The HP/Negima crossover
So some time ago I was reading some HP threads somewhere, and came upon...
So some time ago I was reading some HP threads somewhere, and came upon...
User | Total |
---|---|
WanderingAirhead | 5 |
From: Hogwarts School of... | Letter of Invitation - Dear Sir or Madam, We are pleased to inform you that Harry Potter have been enrolled for the preparatory program...
While I don't think the actual date was stated, there is context that can be used to figure out generally when things occurred. For instance Negi was born in 1993, and is 9 when he becomes a teacher (while he claims to be 10, he also notes that is under a system of calculating ages that starts with the person being 1 when born, and increases by 1 each birthday after). As such Negima canon starts in 2002. As for the technology, that generally seems to be a mix of Mahora having unusually high tech compared to the rest of the world, and Akamatsu verse in general having weird bits of super advanced tech along side the more normal technology for the time period (for instance the AIs in A.I. Love You, much of what Kaolla Su from Love Hina makes, etc.). That said, shifting things slightly into the future doesn't really alter it overly much, and likely will help in avoiding anachronisms, though the uneven tech level could explain those away anyway.
I also would not consider Dumbledore the strongest mage on earth. It doesn't really make sense with people like Rakan and Nagi out there.
Second, I think the two areas that Potterverse magic is superior to Akamatsuverse magic are teleportation (as portkeys and Apparation seem much more common, and the only known actual teleportation in Negima has been by high powered mages) and transfiguration.
Those two aren't on Earth, though, they're on counter-Mars. Along with most of the other figures in that weight class we know the current location of, save for Eva (who I could see Dumbledore equaling fairly easily from a narrative perspective).I also would not consider Dumbledore the strongest mage on earth. It doesn't really make sense with people like Rakan and Nagi out there.
A couple of things.
First, and this is just a side comment, Harry Potter, the book series, exists in the Akamatsuverse. In one of the early volumes, Negi makes a comment about 'no Quiditch jokes' when riding on his flying staff.
Second, I think the two areas that Potterverse magic is superior to Akamatsuverse magic are teleportation (as portkeys and Apparation seem much more common, and the only known actual teleportation in Negima has been by high powered mages) and transfiguration.
Though, Potterverse's undetectable expansion charm (makes things bigger on the inside than the outside) is also pretty cool.
Third, don't forget that there's a difference between Western and Eastern magic traditions in Negima.
Those two aren't on Earth, though, they're on counter-Mars. Along with most of the other figures in that weight class we know the current location of, save for Eva (who I could see Dumbledore equaling fairly easily from a narrative perspective).
Ancient Greek, not modern Greek, as I understand, which is a fair bit of difference (like Latin and Italian).Fourth, and this is pretty obvious, they use Eastern languages, whereas Western magi use Latin, Greek, and occasionally Sanskrit.
And? Barty Crouch Junior turned Malfoy into a ferret with a wave of his wand, when he was pretending to be Moody. Plus, animagi.While I don't recall much about teleportation, I would note that there seems to be some pretty strong transfiguration in Negima that doesn't really get seen much. After all, one of the possible punishments in the setting is being turned into a ermine.
I was not suggesting such did not exist in Harry Potter. My point was that there is complex transfiguration in Negima rather than it being absent.And? Barty Crouch Junior turned Malfoy into a ferret with a wave of his wand, when he was pretending to be Moody. Plus, animagi.
Interesting. And I gotta say that I'm curious which is more dread by Magic Britain's society, He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named(-Without-Many-Hyphens), or the Advent of Evil, Maga Nosferatu, Apostle of Calamity, aka: Kitty.
Well, in Negima he went to school in Wales, if I remember correctly, and seemed to have family (or rather guardians) there. Presumably he was already there at the point that he came to be noted as an exceptionally skilled mage. Admittedly that may be one of the things that changes, but who knows.Hmmm, would Negi have graduated from Hogwarts then? Seeing the British response to one of their best and brightest leaving the country would be interesting.
Interesting. And I gotta say that I'm curious which is more dread by Magic Britain's society, He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named(-Without-Many-Hyphens), or the Advent of Evil, Maga Nosferatu, Apostle of Calamity, aka: Kitty.
Hmmm, would Negi have graduated from Hogwarts then? Seeing the British response to one of their best and brightest leaving the country would be interesting.
Hmmm, would Negi have graduated from Hogwarts then? Seeing the British response to one of their best and brightest leaving the country would be interesting.
He also graduated at age 9. So unless Hogwarts sent for him from a young age he'll be done with his schooling and have secured his spot in Mahora by the time he gets a letter.