Central Planning, Fantasy Edition

[X]Decline. A ministerial head must be well-rounded regardless of their own biases. Not shying away from any aspect of development is crucial.

[X] While a massive demand for more metamaterials is only expected to increase, it may be prudent to shift current efforts towards a more detailed investigation of the underlying nature of Glimurn. The last time such a thing was attempted it failed, but now we are better prepared with more knowledge and better equipment, as well as possible local allies. It will not produce anything of note but knowledge on how to proceed, however. (Glimurn Crystal Caverns Scientific Expeditions) (20 Resources per dice 150/250)

[X] Drag them into the light: In the end, this is an underhanded and sneaky attempt to slip so called reforms by when people are not paying attention. Spearheading a loud and aggressively public investigation into conflicts of interest and allegations of corruption would be a political bomb shell with difficult to predict consequences, but perhaps better than a literal one. The only real drawback is that like some other options under consideration it could cause unrest and weaken the nation.
[X] Push for financial services: The primary barrier between someone with a good idea to fulfill a demand for the people, and them actually doing it, is access to enough money to form a cooperative. The occasional ministry incentives or contracts to try and develop specific sectors is not enough, and access to loans for validly formed cooperatives will increase the economy's adaptability without giving the corruptive forces of capitalist accumulation a toehold. There will have to be regulations to prevent exploitation as always, but it is better than allowing private enterprises.
 
[X] While a massive demand for more metamaterials is only expected to increase, it may be prudent to shift current efforts towards a more detailed investigation of the underlying nature of Glimurn. The last time such a thing was attempted it failed, but now we are better prepared with more knowledge and better equipment, as well as possible local allies. It will not produce anything of note but knowledge on how to proceed, however. (Glimurn Crystal Caverns Scientific Expeditions) (20 Resources per dice 150/250)

[X] Drag them into the light: In the end, this is an underhanded and sneaky attempt to slip so called reforms by when people are not paying attention. Spearheading a loud and aggressively public investigation into conflicts of interest and allegations of corruption would be a political bomb shell with difficult to predict consequences, but perhaps better than a literal one. The only real drawback is that like some other options under consideration it could cause unrest and weaken the nation.

[X] Push for financial services: The primary barrier between someone with a good idea to fulfill a demand for the people, and them actually doing it, is access to enough money to form a cooperative. The occasional ministry incentives or contracts to try and develop specific sectors is not enough, and access to loans for validly formed cooperatives will increase the economy's adaptability without giving the corruptive forces of capitalist accumulation a toehold. There will have to be regulations to prevent exploitation as always, but it is better than allowing private enterprises.

[X] Threaten to blow up the coalition: The careless attitudes of the Grey bloc have gone too far in allowing this idea into circulation. While it's true that something must be done to deal with the consumer goods situation, the entire revolution was about rejecting the endless hungering maw of greed and accumulation. From here it will be wage reforms, and then repealing of overtime law and other worker protections, and then mechanisms of debt slavery. To this we must say 'No'! We cannot work with a faction that would sacrifice the soul of the nation to make a balance sheet look better!


Coups, even those done with the best of intentions, have a tendency to be pretty bad for the long-term and short-term political health of a nation.
 
Have faith in the people! Once we bring their duplicity to light, the people will surely be with us! We must have faith in the revolutionary masses!

Precisely, the people have spent decades experiencing the benefits of the revolutionary system and have two brutal wars post revolution against the footsoldiers of capital to remind them of why they fought the revolution in the first place, they will not stand for this

[X] Drag them into the light: In the end, this is an underhanded and sneaky attempt to slip so called reforms by when people are not paying attention. Spearheading a loud and aggressively public investigation into conflicts of interest and allegations of corruption would be a political bomb shell with difficult to predict consequences, but perhaps better than a literal one. The only real drawback is that like some other options under consideration it could cause unrest and weaken the nation.
 
