[X] Anya makes the most sense. Her reputation and experience will make her much more effective as a Slayer. Plus, D'Hoffryn's likely to approve as a judge, even if Anya's irrationally nervous about it. Hopefully those traces on the soul aren't just metaphorical.
It was possible that the blood would help. Maybe things with Harmony would go fine.
But there was no way of knowing. And she had a feeling the consequences could be extreme. Her power was sort of tamed, at least for now, but she didn't have any illusions that it was fully domesticated.
But Harmony had never really asked her for anything. She probably didn't really understand the magnitude of the risks, but she'd still be disappointed. Between that and Eris' bitchery last night, she had to make sure to smooth this over.
"Harmony," she started awkwardly, but then got close to her and put a hand around the back of her neck. She liked that. "It's not that I don't trust you or that I don't think you deserve it. But I'm really sure. It'd be too dangerous."
Her girlfriend slumped down and pouted, saying, "I guess you know best."
Buffy gave her a kiss on the nose and she visibly cheered up.
"Should I alert Zoe Berenson?" CyberWillow asked.
"Hey, wait just a second," Anya raised a finger in the air. "It's not like this isn't a group project! I agree that it's probably too dangerous to make a vampire into a slayer on your second try. But I'm human now, with a convenient landing strip already burned onto my soul. You don't have to worry about exploding me into dust or replacing me with my alternate self or any other obvious catastrophes."
"I still don't know what I'm doing!" Buffy repeated. "I barely know what I did the first time!"
"I don't care!" Anya said. "I understand the risks! I want it anyway!"
"Anya-" Buffy started, but was cut off.
"I'm over a thousand years old!" she said. "You don't need to treat me the same as a fledgling vampire."
"Hey!" Harmony objected.
"You should be on my side!" Anya argued. "How else is Buffy ever going to be confident enough to do mystical surgery on you if she doesn't do it on me first?"
"Why shouldn't it go the other way?" Harmony said. "I'm not five! I know the risks too, and I'm totally ready for anything Buffy does to me!"
"You guys need to calm it down! This could mess either of you up permanently!" Buffy said. "Couldn't it?"
"You'd better believe it, bucko," Skip confirmed. "A lot of the most unspeakable monstrosities around are the result of a botched mantlization. You should ask your buddy Pan about the Hecatoncheires sometime."
"I could be a Hecatoncheires," Harmony said confidently.
"Do you even know what a Hecatoncheires is?" Anya asked sarcastically.
"I totally do!" Harmony said. "They probably come from heck, right? And tie… bees?"
"It's almost as if she knows Greek," Skip said slyly.
Buffy rubbed her forehead, but couldn't think of anything to say. It was too early in the morning for this disaster of an argument.
Meanwhile, Anya was frustrated with Harmony's educational deficits. "Fine, new example. You've seen the Rat King. What if you ended up like that?"
That gave Harmony real pause. "Wait, isn't that different?"
"In a strict sense, yes," CyberWillow contributed. "However, it's not impossible that a similar perception-compromising effect could arise here."
"Wait, didn't you want me to go forward with this?" Buffy asked her.
"It would be an extremely interesting result, if a possibly unfortunate one," she answered. "To do true science, we must perform experiments."
"Harmony, I don't know what I'd do if I unspeakablified you into something," Buffy said. "It'd destroy me. And Anya, think about what Xander would say if you came back with three heads."
"This is about Xander now?" Anya said. "Fine then, we can break up. You can even rope him into your harem if you do this for me, no hard feelings."
"I'd have hard feelings!" Harmony said. "Eww!"
"Anya, what the hell?" Buffy just had absolutely no idea. "Where is this coming from?"
Anya sighed, visibly composing herself. "I should preface this by saying I don't like to whine about things I can't change."
That sounded about zero percent accurate, but Buffy was in too deep with this conversation already. She just nodded.
"Harmony, you love being a vampire right? Best thing since sliced bread?" Anya asked.
"Duh," she responded. "But I don't see what that has to do with Xander being in our harem!"
"I loved being a vengeance demon the same way," Anya said. "What I don't love? This." She gestured at herself. "I'm helpless, nobody respects me, and worst of all I'm aging. It's disgusting and I hate it!"
"I'm not sure how you expect me to solve that." Buffy said it with a mix of sarcasm and legitimate curiosity. "Becoming a slayer isn't good for your life expectancy."
