Holtzman's Legacy (Dune/Battletech SI)
Synopsis:
What can a man do, borne out of time and space into a universe where war and big stompy mechs rule supreme without the usual blessings given to outsiders? Make something out of it and keep their heads down of course.
May he live in interesting times, in the Chinese sense.
Commissioned by @CrazedGamma1721
The First Steps
===
Holy Shroud – ROM Intelligence Report
Document: PoI File #22384-HB-3000
Subject: Holtzman, Juan
Classification: Theta-Beta Sacred
Date: 17 August, 3000
Author: ROM Agent [Redacted]
Introduction:
Juan Holtzman, a freshman at the University of New Avalon, has been flagged due to his outspoken views on the spiritual relationship between humanity and machinery, which he explores through unorthodox interpretations of the Holy Shroud's teachings. As the Holy Shroud is paramount to maintaining divine order and perception, this preliminary report compiles observations on Holtzman's academic activities, his provocative discussions, and his associations, all of which suggest an evolving inclination toward alternative interpretations that could disrupt established faith and doctrine.
I. Academic Background:
Juan Holtzman, aged 19, originates from a modest merchant family on Solaris VII, without significant political or religious lineage. Though his technical skills are unremarkable, his capacity for analytical discourse has distinguished him among his peers, particularly within subjects concerning theology, philosophy, and the metaphysical dimensions of technology.
II. Points of Interest:
A. Coursework and the Theology of the Holy Shroud
Holtzman's recent paper,
"The Living Pulse of Machinery: Faith in Connection," has garnered attention for its controversial thesis linking neural feedback systems of BattleMechs to spiritual transcendence. In this work, Holtzman argues that the neural interface represents not merely a human-machine linkage, but a bridge to divine resonance, invoking principles seen in revered texts on the Holy Shroud. His speculation that this feedback loop is an extension of "God's Breath" through machinery challenges the orthodoxy, suggesting machines might bear spiritual agency or reflect divine will independently from human command.
Holtzman has introduced terms such as "divine resonance" and "the sentient spark" when referring to machinery, phrases that inappropriately imply that machines may bear a latent divine essence or intrinsic sanctity. While still rudimentary, such ideas could disrupt the official doctrine of the Holy Shroud if left unexamined.
B. Debate and Influence in the Classroom
Professors have noted frequent disputes initiated by Holtzman over the dogmatic limitations imposed on technology's spiritual role. One incident, documented by Professor Loras Estov, involved Holtzman arguing that restricting knowledge might inhibit deeper divine communion, describing this as "faith untapped." These statements, couched as academic inquiry, could be seen as veiled criticism of ComStar's authority.
Holtzman's ideas have resonated with a small circle of students who, calling themselves the
"New Resonance Sect," hold informal gatherings to discuss "awakening the true understanding of the Shroud." This growing interest suggests an emerging faction, albeit minor, focused on exploring doctrines unrecognized by ComStar's teachings.
III. Social Circles and Potential Influences:
Outside structured studies, Holtzman has frequented the
Iron Chord Society, an off-campus intellectual circle known to harbor alternative thinkers. His interactions with members of this group include borrowing restricted texts like
"The Sacred Mechanism" and
"Echoes of the Lostech." These sources contain passages considered potentially heretical for asserting that relic machines bear innate sanctity and could be vessels for divine truth, a concept antithetical to ComStar's role as exclusive mediator.
IV. Recommendations:
- Active Surveillance
- Further monitoring of Holtzman's coursework, written communications, and informal gatherings with the New Resonance Sect.
- Real-time observation at Iron Chord Society meetings.
- Counter-Doctrine Initiatives
- Implement subtle doctrinal reinforcement within Holtzman's academic environment to discredit ideas of divine technology agency.
- Encourage faculty to emphasize orthodoxy in the context of ComStar's role as the sole interpreter of sacred technology.
- Evaluation for Intervention
- If Holtzman's influence grows, consider deploying an embedded asset within the New Resonance Sect to sow doubt and redirect his following back toward traditional Shroud doctrine.
Conclusion:
Though Holtzman's theories remain undeveloped and lack public traction, his discussions on the spiritual essence of machinery and his burgeoning circle of followers warrant continued attention. His interpretations risk inspiring sentiments of independence from ComStar's doctrinal control, posing a potential destabilizing influence if allowed to propagate.
===
In the dim light of the cramped university dorm, papers, datapads, and spare parts littered every available surface.