[X] Acquiesce. Services department returns to normal for the next Five Year Plan. Infrastructure department gains Staver's bonuses going forward.
[X] While a massive demand for more metamaterials is only expected to increase, it may be prudent to shift current efforts towards a more detailed investigation of the underlying nature of Glimurn. The last time such a thing was attempted it failed, but now we are better prepared with more knowledge and better equipment, as well as possible local allies. It will not produce anything of note but knowledge on how to proceed, however. (Glimurn Crystal Caverns Scientific Expeditions) (20 Resources per dice 150/250)
[X] Threaten to blow up the coalition: The careless attitudes of the Grey bloc have gone too far in allowing this idea into circulation. While it's true that something must be done to deal with the consumer goods situation, the entire revolution was about rejecting the endless hungering maw of greed and accumulation. From here it will be wage reforms, and then repealing of overtime law and other worker protections, and then mechanisms of debt slavery. To this we must say 'No'! We cannot work with a faction that would sacrifice the soul of the nation to make a balance sheet look better!
 
>People don't want to pick the radical options that would fix the situation
>Vote for the option that says "The only real drawback is that like some other options under consideration it could cause unrest and weaken the nation"

:V

This will bite us in the ass I can't wait for the union to collapse back into capitalism
 
>People don't want to pick the radical options that would fix the situation
>Vote for the option that says "The only real drawback is that like some other options under consideration it could cause unrest and weaken the nation"

:V

This will bite us in the ass I can't wait for the union to collapse back into capitalism
>doubting the wisdom of the masses
>expecting a "Great (Wo)Man" to fix the issue

I name you a crypto-Stalinist liberal!
 
[x] Decline. A ministerial head must be well-rounded regardless of their own biases. Not shying away from any aspect of development is crucial.
[x] While a massive demand for more metamaterials is only expected to increase, it may be prudent to shift current efforts towards a more detailed investigation of the underlying nature of Glimurn. The last time such a thing was attempted it failed, but now we are better prepared with more knowledge and better equipment, as well as possible local allies. It will not produce anything of note but knowledge on how to proceed, however. (Glimurn Crystal Caverns Scientific Expeditions) (20 Resources per dice 150/250)
[x] Threaten to blow up the coalition: The careless attitudes of the Grey bloc have gone too far in allowing this idea into circulation. While it's true that something must be done to deal with the consumer goods situation, the entire revolution was about rejecting the endless hungering maw of greed and accumulation. From here it will be wage reforms, and then repealing of overtime law and other worker protections, and then mechanisms of debt slavery. To this we must say 'No'! We cannot work with a faction that would sacrifice the soul of the nation to make a balance sheet look better!
[x] Drag them into the light: In the end, this is an underhanded and sneaky attempt to slip so called reforms by when people are not paying attention. Spearheading a loud and aggressively public investigation into conflicts of interest and allegations of corruption would be a political bomb shell with difficult to predict consequences, but perhaps better than a literal one. The only real drawback is that like some other options under consideration it could cause unrest and weaken the nation.
[x] Push for financial services: The primary barrier between someone with a good idea to fulfill a demand for the people, and them actually doing it, is access to enough money to form a cooperative. The occasional ministry incentives or contracts to try and develop specific sectors is not enough, and access to loans for validly formed cooperatives will increase the economy's adaptability without giving the corruptive forces of capitalist accumulation a toehold. There will have to be regulations to prevent exploitation as always, but it is better than allowing private enterprises.
 
[X] Drag them into the light: In the end, this is an underhanded and sneaky attempt to slip so called reforms by when people are not paying attention. Spearheading a loud and aggressively public investigation into conflicts of interest and allegations of corruption would be a political bomb shell with difficult to predict consequences, but perhaps better than a literal one. The only real drawback is that like some other options under consideration it could cause unrest and weaken the nation.

[X] Push for financial services: The primary barrier between someone with a good idea to fulfill a demand for the people, and them actually doing it, is access to enough money to form a cooperative. The occasional ministry incentives or contracts to try and develop specific sectors is not enough, and access to loans for validly formed cooperatives will increase the economy's adaptability without giving the corruptive forces of capitalist accumulation a toehold. There will have to be regulations to prevent exploitation as always, but it is better than allowing private enterprises.
 
[X]Decline. A ministerial head must be well-rounded regardless of their own biases. Not shying away from any aspect of development is crucial.