"Becoming a one-warrior-bulwark against all the most powerful demons roaming Earth isn't good for your life expectancy," Anya countered. "Getting a huge durability upgrade and slow regeneration is great for your life expectancy! Do you know how long it ordinarily takes an ACL knee injury to heal?"
"Umm, a few days?" She thought she remembered Giles saying something about that once, when she came back with a limp.
"Months! Years! Sometimes it won't heal at all!" Anya ranted with a crazy look in her eye. "Slayers died because they operated without support, and that was probably because as we recently discovered the Watcher's council was terrified of them turning into psycho-killer versions of you. But do you want to know why normal humans die? For practically any reason you can think of! I could be sneezing one day and dead the next week!"
"But, I mean, Slayers still get old right, isn't that different?" Buffy asked, now thoroughly befuddled.
"Uncertain, and also uncertain," CyberWillow commented.
"It'll be close enough," Anya said it with a lot of confidence.
"And you don't want to wait for me to get some more experience first?" Buffy said. "I've almost got enough in me for two."
"Then what about me?" Harmony said indignantly.
"Umm," Buffy hesitated.
"It's important that it's me this time, politically," Anya said. "Having it be public and showy like this, it won't just be good for your score, it'll make waves, let me put more pressure on old contacts."
"I don't want any more people getting ahead in line!" Harmony continued her parallel argument, tugging insistently at Buffy's shirt.
"Fine!" Buffy waved her hands in the air. "But you need to find someone who has half a clue, so I can have a quarter of one before I do this."
"Sure, of course. I already have an idea," Anya nodded.
"And you have to be the one to call Xander and tell him," Buffy added.
"I'll do it right now," Anya agreed.
"And I still get to go after right?" Harmony said. "I don't want to get left behind!"
Buffy covered her eyes with her hands, trying to rub the headache away. It wasn't just from the hangover anymore either. "We'll see."
"That means yes!" Harmony cheered.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Buffy found herself enjoying this event. She turned another corner in the massive hedge maze, and here was Frosty the Snowman.
Well, probably not really, but it was some kind of giant snow elemental made of stacked snowballs, and even if it didn't have dead branches for arms it did have the carrot for a nose. It roared a challenge and charged her, eerily moving forward by rolling the bottom snowball.
KILL
She met its charge head-on, swiping up at it with her hammer to halt its progress. Unfortunately instead of stopping altogether when it was hit, the middle part totally imploded as the rest rolled into her, but it was a pretty hot day to be running around in a maze anyway. The snow was refreshing.
No time to bask in it though; she quickly extracted herself, squeezing between its bulk and the thorny wall to get behind the construct. It'd survived the destruction of its middle section by just having the top drop down to where it'd been, and that top spun around like a tank turret to track her as the bottom reversed direction to charge again.
KILL
The height it'd lost would cost it though. This time Buffy jumped up, kicking off a wall to get even more height. The head spun straight up to face her, but that didn't do it any good as she smashed her hammer down right into its carrot nose. Her strike took her down completely through the head and then sundered the body below, leaving her on top of a pile of suddenly inanimate snow.
She scrambled out and forward, ready to face a new challenge. None of the stuff in here was that dangerous, presumably because most people couldn't fight as well as she could, but there was a cute element of whimsy to them that lightened her spirits. If only the demons she'd grown up with had covered her in snow and flowers instead of slime and more slime.
She turned at the next junction and was momentarily surprised to face the exit! It was over already? Well at least-
Lethe was standing right in front of her, smiling mischievously, and the rest of the contestants were scattered all around the exit clearing. She was last, or close to it.
"That has to be cheating," Buffy muttered. It was obvious now that the point was just to finish the maze quickly, and not kill everything in it, but of course she'd forgotten that when it mattered. Lethe was so annoying.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
"I'm not sure how this is supposed to help with Anya," Buffy said.
"But I'm sure of how this will help with you," Echo said back to her in a copy of her voice. It was seriously disconcerting.
"Do you always have to do that?" Buffy asked.
"I don't literally always do it, but it's part of the process, it makes it easier. And this is seriously uncomfortable, so maybe like, make a tiny bit of an effort?" It wasn't just the voice; she had her verbiage down too. Sorta creepy.
She hadn't quite revealed to Pan what she wanted to do, but when she told him she was pushing her limits he'd all but thrown Echo at her to help. She was technically the competition, but Buffy couldn't afford to turn up her nose.
Buffy closed her eyes and felt at Echo with her extra senses. What she felt back was both foreign and familiar: supposedly, this was what her own domain felt like from the outside. And since piled under everything else, Buffy was technically still a potential, it came in way more clear than normal, given she'd already influenced her power towards looking at them.
The beach ball center didn't have distinct spines or anything, and instead was surrounded in layers of moving shadows. They would shift back and forth between all kinds of shapes even as she looked at them, and it was suddenly kind of obvious why she had so much trouble metaphysically grabbing onto things.
"Hey, hold onto this for a second, I have an idea," Buffy said. Without bothering to open her eyes, she took her hammer out of nowhere in specific and handed it to Echo.
Echo made a little noise and teetered when she took it before stabilizing. She made a catty-sounding comment, but Buffy tuned it out, watching closely. The shadows were more ordered now, twisting and turning around it. Kind of. This was definitely how she used it to grab onto Rachel. Without warning, she snatched the hammer back.
"Can you do that same spiral thing again now, without it?" It'd be a lot easier if she didn't have to use it as a crutch. And a lot less embarrassing than her looking like she was playing some kind of demented fishing game in front of everyone.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
"C'mon, you can do it, go, no, go that way!" Buffy tried to keep her voice level, but this was surprisingly stressful.
The little demon-dog-racoon thing stopped and turned to her, then got up on its hind legs and pawed at her shin. It was cute, but it wasn't going to win.
<Dratted creature! Cease this dithering or feel my tail blade!>
Luckily, the rest of the so-called Greater Beings weren't doing a much better job getting their tanuki demons to proceed through the race's obstacles. Even the psychic ones. Esplin's crazed ranting was definitely counterproductive; his tanuki was curled up in a ball with its head hidden under little paws.
Meanwhile, Elfangor had lowered himself down to the knees of his front legs and was locking (all four) eyes with his racer. Whatever he was saying wasn't being publicly broadcast, but at least wasn't causing the tanuki to panic in terror.
¿PlagueOfRats?
Her attention was drawn to the side, and she saw the Rat King of all people was finally making progress. You weren't allowed to pick your tanuki up, but his swarmy self was escorting it on both sides now like a royal procession, and the tanuki was contently marching up to the first obstacle in the arena.
Had it been his domain that'd let him do it? In a burst of inspiration, she thought she could try hers, with that thing she'd just managed to learn! She felt deep inside or maybe along herself, and twisted up those subjective shadows to reach out and give her tanuki a gentle tap, just something to get its attention…
KILL
There was an instant of pure terror in its eyes, and then it jumped away from her and dashed back into its starting box to hide.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
"Everything's way more chill if you have three outcomes ready to go," Kyle said. "Focusing on just one thing is super-harsh on the energy."
Willow's thricewise 'friend' was currently transformed into the guise of a typical surfer dude, complete with a board that had three little fins sticking out. Was there a surfing event happening at some point? She'd lost track.
Willow had said that he knew a ton about all kinds of magic and he could probably help, but Buffy was skeptical.
"This isn't really a horseshoes or hand grenades thing," Buffy tried to argue. "There might not be just one slayer anymore, but there's still one, well, type of slayer? I'm not sure I could turn Anya into anything else, and even if I could, it'd be a pretty bad idea, wouldn't it?"
"Just open your mind to all possibilities," he advised. "Let the universe carry you over the wave."
Buffy leveled a look at Willow.
"I know it sounds goofy, but he has a lot of experience!" Willow said defensively.
"I'm sure she's in as good a position to judge that as anyone," Skip snarked from the corner.
She blushed in response, and it looked surprisingly natural on the Willowbot. However skeevy Warren's advanced tech had turned out to be, she had to admit it was pretty revolutionary.
"Vanilla doesn't have to be the only flavor, man," Kyle continued. "There's sulfur too. And kittenblood."
"Hey, didn't you say you were vegetarian?" Willow asked.
"The ice cream isn't made from real kittens," Kyle explained. "They do it in a factory or something."
"Oh!" Willow looked chagrined. "Sorry for doubting you."
"It's cool girl, we all-"
"Actually," CyberWillow interrupted from the radios, "My past research indicated that Mad Moxie's Kittenblood Ice Cream is made with a gore slurry which includes parts of donkeys, goats, rabbits, and humans."