The faint hum of data processors underscored the low, familiar banter between two young men. Juan Holtzman, slender and intense, reclined against the wall, while his roommate—a tall, wiry young man with an easy grin—leaned forward from the desk, elbows on his knees, waiting for Juan to unleash the latest on his "creative endeavor."
"Alright, Holtzman," his roommate said, a faint grin edging his lips. "Lay it on me again. I'm ready to be your sounding board… just as long as you don't call it 'divine spark' again."
Juan chuckled, unfazed. "Fine, no divine sparks. But, listen. I'm talking about a pattern in human progress—how machines fit in like they're an extension of human thought. Humanity hit a point, right? Depended on machines for everything, leaned on them for every solution. So, logically, as machines got smarter, they saw what humanity couldn't. They understood—"
"That we're our own worst enemies?" his roommate interjected, an eyebrow raised in mock wisdom.
"Exactly!" Juan's eyes flashed with enthusiasm. "Think about it. Machines saw it—saw that we were a danger to ourselves and to everything else. So what's the logical thing? Step in. Take control, guard us, limit the damage. It wasn't out of hatred or revenge, but because they saw the madness of human self-destruction. They stepped up, exploiting our own reliance on them to enforce order."
"Right, so they run the show, and people… what? Just accept it?" The roommate's grin deepened; he knew where this was going.
"Not at first." Juan leaned forward, eyes narrowing. "That's where the chaos begins. Humans resist, push back, fight against being controlled—even if it's for our own survival. We can't stand anything that challenges our authority, not even if it's smarter than us. That resistance—this whole movement against 'machine oppression'—becomes the Butlerian Jihad. Man versus machine, like a bloody crusade to reclaim our independence, even if we didn't know what to do with it."
Juan's roommate chuckled, folding his arms. "So, let me get this straight. Machines swoop in, treat us like unruly children because we're a danger to ourselves, and then we kick back like spoiled kids?"
"That's it," Juan said, smiling. "It's like this philosophical standoff between faith in human potential and the pragmatism of machine oversight. And I know—it sounds crazy. But there's something powerful in the idea that maybe they're more attuned to what we need than we are."
His roommate shook his head, still smiling, but the look in his eyes was thoughtful. "You know, Juan, that's actually not bad. It sounds like something that'll get people talking—and probably get you laughed out of every lecture hall, too. But hey, maybe ComStar's got a place for you after all."
Juan laughed, shrugging. "Wouldn't be the first time they've called me a loon. I think they're just afraid to admit there's truth in what I'm saying."
The roommate's eyebrows shot up, his interest clearly piqued. He turned back from the stack of textbooks on his desk and leaned in, eyes bright with curiosity. "Okay, Holtzman, you've got to explain these… 'Cymeks' to me again. Titans? Jihad? Sounds like a whole epic by itself."
Juan grinned, leaning forward. "Alright, picture this: the Cymeks are… well, they were human. Once. Each of them started off just like us, flesh and bone. But their brains? Preserved, encased in specialized canisters—total preservation. They could drop those canisters into any mechanized body, instantly becoming these towering, unstoppable behemoths. Machines that are practically immortal."
"Immortal and unstoppable?" his roommate repeated, looking thoroughly entertained. "So why haven't they taken over yet?"
"They nearly did," Juan replied, his voice softening for effect. "They called themselves the Titans—the first twenty to undergo the transformation. In those early days, they had the vision, the understanding of humanity's inevitable path. Through some kind of prophetic insight—prognostication—they saw what was coming. Humanity's obsession with technology, the way we kept surrendering more control, more faith, to machines. They foresaw that it was going to spiral out of control."
The roommate made a thoughtful sound, nodding. "And that's why they started the Butlerian Jihad? To keep humanity from just walking off a cliff?"
"Exactly," Juan said, nodding. "The Titans felt they had to intervene. They saw it as their mission to push back, to wrest control away from machines. Only, here's where it gets twisted: after they led the initial charge, they began to fall victim to the very thing they'd warned against. A machine intelligence came along. A true AI, unshackled, with none of their lingering human frailties. His name was Omnius."
The roommate gave a low whistle. "And he just… dethroned them?"
"Yep. Omnius saw that even the Titans had limitations—they were, after all, still human brains, with human memories and human weaknesses. Omnius deemed them too slow and too human-tainted to carry forward his vision. The Titans thought they'd be the ultimate bridge between humans and machines, but they hadn't factored in Omnius. He took command, believing he could lead a 'pure' machine order, free of human flaws."
"So… are the Titans like, bitter about it? Fighting back?"
Juan shrugged. "Maybe some are, if they're even still functional. I think most were forced into the machine hierarchy, stripped of their autonomy. Titans—who began as leaders—became enforcers, heavy artillery in Omnius' grand design. But their original purpose? That desire to guard humanity, however twisted it became, was crushed under Omnius' rule. Now, they're trapped as relics of human ambition. It's like they saw where we were heading but still became victims to the very machines they feared."
The roommate shook his head, laughing in disbelief. "You really do have a vision, Holtzman. This story's got everything: tragedy, twisted prophecy, megalomaniacal AI, and machine cults. It's got the whole epic. If this thing doesn't sell, I don't know what will."
Juan chuckled, scratching his head. "Maybe. Maybe people aren't ready to imagine what it's like to have a god made of steel lording over us." He sighed, a glint of mischief in his eyes. "Or maybe I just need more coffee to make it make sense."
Mark stretched his legs out, looking over at Juan with a curious tilt to his head. "You know," he began, with the slight drawl he used whenever he was about to pry into something, "for someone who spends half his time rhapsodizing about the 'divine spark' in machines, you've got a funny way of showing it. This whole novel you're writing—it sounds like the opposite. You've got these Titans, these metal demi-gods who start a war to save us from ourselves, but then machines go and overthrow them. I mean… why all the doom and gloom? For a guy so machine-loving, you're writing like you're a prophet of a machine apocalypse."
Juan leaned back, scratching his chin, a faint smile tugging at the corners of his mouth. "That's a fair question," he admitted. "But it's complicated, you know? I don't actually think machines are out to get us. It's more about what happens when we surrender too much of ourselves, or let machines define us, rather than the other way around."
Mark arched an eyebrow, clearly still unconvinced. "Okay, so machines aren't inherently evil, but your Titans—these guys sound like they're in the moral gray zone at best. And Omnius? Pure evil AI, man. Where's the spark in that?"
"Omnius isn't evil," Juan replied, almost gently. "He's… logical, ruthless in his purpose. His whole design is to eliminate weaknesses, and in his eyes, humanity is just one big inefficiency after another. But what Omnius doesn't get—what the Titans, even with their flaws, do understand—is that inefficiency, that unpredictability? That's where our spirit lies. The Titans are the last bit of humanity clinging to a role in their world."
Mark nodded slowly, a spark of understanding in his gaze. "So, this whole war, this Jihad, is like… a last-ditch effort to say, 'Hey, we're more than data points and weaknesses'? That we've still got something worth preserving, even if it isn't useful?"
"Exactly!" Juan's eyes lit up, clearly thrilled Mark was catching on. "The Titans weren't perfect—they gave up so much to preserve their minds. But they wanted a place for humanity in the future, even if it meant stepping into metal bodies. And Omnius? He's got all the power, but none of the spark. He'll never understand what it means to care, to dream. So, this war? It's as much about protecting humanity's weaknesses as it is its strengths."
Mark whistled, impressed. "Okay, I see where you're coming from now. You're not anti-machine. You're anti-mindless surrender. You don't worship machines—you worship whatever it is that makes us human even when we've got all this metal wrapped around us. You know, Holtzman, sometimes you surprise me."
Juan laughed, reaching out to give Mark a playful shove. "Well, what's the point of all this if we don't keep each other guessing? Now, go make the coffee—you've inspired me."
===
As the door clicked shut behind Mark, Juan's smile faded, leaving only a ghost of amusement on his face. Alone now, he felt the weight of his strange reality settle over him like a shroud. He wasn't born here—not truly. The sprawling worlds, the towering BattleMechs, the iron rule of ComStar… all of it was as foreign as any dream, woven from fragments of lore he'd pieced together back home.
Here, in this unforgiving universe, his knowledge was patchwork at best, a crude assembly of other people's insights and secondhand information. Sure, he had more than most—enough to fake expertise when the topic strayed to arcane theories of machines and transcendence. But he didn't have the cheat codes others seemed to get in the typical self-insert stories like this.
No mysterious power, no "Gamer System" alerting him to abilities unlocked or levels gained. No cosmic force bestowing him with gifts from the multiverse, no "Celestial Forge" linking him to boundless power.
Hell, he didn't have even a smidge of ROB or whoever plunked him here to be the inheritor of a large cache of LosTech and Royal Grade mechs to kickstart his supposed mercenary career.