[X] The Wall of Flesh and any similar threats can be dealt with now that we know they will be a regular occurrence. By installing purpose-built military hardware and war-spellframes, even grave threats can be properly addressed with fortifications and explosives. Through this method, extraction of metamaterials that are extremely valuable for pioneering magical research and development can quickly expand. (Glimurn Crystal Caverns Mine Expansion (Stage 5)) (30 Resources per dice 150/300)

[X] Drag them into the light: In the end, this is an underhanded and sneaky attempt to slip so called reforms by when people are not paying attention. Spearheading a loud and aggressively public investigation into conflicts of interest and allegations of corruption would be a political bomb shell with difficult to predict consequences, but perhaps better than a literal one. The only real drawback is that like some other options under consideration it could cause unrest and weaken the nation.

Tally ho! Definitely an incendiary bomb politically speaking, but in my opinion much preferable to using our archmage powers to vaporize a fourth of the political establishment and then getting put down like a mad dog. Or failing to do a coup.
 
the big thing that we have to absolutely commit to if we go through with drag to the light is that we HAVE to invest into congoods. literally non-negotiable, we need to slow down our hi and mag ind investments and fix the issue. if we don't the reactionaries will ""have a point"" and they actually gain power from this. so i know it may go against our brainworms, but we need to focus on this, and we need to do so in a way that the populace will visibly see us do. this is as much a matter of propaganda as it is politics
 
the big thing that we have to absolutely commit to if we go through with drag to the light is that we HAVE to invest into congoods. literally non-negotiable, we need to slow down our hi and mag ind investments and fix the issue. if we don't the reactionaries will ""have a point"" and they actually gain power from this. so i know it may go against our brainworms, but we need to focus on this, and we need to do so in a way that the populace will visibly see us do. this is as much a matter of propaganda as it is politics
That probably wouldn't hurt, but I don't think it'll solve the issue. The reason why the Greens have the opportunity to push this is because centrally planned ConGoods projects are not good at fulfilling demand, either under or overshooting what's needed. What we really need to do is boost the private sector, which is one of the reasons why I'm considering removing my approval vote for exposure, since having a financial services industry should do wonders for the private sector.
 
That probably wouldn't hurt, but I don't think it'll solve the issue. The reason why the Greens have the opportunity to push this is because centrally planned ConGoods projects are not good at fulfilling demand, either under or overshooting what's needed. What we really need to do is boost the private sector, which is one of the reasons why I'm considering removing my approval vote for exposure, since having a financial services industry should do wonders for the private sector.
my dude, the whole point of this is to either not have a private sector, or to have as little of one as possible. central planning is not good at responding quickly to public demand, because it's a centrally planned agency. it is still good at fulfilling the demand that it recognizes. what we need to is find a way to answer these problems: determining where a shortfall is, how to meet that shortfall, how to allocate resources to meet that shortfall, then determining if you've overshot and doing all of this quickly. a private sector isn't needed to answer these questions, it's just the one that we, as people in a capitalist society, default to.

one way to do this is to allow flexibility in a factory's production, with them being equipped for production of goods in a certain category. with the factories in communication with the stores for what consumer goods are needed, and able to switch between lines. that's one conventional way to answer the question.

however in universe we have magic, if we need to keep track of how many of toaster x is needed we could use magic to scry a region to see how much we need to produce to fix the data issue. have a data scrying enterprise keep track of how many toasters are needed and where through scrying, then we have a, to borrow from soviet quest, cybernetic mechanism to control the economy's consumer goods with
 
We need to work on the consumer goods aspect regardless of what happens. Leaving it undealt with leaves the Union open to such an attempt at a later date.
How we deal with it is not as important right now.
 
[X] Acquiesce. Services department returns to normal for the next Five Year Plan. Infrastructure department gains Staver's bonuses going forward.

[X] The Wall of Flesh and any similar threats can be dealt with now that we know they will be a regular occurrence. By installing purpose-built military hardware and war-spellframes, even grave threats can be properly addressed with the power of fortifications. Through this method, extraction of metamaterials that are extremely valuable for pioneering magical research and development can quickly expand. (Glimurn Crystal Caverns Mine Expansion (Stage 5)) (30 Resources per dice 150/300)

[X] Push for financial services: The primary barrier between someone with a good idea to fulfill a demand for the people, and them actually doing it, is access to enough money to form a cooperative. The occasional ministry incentives or contracts to try and develop specific sectors is not enough, and access to loans for validly formed cooperatives will increase the economy's adaptability without giving the corruptive forces of capitalist accumulation a toehold. There will have to be regulations to prevent exploitation as always, but it is better than allowing private enterprises.
 
