a costume and go fight things there was either a warlord, a warlord's minion, or dead. Smart parahumans, like herself, just kept a low profile and tried to get by. A costume, a public identity, all of that was just painting a target on yourself.
In more "civilized" territory, capes were Schicksal's Valkyries, not to be trusted. Her father had warned her, extensively, that Schicksal was a danger to her, that they hid monstrous deeds under a facade of public good. That their master was a cunning, obsessive man with no moral scruples. That if they knew who and where she was, she would not be safe.
So she kept a low profile, she stayed away from their operations as she traveled. After a close call with an ostensibly independent cape who reported her "for her own good," she started avoiding them as well. It was the criminals that were reliable, in the end. Selfish, possibly unstable, looking out for them and theirs, out to make a quick buck… those were all things she could deal with. Never safe, but she would take a gun in her face over a knife in her back any day of the week.
Was America any different? In the end, she didn't know. It looked like, for all of Brockton Bay's nature as a shithole, there were more independent heroes here than there had been in Schicksal territory. Maybe the PRT had leashes on them, behind the scenes. Maybe the Guild, the Canadian equivalent to the Protectorate, wasn't as independent as they pretended.
But when her thoughts returned to Glory Girl, to Panacea, to Lady Photon, something about them, something special, stuck in her mind. And not just them - even Armsmaster, obvious PRT stooge that he was, had had a certain… presence to him. A sense that he was something more. Something that she hadn't felt since she first met Mei.
Maybe all it was was… she wanted to believe. To believe that maybe there was something she could do, that people could do, to make the world a better place. To not get stabbed in the back for trying. To, maybe, be something like a hero.
She wondered, thinking of the countless designs she'd doodled over the morning, if wanting was enough to matter.
What I notice first here (besides musing on how this sort of direct running commentary of Kiana's inner dimension was rare by the earlier arcs of Honkai Impact) is how generally melancholic and aimless Kiana is here, having pulled herself out of Nagazora with Mei and Bronya, never meeting Theresa and Himeko to galvanize her towards a goal besides keeping her head down and finding her dad...It's almost expected that the omnidirectional wretchedness of Winslow might be draining her will to do anything beyond going through the motions, if she has to further balance hunting for Siegfried and not endangering the only family she's had since by making scenes.
This lack of an ambition like becoming Schicksal's top Valkyrie, it's taking something out of her, alongside the continued lack of real security, it's pushing her into a state that's very familiar to those acquainted with her stint in Arc City, which our author actually references:
Kiana is really fun to write, because her focus and effort on a problem or scenario is generally inversely proportional to how safe she feels it is. In St. Freya she's an enormous slacker, because she's safe there and doesn't need to worry about where her next meal comes from or when she's going to have to skip town, and can afford to just goof off. Put her in Arc City on the run, doubting her own sanity, and she pulls out the skills she used to survive, on her own and off Schicksal's radar, for years, and simultaneously protects the city from Honkai and digs up a conspiracy that even Schicksal hadn't uncovered, all while being hunted by the Immortal Blades.
Like, it might be making her competent, but Kiana's never really happy when she's competent, and it's clear she's in a rut, and unlikely to find the right step forward without a push...
"But that's nothing you need to worry about." She smiled kindly, and the anger… didn't fade, but seemed to move more to the background. "Thank you again, for rescuing my daughter. And actually… would you mind giving me your contact information? I'd love to have you over for dinner, once Taylor's feeling better."
Kiana's thoughts came to a screeching halt. In the pros column: a home cooked dinner by an actual mom (moms were all good at cooking, right?). In the cons column: Annette was scary, she didn't know Taylor, and she had no idea how 'normal' families acted.
There was really only one answer.
"Of course!"
Hang on, what do we have here? A dangling hook for the two media's central protagonists to meet later on? When Taylor's reaction to getting trauma superpowers was to starting jogging to get in shape while spiders spin her up a supersuit?
Gee, I wonder how that might coincide with being reintroduced to the person who got her out of the locker (after some inconspicuous Parahuman just so happened to bust it open with inhuman force then duck out, shock and dismay), with a very similar urge for heroism to combat the ennui of living in a world at the edge of armageddon, ho hum.
It'd been fairly obvious how Taylor was likely to get tied up with Kiana on her side, but this provides a nuanced counterpoint for why Kiana might find herself drawn into the gravity of Taylor's north star, which is very much an essential ingredient to making a storyline balanced between the central axles of the source materials–Well, as long as Taylor's actually meant to be one of the primary viewpoints too, which isn't anywhere near settled yet, of course.
Now, off to more whimsical topics:
"Heyyyy…" Victoria's expression turned thoughtful, perhaps even cunning. It made Mei… not uneasy, perhaps, but uncertain. What was the girl's angle? "Actually, if you were willing to do me a favor… would you like to help me pick something out for Amy? Looks like you could use some replacements, and I like your style!"