"No way!" Kyle exclaimed.
"It came up and was rejected for obvious reasons while investigating possible refreshment options for foreign dignitaries," CyberWillow continued.
"But this must be like, a big secret right?" Willow asked. "How did you find out?"
"It's written on the packaging in one millimeter font," CyberWillow explained.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
"Look, we might not like it, but we both want to win right?" Buffy said.
<I suppose that's true,> Esplin said reluctantly. The morph he was in seemed to be made of pieces of crystal, all optical surfaces and sharp angles, but he still managed to make a mulish expression somehow.
"Well, there's no changing things now," she continued. "We signed up to do this together a week ago, and everyone else is already paired up. So let's just be professional about it. Forget all the crazy plans, just for-"
<I'm not planning anything!> He declared
"You totally are," Buffy said. "Don't think I can't tell you can use that morph to make laser attacks or whatever. It won't catch me by surprise, so just don't try."
<Attacking you now would be idiotic. I'd never try such a transparent ploy.> He didn't sound very convincing, but she figured she'd at least headed that madness off at the pass. Then he changed the subject, <Are you sure you're even capable of the routine you gave me?>
"Oh, you'd better believe it. I used to live and breathe this stuff," Buffy cracked a smile.
Sure, it wasn't the best of circumstances, but she wouldn't let it get her down. Not for this event. The little girl inside her was practically squealing with delight.
"AND NOW, WELCOME MAYOR SUMMERS AND VISSER THREE, PERFORMING TO 'ANYTHING YOU CAN DO, I CAN DO BETTER!'"
A satyr threw open the little gate, and then they were both skating out onto the icy lake. Doubles Figure Skating was a more traditional event than she'd have expected from Pan, but she wasn't going to look a gift horse in the mouth.
"And just remember," she whispered, "If we lose? Elfangor and that weird fish girl win."
<Yes, yes, I get your point. Just prepare for your jump.>
Esplin caught her by the hand, flicked her off the ice, and she made six rotations in the air before coming back down. This one, she had in the bag.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
"And you won't believe what happened next!" Halfrek declared.
"Did Salricia dump him? Like, how couldn't she?" Anya was perched excitedly on one of the bean bags.
"She pulled the Dagger of Unlast out of her dress and eviscerated him with it in front of everyone!" Halfrek mimed the stabbing.
"Oh my gawd!" Harmony yelled, slumped over her own bean bag.
"But how did she know in advance?" Anya asked.
"That's the thing! She didn't! She'd been planning to gut Gharghar with it instead the whole time, over the South Delthrox thing, but the drama of it all just ran away with her," Halfrek answered.
"South Delthrox thing?" Anya echoed.
"Is South Delthrox like South LA? Is it a ghetto?" Harmony wondered.
"You poor girls, you're so behind the times," Halfrek made a sympathetic face at odds with the demon wrinklies she was currently sporting. "Let me fill you in!"
While Buffy had made some strides in controlling her weird domain powers, she still couldn't pick much of anything up from Anya, which would make slayerizing her difficult at best and impossible at worst. Anya had anticipated this though, and had an idea.
If Buffy was having a hard time detecting traces of vengeance demon, what better remedy for that was there than seeing the real thing? And even if she was leading one of the other teams, apparently Halfrek was a close enough friend of hers that she was willing to come over and be a guinea pig.
Of course, once she was here, the two of them started gossiping up a bizarre pseudo-vengeancey storm, somehow sucked Harmony into their orbit, and ultimately left her mostly to her own devices. Unfortunately, her own devices had so far been quiet and sad, like toys without batteries.
She could definitely tell Halfrek was there in a threat-sense. Her power helpfully gave her an instinct for how strong she'd be, how fast, and what her weaknesses were (she'd noticed a tendency to zero in on one person and ignore the rest of the environment that could be exploited in a fight.) And she could even tell she had a big something extra, something super-dangerous and wacky, which was obviously the wishing powers.
But she couldn't perceive her in that precise way she could the potentials, she didn't have that beach ball style read available. She'd tried convincing herself to just get it in the same frustrated way she'd gotten that sense going in the first place, but either she wasn't angry enough or she had to do something different.
"Still having trouble over there?" Halfrek said condescendingly, breaking her concentration. "Don't mind us, we're having a blast, but maybe you want to try something different?"