[X]Decline. A ministerial head must be well-rounded regardless of their own biases. Not shying away from any aspect of development is crucial.

[X] While a massive demand for more metamaterials is only expected to increase, it may be prudent to shift current efforts towards a more detailed investigation of the underlying nature of Glimurn. The last time such a thing was attempted it failed, but now we are better prepared with more knowledge and better equipment, as well as possible local allies. It will not produce anything of note but knowledge on how to proceed, however. (Glimurn Crystal Caverns Scientific Expeditions) (20 Resources per dice 150/250)

[X] Push for financial services: The primary barrier between someone with a good idea to fulfill a demand for the people, and them actually doing it, is access to enough money to form a cooperative. The occasional ministry incentives or contracts to try and develop specific sectors is not enough, and access to loans for validly formed cooperatives will increase the economy's adaptability without giving the corruptive forces of capitalist accumulation a toehold. There will have to be regulations to prevent exploitation as always, but it is better than allowing private enterprises.
 
I'm down with the idea of some more dice on con-goods.

I also have no issue with small private industry. I'd expect entrepreneurs to be more responsive but if they scale up too much I'd also want the state to either nationalize parts of their business (at a more than fair market rate or like letting them keep minority ownership) or to split the company. I'm not certain where to draw the line but preventing companies from getting too large might help maintain a closer knit mindset and also force companies to collaborate without as many incentives to try and weaken each other in the marketplace. Flooding a market or screwing parts of your supply chain are less attractive if your company won't survive trying to gobble up their remains at a discount and being smaller might improve responsiveness.

It likely caps the maximum complexity on products that any cooperative could make but it feels like at a consumer level this wouldn't be too negative for another 20-30 years. By then hopefully the state has the tools to be more responsive or else the cooperative system is better managed.
 
my dude, the whole point of this is to either not have a private sector, or to have as little of one as possible. central planning is not good at responding quickly to public demand, because it's a centrally planned agency. it is still good at fulfilling the demand that it recognizes. what we need to is find a way to answer these problems: determining where a shortfall is, how to meet that shortfall, how to allocate resources to meet that shortfall, then determining if you've overshot and doing all of this quickly. a private sector isn't needed to answer these questions, it's just the one that we, as people in a capitalist society, default to.

one way to do this is to allow flexibility in a factory's production, with them being equipped for production of goods in a certain category. with the factories in communication with the stores for what consumer goods are needed, and able to switch between lines. that's one conventional way to answer the question.

however in universe we have magic, if we need to keep track of how many of toaster x is needed we could use magic to scry a region to see how much we need to produce to fix the data issue. have a data scrying enterprise keep track of how many toasters are needed and where through scrying, then we have a, to borrow from soviet quest, cybernetic mechanism to control the economy's consumer goods with
Thing is, the private sector is pretty damn good at solving those problems. So long as the staples are provided by the state, most, if not all of the issues with a private sector can be addressed, or at least heavily mitigated.

I don't think your conventional solution is a s foolproof as you think. It will be expensive, in ways both direct and indirect. Equipping a facility to produce multiple different products will cost significantly more in terms of machinery and employee cross-training than a more traditional facility would. Plus there's the maintenance costs of whatever equipment is being left idle, and the fact that economies of scale dictate that said factories will be less efficient than mono-focused equivalents of the same size. I don't think we'd get much support for that if any when coops do the job cheaply yet well.

As for magic, I don't think it works like that. From what we've seen, magic in this setting is mostly just capable of doing stuff that would be doable using early to mid twentieth century technology.
 
As for magic, I don't think it works like that. From what we've seen, magic in this setting is mostly just capable of doing stuff that would be doable using early to mid twentieth century technolog
Magic, in this setting, has been shown to be able to do *literally anything*. The issue is cost efficiency, not capability.
 
As for magic, I don't think it works like that. From what we've seen, magic in this setting is mostly just capable of doing stuff that would be doable using early to mid twentieth century technology.
This is largely a result of choosing a material science focused first minister; He went with steel and steam because it's what he knew, it was something that could be scaled rapidly without relying on weirdos in pointy hats muttering and chanting, and it was less expensive than same. The first industries in the union were focused on mining, refining, steam, machinery. The first generation of Chelskan engineers learned on that diet of steam and steel, and continued with more of the same, supplementing with magic when necessary but only where it made things massively easier, and continued with more of the same.

You have weird shit- Flying ships, portals, magic shields and fireballs and acid splash and all sorts of other killy things in addition to the old standby of 'gun' and 'bomb', body-transforming magic, literal healing potions, chairs that make you meditate and cultivate mana like a wuxia protagonist, trees that make meat, mining machines that literally minecraft-ify rock instead of crushing it with big metal teeth, and magic potatoes, and children's toy horses that really will run around in herds, and telekinesis based earthmoving for major construction projects, where a crane operator uses the magic of his mind instead of levers and hydraulics, and magic swamps and forests where the plants are always fruiting, run by a surly tradition of tree-huggers. You also have a lot of other, more familiar seeming stuff. Lightbulbs and trucks and houses and plastic. Because people want to fly and be super strong and do silly fun things, yes, and they can do that with the PMDs, potions, spells, and other things. But people also want nice houses and warm food and ways to move shit around and news from afar and ways to kill their enemies. And the most cost-effective solutions for those things, as devised by a burgeoning industrial power that decided to lean into the material manufacturing and standardization as their strength, do look kind of familiar, really, don't they?

Is not the true measure of a society, the quality of life and variety of products available to the average consumer? Praise God and Costco, for both hath brought prosperity untold in the sheer variety of options. Four types of fried fish sticks and three different flavors of grapes. Cheap cookware and two dozen types of delicious salty snacks. A shirt and pants that cost two or three hours' labor instead of dozens and more of hand spinning rough wool. Industrial mass production is perhaps the single greatest benefit to sapient-kind in the history of forever, despite all the side effects and bad consequences, despite the lives condemned to drudgery and deaths in the name of Number Go Up, often what that number represents- Not perfectly, not always, but often- Is a kid who has toothpaste to brush his teeth with, so he doesn't have lifelong dental pain. A grandma who can speak to her gandchildren across the sea. A man who dreamed of flying finding himself aloft in the sky on a great ship of steam and steel and wood and magic, wonder in his eyes.

( Am very tired while writing this, it might not make much sense )

(Also, if you want magic augury-computers to predict what goods are needed where... Maybe do the one magic computing project that's currently available to develop the sector: Basic Automation Programs?)
 
Last edited:
[X] Acquiesce. Services department returns to normal for the next Five Year Plan. Infrastructure department gains Staver's bonuses going forward.
[X] While a massive demand for more metamaterials is only expected to increase, it may be prudent to shift current efforts towards a more detailed investigation of the underlying nature of Glimurn. The last time such a thing was attempted it failed, but now we are better prepared with more knowledge and better equipment, as well as possible local allies. It will not produce anything of note but knowledge on how to proceed, however. (Glimurn Crystal Caverns Scientific Expeditions) (20 Resources per dice 150/250)
[X] Drag them into the light: In the end, this is an underhanded and sneaky attempt to slip so called reforms by when people are not paying attention. Spearheading a loud and aggressively public investigation into conflicts of interest and allegations of corruption would be a political bomb shell with difficult to predict consequences, but perhaps better than a literal one. The only real drawback is that like some other options under consideration it could cause unrest and weaken the nation.
 
[X] Direct action: It is clear that poisonous ideas have infiltrated the politics of the conservative bloc. With corruption, racism, and other frustrating blockheaded issues constantly coming from their direction, we have tried to work with them anyway and been repaid with more issues. It is now perhaps time to take decisive and personal action in removing obvious threats to the future of peace and cooperation, before the rot can fester further. After all, who can actually stop a determined archmage acting in the best interests of the nation? (Radical)

[X] Arrange a radical shift: Now is not the time for hesitation or cowardice and any action, even violent ones, are necessary to prevent these rotten ideas from taking root. We have tolerated corruption, racism, and selfishness from these reactionaries for too long, and even now conservatives arrange sinecures and benefits for themselves. Working with the Army to correct the course of politics is very risky despite the relationship shared with them, but it may be the best way to save the Union. (Radical)
 
