Question 10
fallacies
Puyo Mage
Q10. If he can incarnate himself so easily, how is the Third Magic still worth anything?
It's a closed-circle mystery.
You -- the one playing the role of the great detective -- have already witnessed the ending of the story in all of its depressing horror. Because of time shenanigans, however, you're now in the past, and you're using your foreknowledge to cheat pettily in a game of 'deductions.' It's all for a good cause, though.
You intend to teach a valuable lesson to Solomon the Wise.
"You've lied a lot," you say. "But here and now, for the sake of conversation, I'm only gonna call you out on two of your fabrications."
Other than to narrow his eyes, Solomon doesn't respond.
"The first," you say, "is the idea that Grand Servants have carte blanche to incarnate into any timeline at will. Flawless materialization of the soul is impossible -- and so, if it happens, it's either mediated by Magic, or explicitly permitted by the Counter Force. Last I checked, Solomon the King happens not to be the current custodian of Heaven's Feel -- and outside of imminent apocalypse, Alaya isn't in the habit of passing out its house-keys at all."
"We've seen him manifesting and demanifesting, though," says Da Vinci. "If you're saying that Grand Servants can't actually do that voluntarily, how'd he pull it off?"
You gesture with your arm.
"Sleight of hand," you say. "To an observer in any timeline we visit, our own leyshifting would appear to do exactly the same thing. Difference is, we don't go around telling people that we're higher beings."
"So -- this whole time, we really have just been fighting the equivalent of leyshift projections," mutters Da Vinci, eyeing Solomon and Grand Assassin with disdain. "But hold on. If Grand Servants can choose not to be summoned, and Solomon isn't able to incarnate himself, how's he even here?"
You give an unladylike snort.
"Clearly, he was summoned," you say, dismissively. "But that brings me to his second fabrication -- the idea that, as Grand Servants, we actually have the option of refusing a summons. We don't, period. Otherwise, we wouldn't be Grand Servants."
For once, Da Vinci appears to be as lost as Mashu. You decide to preemptively clarify.
"The concept of a 'Grand Servant' only exists as a thing because Alaya needs a summonable defense against existential threats. So long as we're manifested in the capacity of a Grand Servant, in other words, we're acting on the explicit permission of the Counter Force -- at request. Ergo, by definition, you can't be a Grand Servant and still maintain the freedom to refuse a call. It's just outright impossible."
Again, you fix your gaze on Solomon.
"Fortunately," you say, "the King of Magecraft isn't capable of achieving the impossible." The sides of your lips curl upwards. "That's why he's the King of Magecraft."
It's a closed-circle mystery.
You -- the one playing the role of the great detective -- have already witnessed the ending of the story in all of its depressing horror. Because of time shenanigans, however, you're now in the past, and you're using your foreknowledge to cheat pettily in a game of 'deductions.' It's all for a good cause, though.
You intend to teach a valuable lesson to Solomon the Wise.
"You've lied a lot," you say. "But here and now, for the sake of conversation, I'm only gonna call you out on two of your fabrications."
Other than to narrow his eyes, Solomon doesn't respond.
"The first," you say, "is the idea that Grand Servants have carte blanche to incarnate into any timeline at will. Flawless materialization of the soul is impossible -- and so, if it happens, it's either mediated by Magic, or explicitly permitted by the Counter Force. Last I checked, Solomon the King happens not to be the current custodian of Heaven's Feel -- and outside of imminent apocalypse, Alaya isn't in the habit of passing out its house-keys at all."
"We've seen him manifesting and demanifesting, though," says Da Vinci. "If you're saying that Grand Servants can't actually do that voluntarily, how'd he pull it off?"
You gesture with your arm.
"Sleight of hand," you say. "To an observer in any timeline we visit, our own leyshifting would appear to do exactly the same thing. Difference is, we don't go around telling people that we're higher beings."
"So -- this whole time, we really have just been fighting the equivalent of leyshift projections," mutters Da Vinci, eyeing Solomon and Grand Assassin with disdain. "But hold on. If Grand Servants can choose not to be summoned, and Solomon isn't able to incarnate himself, how's he even here?"
You give an unladylike snort.
"Clearly, he was summoned," you say, dismissively. "But that brings me to his second fabrication -- the idea that, as Grand Servants, we actually have the option of refusing a summons. We don't, period. Otherwise, we wouldn't be Grand Servants."
For once, Da Vinci appears to be as lost as Mashu. You decide to preemptively clarify.
"The concept of a 'Grand Servant' only exists as a thing because Alaya needs a summonable defense against existential threats. So long as we're manifested in the capacity of a Grand Servant, in other words, we're acting on the explicit permission of the Counter Force -- at request. Ergo, by definition, you can't be a Grand Servant and still maintain the freedom to refuse a call. It's just outright impossible."
Again, you fix your gaze on Solomon.
"Fortunately," you say, "the King of Magecraft isn't capable of achieving the impossible." The sides of your lips curl upwards. "That's why he's the King of Magecraft."
Last edited: