Hmm. I like plan Morgoth's bane but Going with the twins doesn't really make sense. If we want to focus on Angband, than Maeglor is an better choice since he is on the frontline.
[X] Plan: Luigi Cadorna
[X] Plan: The old Smith
[x] Plan Morgoths-Bane 2.0
-[X] Maglor
-[X] Female

-[x] Ilcariel (Gleaming-White, Female)
- [X] Smith
- [X] Firstborn
-[x] Weapon Of Elder Days:
-[X] A Lover's Blood


An modification of the plan. I am tempted to take hunter instead of smith but some flexibility might be useful and I like the idea of the MC having created her own legendary weapon, which may become an thing with the Smith focus.
 
Last edited:
Three-way tie between Morgoth's Bane, Silver Voice, and Luigi Cadorna at the moment, so I'll let the vote run until the end of the day today.

EDIT: Also totally rewrote the intro post for clarity, since I figured it was a little too obtuse to franchise newcomers.
 
Last edited:
Hmm. I like plan Morgoth's bane but Going with the twins doesn't really make sense. If we want to focus on Angband, than Maeglor is an better choice since he is on the frontline.
[X] Plan: The old Smith
[x] Plan Morgoths-Bane 2.0
-[X] Maglor
-[X] Female

-[x] Ilcariel (Gleaming-White, Female)
- [X] Smith
- [X] Firstborn
-[x] Weapon Of Elder Days:
-[X] A Lover's Blood


An modification of the plan. I am tempted to take hunter instead of smith but some flexibility might be useful and I like the idea of the MC having created her own legendary weapon, which may become an thing with the Smith focus.
I admit my thinking pretty much broke down to "hunting weird monsters is more fun than fighting orcs". Could have gone hunter, but Middle Earth crafting is fun.
 
[X]Plan Wizard
-[X] Maglor
-[X] Ilcarion (Gleaming-White, Male)
-[X] Minstrel
-[X] Mastery Of Ages Yet To Come
-[X] Firstborn

-[X] A Lover's Blood
Changed vote
 
Last edited:
[X] Plan Silver Voice
[X] Plan: The old Smith

I was kinda hoping someone would make a plan with Sworn to the Flame for maximum interaction with the Sons, but the Kinslaying requirement is admittedly a pretty big drawback. Actually, how 'set' is fate here? Iirc canonically all the Elves are basically predestined to do what they did, so technically everything should do exactly as they did in canon, but I'm assuming we get some leeway here?
 
@Telamon please stop hurting this and stick to one LoTR Quest at a time please. This is honestly worse then the usual dropping a quest and starting up something in a totally different setting thing that you normally do.
 
Back
Top