Anime Rival Quest (Very Meta)

[X] [Combat] Traps worked the first time so toss down another one. See if she's learned anything.
-[X] Sneak in a second trap for when she avoids or breaks through the obvious one.
[X] [Bishie] No Bishie!

Not voting for a song cause I have no ability to properly assign themes. I know good music when I hear it but not music appropriate to the situation.

That and I just read the story, adding music slows my reading down.
 
Last edited:
Ohkay... So I would like to apologize. I was going to close the votes now, but the last leg of work had me sprinting around like a madperson so I am frigging beat right now.

On the upside, tomorrow is my day off, so I'll be leaving the votes open until I've slept and close them once I wake up. If things move quickly enough, I should even be able to do two or three updates tomorrow to make up for this wait.

Sorry for the delay everyone. See you when I'm less dead on my feet.
 
[X] [Combat] Traps worked the first time so toss down another one. See if she's learned anything.
-[X] Sneak in a second trap for when she avoids or breaks through the obvious one.

[X] [Bishie] Bishie!
 
We're a boy, Lilith-nee.

A peace sign and playful winks have been done before, though. I want our MC to do something a little more daring (but not in the NSFW sense) that Negaverse fans would make fanart based on it. If we want to be smug, then we should leverage our specialty in speed and knowledge of our rival's strength and force her to think of ways to overcome it.

And when she does, we easily slip past that and force her to go back to the drawing board as befitting of our spot as the character with the superior intellect.

Maybe a gentle nose-on-nose boop?

...You realize that reveal might come through us sustaining clothing damage that'll reveal our chiseled physique to the world, right?
I

I support reveal through

I

NOSE BOOP OR HEAD PAT WITH SUNSHINE CINNAMON BUN SMILE

Off duty self being a moe glasses cinnamon bun pure and gentle senpai character that still sassy is hnng

[X] [Combat] Write In: Take the Come Back Attack head-on.
-[X] Lower your Blaster, and give the Heroine the Look Of Utter Disappointment
-[X] Use Tolerance Points as need be to render the Come Back Attack completely useless, coming out of the exchange unscathed.

[X] [Bishie] Bishie!


Guys, you do realize that Bishounen are just hot guys and can totally have muscles and other manly attributes... Right? Like seriously most of the male anime characters around are bishounen o=o'
 
Last edited:
NOSE BOOP OR HEAD PAT WITH SUNSHINE CINNAMON BUN SMILE

Off duty self being a moe glasses cinnamon bun pure and gentle senpai character that still sassy is hnng
That is so jarring that even the viewers would be left gobsmacked come the reveal. I like it; smug and dangerously competent as a rival magic warrior but an adorable cinnamon bun when not in duty.

With quick nose boops and/or headpats for a hi/bye gesture.

Yessssss. Yesssssss , Slug likes dis.
 
[X] [Combat] Wait until the last possible moment, then deflect her attack with our gun before twirling it around to pistol whip her.
[X] [Theme] Silly Groose
[X] [Bishie] No Bishie!
 
thats literally a bishounen-esque character oh my god
That is so jarring that even the viewers would be left gobsmacked come the reveal. I like it; smug and dangerously competent as a rival magic warrior but an adorable cinnamon bun when not in duty.

With quick nose boops and/or headpats for a hi/bye gesture.

Yessssss. Yesssssss , Slug likes dis.
FUCK IT I MUST FIND A PICTURE MYSELF
 
That is so jarring that even the viewers would be left gobsmacked come the reveal. I like it; smug and dangerously competent as a rival magic warrior but an adorable cinnamon bun when not in duty.

With quick nose boops and/or headpats for a hi/bye gesture.

Yessssss. Yesssssss , Slug likes dis.
but how should the reveal work? Cinnamon bun and heroine get ambushed by the enemy general and we take a blow for her before drawing our weapon and doing a brutal beat down? attack on the school, she's on her last ropes after her power up failed and then we come to the rescue?
 
Today I learned that people will vote to be less attractive in a quest all about making the audience love you.
 
