AN: Took a little longer than intended. If I don't write a lot, I also tend to not get around to uploading anything, and the busy times around the holidays plus getting a cold halfway through wasn't exactly conducive to writing. On the flip side, that also means you're not really missing out on anything new, because I haven't written anything new; I'm still working on chapter 1.5. To get back into writing I've also been writing on a oneshot a bit, which I currently expect (no promises!) will be my next upload, whenever that may be, so keep an eye on my oneshots thread if you're not doing so yet.
Now, onto this scene and why it's not part of the main story despite being canon: It's a variety of reasons. First, while Emma deserves quite a bit of screen time as a main character, I felt like it's starting to border on too much, in particular when combined with my other points. Because my second reason is that the pacing is already starting off a little slow, and this scene doesn't do much beyond adding more words until we get some action. Third, it's more of the same thing we've already been seeing - Emma's turnaround and her having to come to terms with it. Across 1.2-1.4, we've had two full chapters dedicated to her and Taylor talking about everything. And fourth, this scene doesn't actually advance the plot. Alan and Zoe are going to be very minor characters, and nothing that's said here hasn't already been covered elsewhere. The only reason I wrote it is because telling Emma's parents is something that can't be left unaddressed.
AN 07/02/2023: After reader feedback, I've changed this scene to be a bonus scene, but part of the main story. I'm leaving above reasoning up for completeness' sake.
After school, we'd gone to the mall so Emma could help me pick a phone, as she knew much more about smartphones than I did. She also insisted on paying for it, and while I tried to object, I also realized that it would do Emma good to do something for me. Besides which, money
was much tighter for me and Dad than it was for her and her family.
Now, we were standing in front of the Barnes' home. Alan would be home already – I'd called Aunt Zoe yesterday evening to discuss our plans for the day, as we didn't want to have to tell the story twice.
I glanced to the side.
Emma seriously looked like she wanted to turn and run.
"Come on," I said, grabbing her hand. "They'll have to hear it
some time."
Emma sighed. "I know. It's just…" She took a deep breath. Then another one. "Alright," she said. "Alright, time to stop running."
As if her boots were unimaginably heavy, she put one foot forward and slowly started walking. I stayed at her side until we reached the door, and Emma fumbled with her key.
I hadn't been here for a year and a half, but little had changed. As we entered, I heard Emma's parents speak up, no doubt having heard our arrival. After we took off our coats, Emma dawdled again, so I gently tugged her forward to reach the living room in a reasonable timeframe.
Uncle Alan and Aunt Zoe both smiled as they saw me.
"Taylor!" Aunt Zoe said. "I'm so glad to see you again!"
"So am I," I said. Now that Emma was in view of her parents, she seemed to have calmed down a bit – or at least she'd acknowledged she wasn't going to be able to run – and we sat down next to each other on the couch. Uncle Alan and Aunt Zoe had each taken a chair.
"Are you okay, Emma?" Aunt Zoe asked in a more serious tone, having realized how different the redhead looked from usual.
She smiled weakly. "I will be."
"That's what you said on the phone too, yesterday," Aunt Zoe said. "In fact, you were both rather secretive. What's going on?"
I glanced at Emma. Emma glanced at me.
"I don't think I'm the one who should answer that question," I pointed out.
"No," Emma admitted. "It's just… I… Aarrgh!" She rubbed her face with both hands. "I just… I don't even know where to start!"
"Why don't you start at the beginning?" Aunt Zoe gently suggested.
Emma helplessly looked at me.
"I remember in the phone call yesterday that you'd told your parents that I'd broken off contact with you?" I suggested.
"Yeah," Emma said. "I—I guess that's a good place to start."
"I was wondering about that," Aunt Zoe said. "On the phone you said
you were actually the one who broke it off? And what changed?"
Uncle Alan leaned forward. "You didn't tell me about this," he said to his wife.
"I figured we'd talk about it today," she explained.
"Yeah, I did," Emma said. "And it was stupid. It was all my fault."
"What is your fault?" Alan asked, concerned.
"After the… the
alley, when talking to Sophia, I got this idea that I had to be
strong," Emma said, slowly and haltingly explaining. "And—and I had decided that Taylor didn't
fit with that because of how long she needed to get over Aunt Annette's death. So I—I started pushing her away."
Both her parents looked very worried now.
However, I felt like I should interfere. What Emma was saying wasn't
wrong, but… "Was that the real reason?" I asked gently.
Emma seemed to freeze up for a bit, but then she realized what I was referring to. "N-no," she said, still tripping over her words a bit. "I didn't realize it at the time, but… I think deep inside I knew even then that… well, I wasn't dealing with it at all. I was just
hiding everything that was going on in my head. And if I look back, I think I… I was caught in my own head, if that makes sense?"
"It does to me," I said, encouraging her.
"And, well… I think that somewhere, I knew Taylor could help me, in a way no one else could. But I just… I couldn't ask for help, because that would be
weak, and I didn't want that. So instead I… I…"
She trailed off completely and looked to me, tears forming in her eyes.
I grabbed her hand and squeezed gently, nonverbally encouraging her to say it.
She shook her head.
I can't do it, the motion said.
I can't say the word.
"Emma… started bullying me," I said, apprehensive for the reaction of her parents.
The initial reaction was two distinct intakes of breath. Then a few seconds of silence.
