[X] Homura is right about this. Telling Sayaka would be foolishness.
-[X] There is an issue -- we made Mami a standing offer that if she wants to know, we'd tell her. We explained the consequences for her of learning very loosely, and she said no.
--[X] Because Sayaka is also a magical girl with us, we'd be remiss to not make her a similar offer... But the circumstances aren't the same.
---[X] She needs to know that she can ask if she must -- it'll keep her from running off --but she really doesn't need to know more than that. You'll make sure it stays that way.
[X] If I thought Madoka would react the same way Mami would, then I wouldn't want to tell her, either. I think that Madoka knowing about witches might help keep her from making a wish, especially when I tell her that I'm working on dewitching.
[x] "I did tell Mami that there were other infohazards like the lichbomb, and offered to tell her of them. She declined, but I would have told her if she hadn't."
[x] "And telling Madoka about witches means she can't be tricked into wishing by Kyubey."
[X] Reassure Homura in earnest.
[X] Be Contrite and Respectful Brina. [X] Suggest or Offer that she watch over riskier SCIENCE like messing with seeds, or that a group activity of her and Niko and Brina might be safer
-[X] Promise to not do any of this without Homura's (and Niko's) consent.
[X] She doesn't need to convince us; Witchbombing Madoka would make her want to Contract. We know it's an awful idea. -[X] When we told Mami about KB and Soul Gems, we made mistakes: We assumed we understood the damage that would cause, and we did it so we wouldn't feel guilty. -[X] We're not repeating those mistakes. [X] Explain some of the merits of bombing her. Mainly the risk of her encouraging Madoka that we oversold the downsides of contracting, while she'd be actively helping us dissuase Madoka if she knew
[X] Quieter tone. Explain how you would do Lichbomb Sayaka.
-[X] Use you and Mami, and Niko and Kazumi as examples.
--[X] Sayaka would be informed about the existence of dangerous knowledge and about just how dangerous it is; reassured that progress is being done; and we'd have her think about it for some time before deciding whether she wants to know or not.
[X] Sayaka
-[X] Vote in abeyance.
-[X] Take safety measures and record the Hunt?
-[X] Give her today's Kyouko's payment.
[X] Nadia.
-[X] Ask about Riona, and her not having contacted us yet.
[X] Accept Homura's point. The circumstances might be different, but the way Mami being Witchbombed would affect you and the way Madoka being Witchbombed would affect Homura... Common ground.
-[X] Reassure Homura.
-[X] You've made huge errors of judgement in the past regarding informational hazards. You're not doing that again. Promise.
-[X] Now hug?
[X] Still with Homura: About Sayaka.
-[X] Promise to not even offer her information about the Witchbomb's mere existence without consent from Homura... and Niko, too.
-[X] Should you all make decisions regarding the Witchbomb only as a group? You'll need to introduce them.
[X] Sayaka
-[X] Vote in abeyance.
[X] Nadia.
-[X] Ask about Riona, and her not informing you all of her arrival.