"Ah, sorry. I have a bus that I should catch, so I can get these bags home…"
"I'll happily give you a lift!" she floated upwards a bit to demonstrate, doing a quick twirl in the air. "And I'll cover your new clothes if you do~"
"Ah… well…" she cast around for any other reasons, but none came to mind. Bronya would be fine on her own, and Kiana would be in school for a while yet, as Winslow did not have Arcadia's vocational focus. "...I'd be happy to, in that case. Let me just text Bronya, so she doesn't worry that I'm out late."
For some reason, Amy seemed to twitch at that.
How strange.
The spectacular violence this subplot does to my sides is enhanced by the beautiful awareness that even if she succeeds, Victoria's unknowingly walking Amy right into a repeat of her (second) deepest turmoil:
Amy: Okay Vicky maybe I am willing to try, something, with Mei–
Amy: [Walks in on Kiana and Mei macking on each other or making moon eyes or confessing their undying love or otherwise confirming their unofficial gay marriage]
Amy:
Amy: Extroverts are oppressing me again.
Kiana liking her enough to induct her into the polycule would not mend the wound, because that's just the lesbian version of Dean's "I'm fond of my girlfriend's sister even though she hates me with the spite of several suns and she knows I know she knows."
He'd almost forgotten about the strangeness when, at the end of lunch, and the beginning of the vocational part of the day, Amy excused herself to use the restroom… the Russian girl peeled off, following Amy, shimmering with mingled wariness, suspicion, and determination.
He frowned, turning to Victoria, who was engrossed in conversation with Dennis and Carlos. "Hey, honeybun?" he asked with a smile, putting a hand on her shoulder.
She pulsed red with anger, turning towards him, face set in a scowl. "You know I don't like that pet name, Dean, what the hell?"
"Needed your attention, sorry," he apologized easily, though he knew he'd be paying for it later regardless. "Can you go check on Amy? Think someone just followed her into the restroom. As in, her specifically."
Mercurial as always, red anger mingled with blue concern. "What!? If some bitch thinks she can–"
"I don't know if it's bad!" he interrupted hastily. "Just healthy caution, you know?"
"Whatever it is, she'd better pray…" she muttered to herself as she got up and stalked off, crowd parting as her aura shifted to the 'terror' half of awe.
Dean hoped he hadn't just made a big mistake.
Actually wanna get into this more, because it's sweet in a sad way that Dean earnestly wants to look out for Amy but his existence is homophobic to her. She'd have never scored in his absence but sometimes a person needs a human dartboard to aim all their fine vintage unblemished spite at.
The last thing is the continued question in my mind of whether the Honkai and Entities will be unified as a single front or not, because one is simple arithmetic, while the other is, fiendishly compelling in the right execution.
Behemoth
First Appearance: Iran, 1996
Appearance: Fourteen-meter rough humanoid, 'claws' and one 'eye'
Status: Destroyed (2006)
Notes: Extremely potent energy-control abilities within a radius.
[h3][/h3]Leviathan
First Appearance: Oslo, 1998
Appearance: Nine meter rough humanoid, fourteen-meter tail
Status: Destroyed (2002)
Notes: Wide-scale hydrokinesis, 'water echo,' extreme speed.
The Simurgh
First Appearance: Lausanne, 2009
Appearance: Five-meter pale human, variable number of feathered 'wings' at random points on body. Flight-capable
Status: Inactive (Orbit)
Notes: Mental manipulation, telekinesis, advanced intelligence, possible precognition, possible ability to copy Tinker/Thinker powers.
[h3][/h3]Charybdis
First Appearance: Lunar Orbit, 2010
Appearance: Unclear. Photographs suggest 'tendrils' and at least one 'eye.' Size estimates from ground observation vary from ten meters across to two hundred meters across.
Status: Unknown (Moon) (Suspected)
Notes: Appeared in Lunar Orbit, moved at extreme speed, destroying all trans-atmospheric human constructions, manned or unmanned, disappeared behind dark side of the moon. Has not yet attacked any sub-atmospheric target. Abilities aside from rapid travel through vacuum unclear.
[h3][/h3]Ryujin
First Appearance: Nagazora, 2012
Appearance: Forty meter long 'western-style' dragon, 150m wingspan
Status: Unknown (Unknown)
Notes: Appeared near the center of Nagazora, Japan. Electrical manipulation and storms caused immediate mass casualty event, destroyed most technology in range. Very brief rampage, disappeared (apparent teleportation) mid-battle, without sustaining significant injury. Behavior noted as extremely atypical.
The fact that Behemoth and Leviathan are dead while the Simurgh stepped to the backstage, and we don't ACTUALLY know if every Endbringer is the same kind of Herrscher analogue that Ryujin (Mei) is, is very fascinating to me, the consistency of them being slain or inactive slants the worldstate much more closely to Honkai's Herrscher kill rate in a manner that's painting an eerie dissonance with the current Brockton Bay focus, but nothing actually confirms these are the same kinds of beings driven by the same kinds of goals, only that the general public has slotted them into the same category of "Endbringer" (probably a Honkai Beast Class here, what with the lack of discernable differences from just being an absurd monster instead of the distinctly human Herrscher).
I hope we never get WoG on this, I want to see this uncertainty play out until just the right moment of revelation in the story.