Today I learned that people will vote to be less attractive in a quest all about making the audience love you.
There's a difference between not looking girly and not being attractive. Just because a person isn't bishie doesn't mean they can only be ugly. We can go for the rugged good looks!
 
but how should the reveal work? Cinnamon bun and heroine get ambushed by the enemy general and we take a blow for her before drawing our weapon and doing a brutal beat down? attack on the school, she's on her last ropes after her power up failed and then we come to the rescue?
I was thinking something like this:
>mc and heroine are fighting a powerful enemy
>heroine screws up and gets beaten badly
>we move in and fight the enemy while the heroine regens the damage
>as we fight, we lose bits and pieces of our armor until only our mask remains
>heroine heals enough and saves us
>we look at her to say thanks, but then our mask falls off
>cue heroine going 'wtf senpai?!'

Or something like it.
 
I was thinking something like this:
>mc and heroine are fighting a powerful enemy
>heroine screws up and gets beaten badly
>we move in and fight the enemy while the heroine regens the damage
>as we fight, we lose bits and pieces of our armor until only our mask remains
>heroine heals enough and saves us
>we look at her to say thanks, but then our mask falls off
>cue heroine going 'wtf senpai?!'

Or something like it.
Depends really... that could be the final battle or something honestly. Depends on how much they want to shove the Rival and Heroine into interacting as the Rival and Heroine in civilian life.

I mean... maybe our mentor's know each other? Or something I guess.
 
[X] [Combat] Traps worked the first time so toss down another one. See if she's learned anything.
-[X] Sneak in a second trap for when she avoids or breaks through the obvious one.

[X] [Bishie] Bishie!
 
Last edited:
I was thinking something like this:
>mc and heroine are fighting a powerful enemy
>heroine screws up and gets beaten badly
>we move in and fight the enemy while the heroine regens the damage
>as we fight, we lose bits and pieces of our armor until only our mask remains
>heroine heals enough and saves us
>we look at her to say thanks, but then our mask falls off
>cue heroine going 'wtf senpai?!'

Or something like it.

Or, we could be a complete and utter Chuuni wherein we act (possibly actually true) weaker due to the 'Mask.'

>Season 1 Finale, Big Bad v1.0 ; Mini Boss Mode
>Rival gets a beatdown real quick. Pisses off Heroine.
>Heroine, even after repeatedly fighting against a Trap User, still charges in like she didn't learn anything.
>Gets Rekt'd, ~definitely~ not on purpose because Heroic Will Power barely ever starts when at Full HP. Yet still stands to protect her Rival.
>Banter about protecting one another, and "You're my important rival!"
>Rival decides to finally stop being a Tsundere, takes off his mask, then gets an 11th hour power up + dramatic reveal.

We're gonna have the in-universe audience fucking squeal.

Edit:

Also an actual vote:

[X] [Combat] Write In: Take the Come Back Attack head-on.
-[X] Lower your Blaster, and give the Heroine the Look Of Utter Disappointment
-[X] Use Tolerance Points as need be to render the Come Back Attack completely useless, coming out of the exchange unscathed.

[X] [Theme] Hero's Come Back
 
Last edited:
You know a bishie isn't necessarily an effeminate guy right? they are generally Just good looking men a classic bishie would be kenshin and a more current one is genos from one punch man.

Edit: to specify if your a attractive guy who's more on the pretty or handsome side of the spectrum your a bishie.
There's a difference between not looking girly and not being attractive. Just because a person isn't bishie doesn't mean they can only be ugly. We can go for the rugged good looks!
 
Last edited:
Depends really... that could be the final battle or something honestly. Depends on how much they want to shove the Rival and Heroine into interacting as the Rival and Heroine in civilian life.

I mean... maybe our mentor's know each other? Or something I guess.
inb4 our mentors try to ship us together
Or, we could be a complete and utter Chuuni wherein we act (possibly actually true) weaker due to the 'Mask.'

>Season 1 Finale, Big Bad v1.0 ; Mini Boss Mode
>Rival gets a beatdown real quick. Pisses off Heroine.
>Heroine, even after repeatedly fighting against a Trap User, still charges in like she didn't learn anything.
>Gets Rekt'd, ~definitely~ not on purpose because Heroic Will Power barely ever starts when at Full HP. Yet still stands to protect her Rival.
>Banter about protecting one another, and "You're my important rival!"
>Rival decides to finally stop being a Tsundere, takes off his mask, then gets an 11th hour power up + dramatic reveal.

We're gonna have the in-universe audience fucking squeal.
That'd be amazing, I'll admit.
 