"I'm trying all the different I have," Buffy said, letting just a little bit of her irritation show. "Any suggestions?"
The question had been sarcastic, but Halfrek pursed her lips, deep in thought. She tilted her head back and forth, clearly weighing something, before finally saying, "How old are you? I'm getting mixed messages."
It was a non-sequitur if she'd ever heard one, but she didn't see why she shouldn't answer. "Eighteen."
"Hally, I'm not sure this is the best idea," Anya said.
"Oh lighten up, It's just some professional curiosity," Halfrek said. "There's a whiff of negligent authority here."
"Hey!" Buffy said. "I know that it's important for a mayor to be at her post, but everyone was telling me this was the sort of thing Sunnydale needed."
"Of course not your authority, honey," Halfrek giggled. "And maybe there's something with the mother?" She narrowed her eyes. "Child abandonment?"
"You're gonna have to make with the 'splainy." Buffy said.
"I exact justice, for children who've been wronged," Halfrek said. "Whether by parents, guardians, or the entire system that was supposed to help them. And even if you aren't exactly a child anymore, I'm getting the feeling you were certainly wronged as one. Besides, you're still quite young, by any reasonable standard."
"You want me to make a wi-" She stopped herself just in time. "You want me to make a W-word?"
"Oooh!" Harmony got even more excited than she already had been. "I bet you would make a really cool wish Buffy!" She said, totally forgetting to be careful with the word. "There could be a huge party, or a fight, or maybe a fighting party!"
"I don't know what kind of an impression I'm giving off these days, but I'm not really into creating whole alternate evil realities on a whim," Buffy objected. "What even brought this on?"
"Granting wishes uses the oldest, most powerful magic that a Vengeance demon possesses," Halfrek said. "If anything will call your attention to it and make you see, it'll be that. I bet it'd set your special vision up to 20/20."
"With the aforementioned minor side effect of creating an evil alternate reality," Buffy said sarcastically. Sure, she wanted to slayerize Anya and win the event, but this seemed like it was going way too far.
"Not all wishes have to be big and flashy," Halfrek said. "Certain people just had to always go the extra mile for the 'art'-"
"Hey!" Anya said.
"- but some of us appreciate bringing actual justice to the universe, and having the punishment fit the crime." Halfrek finished. "It doesn't have to be too big a deal, if you don't want it to be."
"You should do it Buffy," Harmony encouraged. "You need to, or else you're not going to be able to slayerize Anya and everything might be ruined! And anyone who was mean to you definitely deserves it anyway."
"I don't want to curse my mom!" Buffy shouted.
So she'd been difficult enough to make her want to move out, but that'd been like, a difference of opinion. And before that, she'd reacted to the slaying kind of badly, but it'd be a big shock to anyone. And there was whole mental institution thing, but it was just a mistake. Understandable really. Anyone could do it.
"It wouldn't have to be your mother, if you're not comfortable with that," Halfrek said. "Maybe your father? I'm getting the feeling he wasn't around much at all when you needed him, was he?"
"If I may suggest a compromise," CyberWillow intoned from the radio. "Quentin Travers certainly would count as an authority figure to you, and he absolutely has abused your trust on multiple occasions, once almost resulting in your and your mother's untimely demise."
"Yeah, curse him!" Harmony urged. "Give him boils!"
Buffy grit her teeth with worry, but she couldn't quite bring herself to object as strongly to that idea. "Anya, this is kind of your area?"
"Yes Anya, it's your area," Hally repeated.
"I don't want to take sides here," Anya raised her hands. "Not taking sides! But wishes should be treated with respect. Of course, I'm sure Hally wouldn't screw you on a wish backlash, it'd be stupid with someone as powerful as you and I know my friend better than that. But you shouldn't make a wish if you don't really want vengeance."
"Justice," Halfrek corrected.
"Vengeance," Anya rolled her eyes. "Because even the kind of wish that's shaped specifically to leave the wisher alone? It can still be pretty nasty for the target."
Vote: Does Buffy make a wish? It could help bigtime with Anya, but it seems like a dangerous bridge to cross.
[] Buffy makes a Wish. Being able to see Halfrek grant it will give her a major bonus on the very difficult upcoming roll.
-[] What's the wish? It has to target some authority figure that wronged Buffy in a child-adjacent sort of way.
[] This is a crazy idea, and Buffy shuts it down. She'll do her best to figure things out without that particular special boost.