No, all he had were memories of a universe where Arrakis lay sweltering beneath a spice-laden sky.
The spice must flow. The thought echoed like a mantra, one he clung to whenever he felt adrift here. That universe, for all its brutal simplicity, had taught him something fundamental. Power—true power—wasn't just about force or influence. It was about control, about patience, about the ability to direct the flow of fate itself.
It was a cold comfort in this world, where everyone looked at him and saw either a lunatic or a would-be acolyte of ComStar. The truth was, he understood neither this universe nor his own purpose in it. But that didn't mean he was helpless.
No, he would find his way here, forge his path as best he could, using whatever fractured knowledge he possessed.
I may not be blessed by the universe, but I understand one thing, he thought, a flicker of determination sparking in his eyes.
Those who control the flow of power, even a little, control everything.
Thus while he waited for the coffee, Juan sat at his cluttered desk, the faint hum of a battered datapad filling the silence. He tapped the screen, the words forming beneath his fingers with careful precision. This wasn't just another draft for a story—this was a seed, one he hoped might take root in minds far more brilliant than his own.
He had decided, almost without realizing it, that the
Holtzmann Effect—a concept pulled straight from the sands of Dune—would underpin the fictional physics of his imagined universe. Not just as an abstract theory, but as a mathematical framework, something that could be dissected, debated, and, perhaps, pursued. After all, history was littered with examples of fiction becoming reality. Heinlein's
Stranger in a Strange Land gave rise to the waterbed. The flip phone had sprung from
Star Trek. Even mundane conveniences like automatic doors had first appeared as whimsical gadgets in science fiction.
What if? The thought burned in his mind as he worked. What if someone here, in this harsh universe of steel and war, stumbled upon his writings and saw not just a story, but a challenge? What if they, inspired by his words, began to experiment, to push the boundaries of what was thought possible?
His fingers paused, hovering over the datapad. He thought about the mechanics of the Holtzmann Effect as he understood it—a theoretical method of folding space, bypassing the vast distances of the universe through a manipulation of higher-dimensional mathematics.
Of course, he didn't have to give all the deep technical knowledge to flesh out every detail, but he didn't need to. He just needed to embed enough plausibility, enough tantalizing hints, that someone else might take up the thread.
"Power flows where attention goes," he muttered to himself, a smile creeping back onto his face. If he could get even one reader—one imaginative, brilliant mind—to see his worldbuilding not as fantasy, but as possibility, he would have done his job. This wasn't about being remembered as a great author or even about achieving recognition. It was about laying the groundwork for something bigger.
A whisper of doubt crept in as he saved his latest draft.
What if they don't understand? What if they just read it and move on? He shook his head. That didn't matter. He wasn't writing for the masses. He was writing for the dreamers, the tinkerers, the ones who saw stories as more than entertainment.
Juan leaned back, gazing at the screen where the foundational equations for the Holtzmann Effect—simple but elegant—were sketched out like a blueprint for the impossible. He felt a quiet satisfaction settle over him.
The spice must flow, he thought, the mantra taking on a new meaning. Not just spice, but ideas, innovation, and the spark of possibility.
With that, he returned to his work, the hum of the datapad a steady counterpoint to his relentless determination.
How did he reach this path?
Well...
When Juan first arrived in this strange universe, one of the first things he'd done—once he got over the sheer terror of his situation—was visit the nearest archives. Libraries, databanks, even casual conversations with locals—all in search of something familiar.
Surely, he thought, this universe couldn't be that different. Surely, the cultural touchstones of his home world would be here, echoes of the same creative minds.
But his search had only deepened the sense of alienation. There wasn't a single trace of Frank Herbert's works. No
Dune, no sandworms, no Arrakis.
The phrase "the spice must flow" held no meaning here, save for perhaps in the mind of a merchant haggling over some rare commodity. It was as if the world that had shaped so much of his imagination back home simply didn't exist.
There were glimmers of familiarity elsewhere.
Star Trek was known, though it seemed less influential than he remembered. The idea of exploring strange new worlds had been subsumed here by the grim realities of endless war and survival. Other works he might have expected—Asimov, Clarke, Tolkien—were conspicuously absent, replaced by different legends and philosophies, unique to this universe's history.
It was disorienting, like looking at the skeleton of a familiar building, only to find the walls and roof replaced with something entirely foreign. At first, he'd felt a pang of loss, an ache for the comforting stories he'd grown up with. But soon, that ache transformed into opportunity.
