You consider things for a long moment, glancing between the files and your new… guest, "Trixie's problems seem to keep growing – It's about time we sorted them out. Let us begin with..." you make a decision, "...Working out what to do with our new guest," you say as you turn to the cart.
"Yes!" Chromia does a little hoof-pump as she grabs the cart and starts pushing it toward her room, "This way, ma'am! I've got a few ideas I've always wanted to try!" Well, you think, you didn't want to do this in sight of Silver anyhow.
"By all means, lead the way," you say as you follow behind her, crossing the hall and into her room. As soon as you're inside, the bat pony ditches the car in the middle of the room as she begins dousing every source of light in the room. You watch her run about for a minute before asking, "Chromia, what are you doing?"
"Setting the atmosphere!" she explains as the last magelight lamp dies and she grabs a chair to drag to the middle of the room, "You remove any indicator of where and when you are, get rid of any sort of environmental cues and then they can't get any sort of bearing. They start filling in the missing details with their own worst nightmares."
You feel a small smirk grow on your face, "The scariest monster is the one you never see, is it? Trixie is reminded of her own work."
"All about showing them what you want them to see, right?" Chomia replies as digs into a bag by the bed and pulls out a coil of rope that soon joins the chair. She considers the scene for a moment, tapping at her chin, "Hrm… it's missing something… Oh! Hold on a minute." Without further preamble, she dashes to the door, light briefly flooding inside as she ducked into the hall.
You stare after her for a moment.
Well, she's certainly enthusiastic. Wonder when the last time she got to do this was?
"Probably never, Trixie thinks," you reply as the door swings open again, this time staying open as Chromia rolls in, "...is that a brazier?"
"Yup!" Chromia replies as she rolls the oversized piece of metalwork into place just in front of the chair. She gives it a few nudges before nodding and collecting a few more objects from her bags and tossing them into the brazier, "Perfect! Now just to tie him up."
You watch the bat pony trot over to the cart, tossing aside a bits of garbage to reveal the still comatose stallion before grabbing him and…
…failing to move him despite what looks like considerable effort, "...Problems, Chromia?"
"I'm fine!" she replies quickly as she keeps trying, "Stupid… cart… no… leverage…"
Oh, come on and help her.
With a roll of your eyes you lift the stallion out of the trash bin and settle him into the chair with a burst of levitation. Chromia glances between the stallion and you briefly before she begins tying him up, "I almost had it..."
"Sure you did," you reply as you glance around, "...Trixie is not sure this is dark enough…."
"Super night vision, remember?" Chromia replies as she finishes the knots, "To him this is pitch black..." she stands up from behind the chair with a frown as she adds, "Actually – you never did say how you got that..."
"Cultist shenanigans, Trixie assumes," you reply with a shrug before gesturing at the stallion with a wave of your hoof, "Now, shall we begin…?"
"Yup," Chromia replies with a nod, taking a seat on the floor opposite the brazier from the chair before glancing back at you, "...could you back up a few steps? I don't want you visible until the opportune moment,"
"Very well," you back up a few steps, "And how will Trixie know the opportune moment?"
"I'm sure you'll figure it out," she replies as she turns to your prisoner, "I'm waking him up now," She reaches under her wing and tosses a small vial into the brazier. In the dark, you can just make out a faint curling of what could be smoke before the smell of salt and flowers hits you. It seems to hit the stallion too as he begins to stir.
"...wha?" the stallion slurs as he slowly returns to consiousness, "Wha…? Where am…?"
"You have been a very naughty pony," Chromia says softly, pitching her voice just right, her voice echoing around the room, "Getting into things that are not yours..."
"I do not answer to you, whoever you are!" the stallion shouts back, head swiveling as he tries to find the speaker, "I answer only to my goddess and her disciples!"
"Oh?" At that moment, the brazier bursts into blue flames and illuminates Chromia's fanged grin in stark contrasts, "And what if she has forsaken you?"
"My goddess will not abandon me, False Messenger!" the stallion hisses back, "Your words shall not sway me. I will not stray from Her divine will!"
Oh really?
"And what," you say as you slowly stride forward, the words spilling from your lips before you realize what you're saying, "Makes you think that the will you follow is mine?"
"The Sacrifice," the stallion says as he watches you, the way he stresses the last word making it sound like an insult, "You are but a petty vessel for Her Divine..." his voice trails off as you pace around the brazier, shadows slowly licking around your hooves and up your legs. Your eyes glow as they bore into the stallion, and his jaw drops open as you set your mane billowing for good measure. Stars and Stones, you love illusion magic.
Hey! Some of that is me!
"False messengers seduce my wayward herd to lead them onto fallow ground," you say as you pace around the stallion, "defiling my name with unclean acts. You will answer our questions – or you will learn the true meaning of judgment." The stallion nods weakly, "Good," you glance at Chromia and see that she is staring at you in… a mix of surprise and awe. You smirk a little as you give her a little nod and a wink.
This seems to be enough to snap her out of her daze as she turns back to the prisoner, "What were you planning with the files?"
"M-my master's desired to know the weakness of those who would stand before us," he stammered, "They fear that others may take this interference as proof that we should delay the Grand Retour."
"What others?" Chromia demands, "And what is the Grand Retour?"
"It is the rightful return of our goddess," the stallion explains, "Some believe that our actions to bring this about are… impudent. That the Goddess will signal to us when the time is right. The others – like my masters – believe it is our sacred duty to bring our goddess back to this physical plane so that she might take her rightful place and-"
"yeah, yeah, we get it-" Chromia cuts him off, "So – some of you don't want to wait, and some of you want to ensure she comes back now."
"And where does murdering innocent ponies come into this?" You hiss.
The stallion's head swings around to stare at you in surprise, "W-what?"
"Innocent ponies," you repeat, "Like the Silvers – where does murdering them come into play?"
"My master strictly forbids killings like that!" the stallion stammers, quailing under your gaze. You're stare continues to bore into him, and he realizes that this is a signal to continue, "B-but, others are… less restrained. They think that such mistakes will not matter soon enough."
"Which others?" You ask, one hoof pressing the stallion back in the chair, "Where can I find those who would dare murder innocent souls in My Name? Where are those who dare to pass Judgment in my stead?"
"I don't know!" the stallion nearly wails, "I am but a humble acolyte! The council has forbidden such acts! They decree that we must remain unseen until we finish the Transmigration. Those who act against such order do so in the shadows."
"You will give us something useful, pony," you growl, "Or you will suffer."
"I don't know anything else, I swear!" the stallion blubbers as he is faced with the visage of an angry goddess, "Please don't kill me!"
"Oh for the love of-" you mutter as you nod to Chromia, who nods in reply before dosing the stallion again. After a moment he slumps in the chair, comatose. You groan as you let your illusion drop, "Well, that was useless..."
"Not really," Chromia replies, "I mean – if what he said is true – then we know that the cult has internal fractures. That they're supposed to be subtle. Now – what hasn't been subtle?"
You blink owlishly as the realization hits you, "The attack on the cafe!"
"Exactly," Chromia says with a nod, "The ambushes in the alley and the cellar probably qualify as 'subtle' for them. Attacking a room full of civilians? Not so much."
"Then we have another pony to talk to..." you say, turning and heading for the door before something occurs to you, "Um..." you turn and look back at Chromia, "What do we do with him?"
Chromia looks between you and the stallion, "Um… throw him in a ditch?"
[ ] Throw him in a ditch.
[ ] Bring him to the guards and hope they don't believe half of what he tells them.
[ ] See if you can erase his memories with the Shadow's help.
[ ] To Tartarus with it – ask Twilight.
[ ] Write-in