[X] While a massive demand for more metamaterials is only expected to increase, it may be prudent to shift current efforts towards a more detailed investigation of the underlying nature of Glimurn. The last time such a thing was attempted it failed, but now we are better prepared with more knowledge and better equipment, as well as possible local allies. It will not produce anything of note but knowledge on how to proceed, however. (Glimurn Crystal Caverns Scientific Expeditions) (20 Resources per dice 150/250)
[X] Threaten to blow up the coalition: The careless attitudes of the Grey bloc have gone too far in allowing this idea into circulation. While it's true that something must be done to deal with the consumer goods situation, the entire revolution was about rejecting the endless hungering maw of greed and accumulation. From here it will be wage reforms, and then repealing of overtime law and other worker protections, and then mechanisms of debt slavery. To this we must say 'No'! We cannot work with a faction that would sacrifice the soul of the nation to make a balance sheet look better!
[X] Drag them into the light: In the end, this is an underhanded and sneaky attempt to slip so called reforms by when people are not paying attention. Spearheading a loud and aggressively public investigation into conflicts of interest and allegations of corruption would be a political bomb shell with difficult to predict consequences, but perhaps better than a literal one. The only real drawback is that like some other options under consideration it could cause unrest and weaken the nation.
[X] Appeal directly to Velkon: Possibly the most dangerous option as who knows what he might decide to do now, on the cusp of his retirement. Perhaps that very retirement is why such a backstabbing is coming now, rather than at any other time? Regardless, the one who steered the ship of Communism so far will be able to right the rudder one last time. Surely Matiro Velkon will see the danger and act to avert it if properly warned, just like he has every single time before.
[X] Arrange a radical shift: Now is not the time for hesitation or cowardice and any action, even violent ones, are necessary to prevent these rotten ideas from taking root. We have tolerated corruption, racism, and selfishness from these reactionaries for too long, and even now conservatives arrange sinecures and benefits for themselves. Working with the Army to correct the course of politics is very risky despite the relationship shared with them, but it may be the best way to save the Union. (Radical)
[X] Direct action: It is clear that poisonous ideas have infiltrated the politics of the conservative bloc. With corruption, racism, and other frustrating blockheaded issues constantly coming from their direction, we have tried to work with them anyway and been repaid with more issues. It is now perhaps time to take decisive and personal action in removing obvious threats to the future of peace and cooperation, before the rot can fester further. After all, who can actually stop a determined archmage acting in the best interests of the nation? (Radical)
 
Vote closed
Scheduled vote count started by Rockeye on Feb 15, 2024 at 11:55 PM, finished with 77 posts and 58 votes.
 
Political Bombshells and Deposition
At the end of the latest five year plan, it is the change of an era.

Speeches in party chambers: Rolled: 10+20 = 30

The political push against the corruption of the system by the Greens started easily enough, using evidence gathered through the technically available notes on committee meetings and reaching out to several of the clerks responsible for handling drafts of the new system and ensuring they understand the grave threat it poses to the Communist system. Political maneuvering through the Party itself ran into frequent and early setbacks from those who have mastered the bureaucracy and all the ways it can befuddle and delay legitimate actions. Simply bringing up the negative consequences of these plans on the Party floor earned little more progress than some derisive statements that a if the current minister of the Economic Ministry could not understand long term policy, perhaps she should be replaced with a man who can think of the long term benefits.

Though some sectors of the Party supported pushback against the growing murmurs of enterprise restriction removal, overall the purely political route of circulating information within the state apparatuses clearly was not going to have a satisfactory result. Even bringing the reports to the Blues, Blacks, and Whites did not produce a rallying as expected, with discourse surrounding the economic changes being discussed as 'unfortunate necessities to ensure stable goods provisioning'. Presenting proposals for improved centrally managed consumer goods systems did nothing to convince people it could be realistically managed, as the systems necessary for accurate assessments of demand in a central location simply do not exist, no matter what theories of advanced mana computing promise.

Going public: Rolled 84

With internal shaming a failure, the only alternative was to drag attention to the brewing disaster of corruption and greed by force of public attention. After gathering a wealth of evidence and assembling it into several damning reports, the resulting pamphlets and papers were distributed through the recently expanded large scale printing systems, creating information accessible to the common people on the dangers of this new trend. Just as other parties have channels of distribution that can be trusted to act semi-secretly, arranging several believers in the cause to distribute the information and plan a small protest march was simple enough. Mostly composed of students and lower level recruits, they were fully concerned with the implications of introduction of capital accumulation and very enthusiastic about protests against such a thing.