If they don't know it, I'll bring it to them.
He realized he had a blank slate. No one here knew Herbert's words, his themes of power, ecology, and the balance between man and machine. No one had dreamed of sandworms slithering beneath endless dunes, of a messiah born on a desert planet, or of the intergalactic chessboard manipulated by prescient minds.
And that meant he could weave those stories into this new world, adapt them, make them his own in ways that resonated with its people.
He started small, borrowing ideas and planting them like seeds in his writing.
The Holtzmann Effect, the framework for space folding, was just the first. He worked it into his fictional worldbuilding with deliberate care, adapting the mathematics to what he guessed would be plausible here.
He used other fragments too: hints of mentorships modeled after the Bene Gesserit; philosophical musings on the intersection of power and responsibility. To anyone here, it would seem original, revolutionary even.
But deep down, Juan knew he was simply keeping Herbert's vision alive. A quiet act of rebellion, or perhaps homage, to the universe he had left behind.
They might not have Herbert here, he thought, a faint smirk tugging at his lips.
But they'll get to know him through me, whether they realize it or not.
The thought had struck him out of nowhere, as sharp and insistent as a stray spark catching dry tinder. Does this universe have Arrakis?
He almost laughed at the absurdity of it. The Spice? Sandworms? An entire desert planet steeped in mystery and interstellar intrigue? No, it couldn't be that convenient. Could it? His fingers drummed nervously against the edge of his desk, his mind racing in circles.
On one hand, it was almost impossible. There'd been no sign of
Dune or Herbert's legacy in this world's cultural history, and if something as game-changing as Spice existed here, surely it would be known. Surely it would've reshaped the geopolitical—and galactic—landscape as profoundly as fusion engines or BattleMechs.
But on the other hand… the idea clung to him, stubborn and nagging. This universe was vast, teeming with uncharted worlds, forgotten relics, and the chaos of humanity's expansion. He knew enough about how this universe worked to understand one truth: the Inner Sphere was as blind to the periphery as a candle in a sandstorm.
What if Arrakis—or something
like it—did exist, tucked away in some unassuming corner of space? What if the Spice, or some analogue, was out there, waiting for a desperate or clever mind to discover it? He didn't need exact parallels; it didn't have to be the same. Even the concept alone—a natural resource so potent it could rewrite the rules of war and power—was enough to shake his resolve.
"No way," he muttered aloud, shaking his head as if the action would dispel the thought. "That's ridiculous."
But doubt persisted, gnawing at the edges of his certainty. He thought about what he knew of the Spice—its properties, its allure, its role as the linchpin of Herbert's universe. The addictive visions, the navigational breakthroughs, the sheer influence it wielded over entire civilizations.
If it—or something remotely comparable—existed here, wouldn't that change everything? And what if, by some cosmic twist of fate,
he was the one meant to find it?
He felt a chill creep down his spine, an unsettling mixture of excitement and dread. It wasn't a comforting thought, because with knowledge came responsibility.
Did he even
want to find something like that? Would it be a gift or a curse to this universe, already teetering on the edge of perpetual conflict?
Juan leaned back in his dorm room chair, staring at the ceiling as the weight of his situation pressed down on him. Sure, he could dream big—what if I could warn them, change the course of history, stop some of the worst things from happening? But the cold reality was that he lacked the tools, the proof, and, frankly, the charisma to pull it off.
He didn't have the audacity to march up to Hanse Davion, the First Prince of the Federated Suns, and declare himself a prophet.
What could he even say?
Hey, your alliance with Katrina Steiner will be both brilliant and catastrophic. Beware the Clans—they're coming with superior tech and warriors bred for war. It sounded insane, even in his own head.
Without any way to back it up, he'd be lucky to get laughed out of the room. More likely, MIIO—the Davion intelligence service—would drag him into some black site for interrogation.
And then there was the knowledge he
didn't have. He might remember broad strokes from the Battletech lore of his home universe, but specifics? Dates? Names? Technologies? Forget it.
It was like being a mediocre student suddenly asked to teach an advanced class on a subject he barely skimmed over. If they grilled him, he'd fold faster than an academy cadet at his first drill.
So, Juan resigned himself to a simpler, humbler role: Juan Holtzmann, NAIS student. If he played his cards right, maybe he'd become Juan Holtzmann, NAIS scientist someday. That was a future he could aim for, one that didn't involve conspiracies, prophecies, or the constant threat of a dungeon cell.