You know a bishie isn't necessarily an effeminate guy right? they are generally Just good looking men a classic bishie would be kenshin and a more current one is genos from one punch man.
Except that Spectral is defining Bishie as exactly that.
inb4 our mentors try to ship us together
inb4 The production company didn't want the Rival and Heroine shipped and so make them brother and sister via the Mentors being their parents and they were separated at birth.

:V

Welcome to Gundam Seed, the dick move.

On a less "Oh Fuck You!" note, I've been seeing these two as the (potential) mentors for now:

Which would you say fits which of our two protags?
 
Except that Spectral is defining Bishie as exactly that.

inb4 The production company didn't want the Rival and Heroine shipped and so make them brother and sister via the Mentors being their parents and they were separated at birth.

:V

Welcome to Gundam Seed, the dick move.

On a less "Oh Fuck You!" note, I've been seeing these two as the (potential) mentors for now:

Which would you say fits which of our two protags?

If limited to those two, the guy's definitely the Heroine's Mentor. Halo Girl is the Rival's. Mostly cause I want their master's personalities bleeding into them, and that's a little thing I'd really like our characters to realize and get past in order to become generally better Protectors.
 
Except that Spectral is defining Bishie as exactly that.

inb4 The production company didn't want the Rival and Heroine shipped and so make them brother and sister via the Mentors being their parents and they were separated at birth.

:V

Welcome to Gundam Seed, the dick move.

On a less "Oh Fuck You!" note, I've been seeing these two as the (potential) mentors for now:

Which would you say fits which of our two protags?
If limited to those two, the guy's definitely the Heroine's Mentor. Halo Girl is the Rival's. Mostly cause I want their master's personalities bleeding into them, and that's a little thing I'd really like our characters to realize and get past in order to become generally better Protectors.
What @Taka said.

My personal headcanon in this case is that both mentors are melee specialists, but only the Heroine followed in her mentor's footsteps.

Our MC got so fed up with his mentor being such an uptight bitch that he became a ranged specialist just to spite her and run circles around her during spars; ie, keeping out of melee range, running away when she tries to close the distance, recoil-dodging, etc.
 
Or, we could be a complete and utter Chuuni wherein we act (possibly actually true) weaker due to the 'Mask.'

>Season 1 Finale, Big Bad v1.0 ; Mini Boss Mode
>Rival gets a beatdown real quick. Pisses off Heroine.
>Heroine, even after repeatedly fighting against a Trap User, still charges in like she didn't learn anything.
>Gets Rekt'd, ~definitely~ not on purpose because Heroic Will Power barely ever starts when at Full HP. Yet still stands to protect her Rival.
>Banter about protecting one another, and "You're my important rival!"
>Rival decides to finally stop being a Tsundere, takes off his mask, then gets an 11th hour power up + dramatic reveal.

We're gonna have the in-universe audience fucking squeal.

Edit:

Also an actual vote:

[X] [Combat] Write In: Take the Come Back Attack head-on.
-[X] Lower your Blaster, and give the Heroine the Look Of Utter Disappointment
-[X] Use Tolerance Points as need be to render the Come Back Attack completely useless, coming out of the exchange unscathed.

[X] [Theme] Hero's Come Back
I've been imagining us pulling kind of a "I can't watch you die too!" thing were we spin things as having watched other magical girls die in front of us and we're forcing her to either get good or quit so we don't have to watch her die. like maybe after the reveal when she demands to know why we have been doing things and we start listing off names of all the magical girls that we've been forced to watch die dispite our best efforts to help them.
 
If limited to those two, the guy's definitely the Heroine's Mentor. Halo Girl is the Rival's. Mostly cause I want their master's personalities bleeding into them, and that's a little thing I'd really like our characters to realize and get past in order to become generally better Protectors.
What @Taka said.

My personal headcanon in this case is that both mentors are melee specialists, but only the Heroine followed in her mentor's footsteps.

Our MC got so fed up with his mentor being such an uptight bitch that he became a ranged specialist just to spite her and run circles around her during spars; ie, keeping out of melee range, running away when she tries to close the distance, recoil-dodging, etc.
Those are just the two I'm seeing right now. Who knows what they'll actually end up being.

Also, yeah, I was seeing it the same as Taka. Genjuro for her, Halo Lady for us.
 
Back
Top