The results of the distribution were greater than at first expected, with a vast number of people in crowded urban areas inflamed by the alarming threat of a slippery slope. In Harkon city, protestors gathered on the designated day at the start of a work week, with the resulting protest being considerably greater than anticipated. While hoping for perhaps a few thousand students incensed at the corruption, instead tens of thousands marched towards the government offices at the center of town. Garrison troops quickly shut down the subway system and began strategically blocking roads, allowing the protestors to spill out into parks and city squares while emergency meetings of the ministries were organized.

Number of deaths/injuries/arrests (higher is more): 1; 9; 52

Despite the tense situation, disaster was averted thanks to the quick thinking of one Colonel Winston, the very same man who had been with Kanna when she shot down a large portion of Glitterdawn Vale's midnight bomber raid. Having spent much of his career studying the potential of wide-area of effect spells and even collaborating with Kanna on spell design at times, he was able to quell the crowd with a slow-acting calming field, which dulled neural and muscular activity until the crowd essentially fell asleep on their feet. Aside from a few particularly paranoid magic academy students, few if any noticed the effect before it was well underway, and as a peaceful tactic for shutting down protests it has worked remarkably well, with not a single death directly caused by the demonstration reported, and only a few dozen injuries, mostly minor. Though sweeping arrests have been made, the lack of any deaths did much to reduce the panic among both legislators and the populace at large.

Holiday coalition stability: 22
Strength of the Red's response: 96 + 10 (public disorder and imminent war) = 106

In the days that followed the yelling and debates grew incredibly harsh, but with the cat out of the bag and pamphlets from the protest circulating openly, it was clear that the Greens had been caught with their hands in the cookie jar. Seized communications between prominent Green members were telling- The old battlewagon Carinna Sarshen has apparently left Chelska entirely a few years ago, but her last few years were marked with enmity and disgust for what the Greens had done, with her personal effects detailing bribery and corruption schemes where funds designated for the Ministry of Interior were used to pay inflated rates to enterprises that prominent Green members had control over, creating an ecosystem that converted state funding into private benefits at every level, with everyone from managers to foot-sloggers steadily finding bribes and other forms of corruption the norm. The regional devolution programs, too, were found to sometimes end up in the pockets of regional leaders instead of actually benefiting the citizens. This was somewhat expected, but not nearly to this extent. With most, if not all, of the uncovered records casting shade on prominent Greens and only occasionally implicating those of other big factions, this, more than anything else, is what triggered the Reds to break off entirely from the Greens.

Ongoing public stability: 29

While the Party was reorganizing its internal policies and investigating the corruption scandals, the public was not sitting idle waiting for the new line to be announced. Protests continued, if on a much smaller scale, with a number of publications, especially co-ops that had no direct state support, taking nearly openly critical stances on the government for allowing corruption to fester to such an extent. The impression painted of Kanna was that of a heroic crusader for the people, pushing back against corruption and shady dealings at every turn. With a history of similar public actions, it was not a difficult line to push, but it was one inconvenient for the ministry in the Party itself, as many began criticizing the economic ministry for inciting instability and public disorder, especially since smaller protests continued to break out in several regions across the Union- All acting out in dissatisfaction over one condition or another, ranging from housing quality, medical access, perceived corruption, stagnant wages, and in Cygnus and Visci several protests about the flailing and ineffectual light rail program.

Increasingly, the general state of instability was blamed squarely on Kanna Dipolous herself for taking the information public instead of working through the proper channels. In the culmination of this trend, Matiro Velkon commissioned a detailed investigation into the source of the protests, and was publicly disappointed in the so-called 'rabble rousing', criticizing the action of turning to the people when bureaucratic action failed as potentially lighting the nation on fire at a time when it needs to be prepared for war and deal with the trade disruptions.

In the end, it was declared that Kanna will be relieved of her post as head of the Economic Ministry. While murmurs of protest were lodged from several sides, none were quite as enthusiastic or insistent as hoped, with nobody really daring to go against Velkon's decision, even as he is less than a year before retirement. Replacing her would be Karoline Staver, having served as the deputy and run smaller sectors of the overall ministry for some time. Considering her to be somewhat more biddable and more likely to do the job without being an armed wand of fireball, as he put it, the replacement could technically be overturned by a sufficiently strong rebuttal, though this seems unlikely. In the end, dragging the public into Party politics has resulted in ostracization from the levers of power, which was not entirely unexpected.