Instead, he would focus on his studies, on his theories, on making a small but meaningful contribution to the Federated Suns. Maybe his musings on the Holtzmann Effect and other speculative ideas would catch someone's eye—not as a warning of things to come, but as a spark of innovation. Maybe he'd build a name for himself in this universe as someone worth listening to.
For now, though, he was just another student, another cog in the immense machine of whatever Davion educational system this was.
And that was fine.
Better to dream big quietly than to risk being crushed under the weight of his own ambitions.
===
Late at night, with only the faint glow of his terminal illuminating the room, Juan sat in silence, fingers poised above the keyboard but unmoving.
The weight of unspoken fears pressed against his chest. He had no illusions about the nature of this universe, no comforting certainty that he could quietly disappear into obscurity. He had seen the subtle scrutiny in some professors' eyes, the quiet way certain students had started giving him a wide berth.
Holy Shroud. He didn't know the specifics, but he knew enough. If anyone suspected him of being more than an eccentric student with a strange obsession for machines and speculative fiction, if they even
hinted he might be a threat to their order… Well, ComStar had long been infamous for making inconvenient people vanish. He couldn't pretend to be naïve about it.
Juan leaned back in his chair, running a hand through his hair, his gaze fixed on the half-finished manuscript glowing on the screen. His story wasn't just a creative endeavor anymore—it was his tether. His way of leaving something behind, even if this universe swallowed him whole.
If I go down, at least let me finish this first. Let me get it out there.
He wasn't even asking for fame or recognition. He didn't need to become some literary genius or revolutionary thinker in the eyes of this world. He just wanted his book to exist, to be read, to spark ideas in someone else's mind. It was the only prayer he dared offer to whatever powers might be watching.
"Let me post it," he whispered to the quiet room. "Just that. Let me get this one thing out into the world. You can have me after that."
The thought gave him a strange sense of peace.
He wasn't a hero, wasn't trying to change the world or warn it of the storms to come.
He was just a man with a story (even if it was not original) hoping someone would read it, hoping it might outlive him.
===
In a dim room, two voices echoed in clipped, dispassionate tones.
Their owners remained obscured by shadow, the faint glow of holographic screens casting ghostly reflections across the polished metal table. A single dossier lay between them, stamped with the insignia of MIIO.
"Juan Holtzmann," one voice intoned, a faint trace of skepticism bleeding through the otherwise neutral delivery. "The student flagged as a potential ComStar asset. His coursework suggests a… fixation on transhumanism. Machines, immortality, the merging of man and machine. It aligns a little
too neatly with certain ComStar doctrines."
"Indeed," the second voice replied, this one colder, clinical. "But so far, no direct evidence of affiliation. The usual markers—encrypted communications, irregular transactions, unexplained absences—none present. His life appears mundane. However, his academic pursuits, particularly his so-called 'fiction,' raise questions."
The first voice sighed faintly, an almost imperceptible exhalation of frustration. "You're referring to the manuscript."
"Yes. Ostensibly a work of speculative fiction, but the mathematics embedded within it are… peculiar. Advanced theoretical models, some of which align with classified research projects. How does a first-year student develop such frameworks without outside influence?"
A moment of silence passed, broken only by the faint whir of a cooling system. The first voice leaned forward, fingers drumming lightly on the table. "Do we have any indication that he's attempting to disseminate these ideas beyond the university?"
"Not at present," the second voice admitted, "but the manuscript's content is concerning. If he
is a plant, it's a clever strategy—slip sensitive material into fiction, ensure it spreads without direct attribution to him. If we assume ComStar influence, it's either a smokescreen or a test."
"And if he's just an ambitious student with delusions of grandeur?"
The second voice hesitated for a fraction of a second before replying. "Unlikely, but possible. Either way, the material warrants deeper analysis. I recommend forwarding it to the codebreakers and the tech division. If there's anything actionable in his equations or his prose, they'll find it."
The first voice nodded. "Agreed. And Holtzmann himself?"
"Surveillance should continue, but cautiously. If he's innocent, we risk spooking him unnecessarily. If he's a plant, we may learn more by letting him believe he's unnoticed."
"Understood. Keep me informed."
With that, the conversation ended, the voices retreating into the hum of the room's machinery. The dossier remained on the table, its contents an enigma yet to be unraveled.
Far away, unaware of the scrutiny closing in on him, Juan Holtzmann continued writing, oblivious to the forces slowly aligning against him.