"Is that true?" Uncle Alan asked sharply.
Emma nodded mutely.
"For… wait," Aunt Zoe paused as she clearly went over the timeline in her head. "For
a year and a half? Your
best friend?"
"I'm sorry!" Emma squeaked out, and I was unsure whether she was apologizing to her parents or, once more, to me. She closed in on herself, like a turtle retreating into it's shell, only she had nothing but her arms and legs to hide behind.
I put my arm around her and pulled her into my chest for comfort – and as a signal to her parents that things had changed.
"But…
why?" Aunt Zoe asked, barely keeping her calm. Uncle Alan looked angry, though he was holding back for now. I gave it a fifty-fifty chance that he was telling himself to hear us out before he could start shouting at Emma.
I took over, as Emma seemed in no condition to talk. "I think… well, keep in mind that this would be Emma's subconscious. I don't think she realized any of this until yesterday. But I think that she was hoping, beneath all the posturing, that I'd push back. That I'd stand up to her and force her to ask herself the questions she was avoiding.
"We'd—we'd probably have a fight, maybe a bad one, but in the end she'd be unable to keep lying to herself."
"And… that's what happened yesterday?" Aunt Zoe asked apprehensively. "But why now?"
"It's… not really what happened," I said. "Honestly, I thought I'd given up on being friends with Emma again more than a year ago. I think, back then, when the bullying just started… well, the teachers and principal refused to do anything about it and even accused me of lying, which is definitely a particular brand of fucked up, but that aside, I never had many friends, and I didn't have any at Winslow. I was still kind of processing Mom's death, though I was doing better than Dad, and the thought of maybe losing Emma for good if I called her out on what she was doing… it scared me. Even though I didn't have much left to lose."
"But what happened yesterday, then?" Uncle Alan asked. It seemed like he'd gotten his emotions under control. "Because
something has obviously changed."
"I got powers," I said simply, intending to continue.
Uncle Alan frowned, then made the connection. "
WHAT?" he thundered as he shot up from his chair. Emma flinched in my arms.
He looked between the two of us, somehow calming slightly. "Did… did Emma do that?" The anger was still there, but it was tinged with… fear, or embarrassment, perhaps? As if he was wondering whether he'd judged too quickly, yet still not liking the way the pieces seemed to fit together at all.
"I did," Emma admitted in a quiet voice, muffled further by my clothes.
Somehow, Uncle Alan did not start a tirade. I suspected it was solely the fact that I was currently comforting Emma that kept him.
"One of my powers lets me learn things about people," I said. "Without going into too much detail, one thing it showed me was how much of a mess Emma was on the inside, and all those things we just talked about, that she'd hidden even from herself. I confronted her about it."
"And what happened?"
"It was one of the hardest things I've ever done," I admitted. "Almost harder than school when… almost harder than school on a bad day. When I was talking to Dad last Monday, I really realized that I still wanted to be friends with Emma again. And then when my power showed me… showed me what was going on within Emma… I think that's the most hope I've felt in a very long time. Since before Mom died."
I rested my chin on Emma's head, now desperate for the physical contact myself. "I thought… for a bit, I thought it wasn't going to work. That I hadn't managed to reach her. I was already…" I swallowed. "I was already walking away, leaving the classroom, when she called out to me.
"Then, we… well, yesterday Emma was doing even worse than now. I got the administration to let us go home, and we talked. For the entire afternoon. About everything that had happened, and everything we'd missed over the past year and a half."
"But… she made you trigger," Uncle Alan said. "Carol told me about that once, Carol Dallon, of New Wave. I thought trigger events were supposed to be practically unforgivable. That they were so bad, that you had to feel so terrible to even go through them, that something would just
break in you."
"It's what I told Emma yesterday," I said. "With any normal friend, I don't know if I'd have bothered. But Emma is
more than that to me; she's like a sister. You can't abandon your sister, no matter what she did to you."
"That's enough to see past whatever Emma did to you? Which we
will be having words about, by the way," he added as a threat.
I couldn't help but snort. "Considering I made Emma trigger right back, I'd say we're even."
Uncle Alan seemed genuinely speechless at that.
Emma finally raised herself up again, though she moved to sit on my lap for support, and I carefully kept my arms around her waist.
"That was mostly my own fault," she said hoarsely. "It was like Taylor said. She forced me to look at myself. To be
honest with myself. And I… I'd fucked it up. I'd fucked everything up. My whole life, my best friend's life, our friendship, everything. When she was walking away, I… I couldn't keep up the lie anymore, and it was like everything came crashing down at once.
"And then…" she started smiling, though it was weak and uncertain. "And then Taylor was there the moment I admitted I needed her. She's the best friend I could ever hope for, and far more than I deserve."
Uncle Alan fell back into his chair with rather more force than needed. "I don't know where to even start."
"Neither do I," I admitted. "I vote we continue the way Emma and I have been doing since yesterday. We just keep going and talk about whatever comes up. Can I stay for dinner? Dad knows that's likely, I'll just have to give him a brief call when he's home to confirm."
"That might be a good idea," Aunt Zoe agreed.
Today was going to be another long and exhausting day – though that was less bothersome as well now that I no longer needed sleep, or at least it had seemed that way yesterday – but having Emma back by my side made it all worth it.