What will Kanna do now?

[] Accept the transfer gracefully: A prominent researcher position as opposed to a top-level administrative one is both something that will rankle greatly, but also be somewhat of a relief. Life can return to something like simplicity, working away in laboratories and workshops to push the boundaries of what is possible in spellframes forward one step at a time. Chelska and the Economic Ministry can do what they like. This elf is done with leadership for now.

[] Campaign to retain the post: Surely a single moment of indiscretion should not end a ministerial career so easily? By accepting any number of oversights, restrictions, and favors owed, as well as more formal limits on authority and other types of checks and balances, the freedom to pilot the economy in a chosen direction will be much lesser than before, but still retained. Besides, as much as the job was detestable at times, Staver needs a few more years to really be prepared.

[] Make for Beseren to intervene: The revolutionary war in Beseren is in a delicate state, especially with strong Chelskan support now cut off due to the closing of ocean trade routes. In order to support the existence of international communism, assisting in Beseren in whatever manner is possible would be a potent action. The champion of Chelskan aid showing up in person to support magical development would be a powerful political symbol, even aside from organization or industrial skills.

[] Make for Halve to intervene: Alternately, the nation of Halve, full of animal-aspected elves, has much more recently launched a large scale uprising from their colonial overlords. While the situation in Beseren is now mostly stable and seems to be heading towards the partitioning of the nation, unless the tides of war turn again, the situation in Halve is likely much more precarious. They could certainly use a skilled administrator and wizard in many capacities, even if they seem more like Monarchists than Communists at this time.

[] Delve into the Glimurn caverns: The depths of this mysterious place hold many intriguing mysteries to be explored, and possibly just as many dangers. How do people live their full lives down here? What is the Wall of Flesh? How are materials 'grown' out of magic? What is the source of the titanic amount of mana that the place is producing and consuming? All of these questions have a dozen potentially fascinating answers, which only lead to more questions. Exploring and investigating it would be a thrill and a source of magical advancement.

[] Make for unexplored lands: Not all of the world is currently known to Chelska. There are rumors from adventurous captains of more continents, neither the Old World nor Tessaria, with many strange and concerning wonders and adventures to be had. A life on the frontier exploring new facets of Elvaria is certainly a heady idea, and would be a wonderful break from all the tangled, thorny issues of Chelska. Frontier adventures, perhaps with a few friends, could be a wonderful vacation and allow an eventual return to see how the world has developed with new eyes.



NOTE: This result was not guaranteed. It happened because Kanna rolled low initially, rolled high to go public, and then the public unrest continued on for a good amount of time. Certain parties decided she is just too volatile to work with, at this point.

So, questers. Unfortunately... I am somewhat bored of central planning: fantasy edition.

I write when I am entertained to write, and stop writing when I'm not. I am probably going to place it on hiatus, or even mark it complete, and move on to writing... Something else.

Likely something related, set within the same world, the same Chelska. It's just that I'm finding it more and more difficult to keep going on the same pattern, so something needs to change. I'm not going to be able to keep pumping out six-month turns of Chelska itself in the same economic-head format.

Ideas I've come up with:
  • Longer time horizon turns for Chelskan economics. Essentially timeskip turns, like in Blackstar's space quest. Two year turns where you choose a number of priorities and roll for the quality of the results, rather than filling progress bars.
  • Follow Kanna as she fucks off to Beseren or Halve and do the economic buildup thing in those countries.
  • Follow Kanna to Beseren or Halve but focus on the political, diplomatic, magic R&D, or military situations, not economic development.
  • Follow Kanna as she goes on an expedition into uncharted territory, exploring fantastical and probably dangerous lands.
  • Take a look at a particular enterprise in Chelska and zoom in to manage that quarter by quarter- Perhaps the beleaguered theme parks and resorts trying to maintain something resembling a tourist industry, perhaps the local director of the trans-continental railroad project that Staver is NO QUESTION locking in, perhaps even a newspaper publisher trying to retain the interest of subscribers and also not offend the Party censors very much.
  • Take a look at another country, like the turmoil in Gallica, the troubled island republics of Mathylko, etc.
  • Take a look at the life of a stressed out Grenoble Empire naval Captain participating in the first Real Big Sea War in modern times.
  • Possibly something else? If you have ideas, let me know.

24 hour moratorium, please.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top