I think the big deal here is that where Karin is concerned its just a talking sword. Swords are things you find and pick up, not generally what you are born with.

She most likely thinks she ran into this magic ghost sword lying around after the owner died
Neji already said she was a part of her soul earlier. Honestly in Karin's position my guess would be 'dunno, reincarnation or something?'

[X] As far as I know, before the Hollow attack I was a pretty normal girl from a spiritually sensitive family, but I guess maybe there's more to it. Nejibana said something about how she's my 'birthright', and both she and Hat n Clogs have acted like I should already know a thing or two about shinigami, but she's not answering me right now. I don't know what else to tell you.
-[X] Suggest that you'd be happy to try and get more information from Nejibana and Urahara. When this conversation is over, let Goat Face know about it, including your plans to try and get answers - this whole day has left you feeling pretty down and worn out, and dads are supposed to be good at helping you feel better about this kind of stuff, right?
 
[X] As far as I know, before the Hollow attack I was a pretty normal girl from a spiritually sensitive family, but I guess maybe there's more to it. Nejibana said something about how she's my 'birthright', and both she and Hat n Clogs have acted like I should already know a thing or two about shinigami, but she's not answering me right now. I don't know what else to tell you.
-[X] Suggest that you'd be happy to try and get more information from Nejibana and Urahara. When this conversation is over, let Yuzu and Goat Face know about it, including your plans to try and get answers - this whole day has left you feeling pretty down and worn out, and family is supposed to be good at helping you feel better about this kind of stuff, right?
 
Last edited:
[jk] I suppose it could be a variation of the Hidden Prince/Princess trope. Kaien and Miyako could be my parents. The pregnancy and birth was hidden because they wanted me to have a mortal life. They found a nice couple to raise me. Once Kaien realized that he would die, he ordered his zanpakuto to search for his heir. Upon my death, Nejibana found and saved me. Now it's up to me my to reclaim my rightful place as a dead magical samurai queen! I could also be a Mordred type. The hidden bastard of the prince sent away to avoid a succesion fight. Maybe I am Kaien, ressurected with dark magic by a grief stricken family. Hidden from sight so that the authorities would not find out their terrible crime, but they almost did anyway! As a last resort they altered my memories and body, and found a nice couple to take care of me. I don't know much about spiritual matters, but those the options that would be given in a video game. Does any of those options sound plausible?
 
[X] As far as I know, before the Hollow attack I was a pretty normal girl from a spiritually sensitive family, but I guess maybe there's more to it. Nejibana said something about how she's my 'birthright', and both she and Hat n Clogs have acted like I should already know a thing or two about shinigami, but she's not answering me right now. I don't know what else to tell you.
-[X] Suggest that you'd be happy to try and get more information from Nejibana and Urahara. When this conversation is over, let Goat Face know about it, including your plans to try and get answers - this whole day has left you feeling pretty down and worn out, and dads are supposed to be good at helping you feel better about this kind of stuff, right?
Adhoc vote count started by Storyteller on Apr 14, 2017 at 10:00 AM, finished with 1080 posts and 19 votes.

  • [X] As far as I know, before the Hollow attack I was a pretty normal girl from a spiritually sensitive family, but I guess maybe there's more to it. Nejibana said something about how she's my 'birthright', and both she and Hat n Clogs have acted like I should already know a thing or two about shinigami, but she's not answering me right now. I don't know what else to tell you.
    -[X] Suggest that you'd be happy to try and get more information from Nejibana and Urahara. When this conversation is over, let Goat Face know about it, including your plans to try and get answers - this whole day has left you feeling pretty down and worn out, and dads are supposed to be good at helping you feel better about this kind of stuff, right?
    [X] Cut the crap! I died and got powers. You think the fact that my zanpakuto is the same as this guy you knew is important? What about the fact that I can never have a normal life!? It's your fault inn the first place! Maybe if you had been better at your job, I would still be alive. Maybe my brother and I would not have to run around killing monsters for you. And now you accuse me of being someone else. Saying that my family is not my family. Screw this.
    -[X] Walk up and leave.
    [X] - "Look, my blade just came to me from inside after I died. I don't know how. And yeah, I know that sounds crazy and not how it works but..." You trail off and blink. "I'm old enough to know there's usually a cause for things happening. You know what, let's go ambush goat da....Isshin right now. My powers came from somewhere and he took it suprisingly without shock."
    [X] I am Karin Kurosaki. Literally no idea why I have a dead guy's Zanpakuto, but now it's mine.
    -[X] Ignore the issue for now
    [X] As far as I know, before the Hollow attack I was a pretty normal girl from a spiritually sensitive family, but I guess maybe there's more to it. Nejibana said something about how she's my 'birthright', and both she and Hat n Clogs have acted like I should already know a thing or two about shinigami, but she's not answering me right now. I don't know what else to tell you.
    -[X] Suggest that you'd be happy to try and get more information from Nejibana and Urahara. When this conversation is over, let Goat Face know about it, including your plans to try and get answers - this whole day has left you feeling pretty down and worn out, and dads are supposed to be good at helping you feel better about this kind of stuff, right?
    -[X] While you're at it, maybe you should introduce Goat Face to Hat'n'Clogs anyways? Being open worked before, he'd probably appreciate meeting* the boss of his daughters new part-time job , especially since the guy could explain better about whats happening to Ichigo and Karin and all.
    [x]First things first, give Rukia a tentative hug, she's sad and that makes you sad.
    -[x] Tell her how you gained your powers, and about how you seemed to be normal before that happened.
    --[x] You want to get more answers, so you decide to seek out what you can.
    ---[x] Ask Nejibana if she knows what's going on, and if she remembers this other guy.
    ----[x] Call dad, you're kind of upset, and maybe he can help you figure out what to do.
    -----[x] Include Yuzu, acquire firm hugs.
    ------[x] After the talk with dad, suggest you all four go to see if Urahara knows anything more.
    -------[x] In the conversation with Dad (and later with Urahara), specifically bring up the details of how you got your powers.
    --------[x] Ichigo can be included in any of this he wants to.
    [X]Tell her that we got attacked by a hollow trying to protect a ghost, then, next thing we knew, we were talking to Nejibana in our inner world thing about whether or not we wanted to live.
    -[X] Maybe he left the sword lying around after he died?
    -[X] You don't feel like you're some kind of superghost samurai before you got your powers, but you're pretty sure you've always been a girl. Yuzu could back you up on that!
    -[X] If she's still unsatisfied, suggest interrogating Urahara, that guy always seems like he knows something, but odds are he'd just give another mysterious answer.
    [X] OliWhale
 
[X] As far as I know, before the Hollow attack I was a pretty normal girl from a spiritually sensitive family, but I guess maybe there's more to it. Nejibana said something about how she's my 'birthright', and both she and Hat n Clogs have acted like I should already know a thing or two about shinigami, but she's not answering me right now. I don't know what else to tell you.
-[X] Suggest that you'd be happy to try and get more information from Nejibana and Urahara. When this conversation is over, let Goat Face know about it, including your plans to try and get answers - this whole day has left you feeling pretty down and worn out, and dads are supposed to be good at helping you feel better about this kind of stuff, right?
 
[X] As far as I know, before the Hollow attack I was a pretty normal girl from a spiritually sensitive family, but I guess maybe there's more to it. Nejibana said something about how she's my 'birthright', and both she and Hat n Clogs have acted like I should already know a thing or two about shinigami, but she's not answering me right now. I don't know what else to tell you.
-[X] Suggest that you'd be happy to try and get more information from Nejibana and Urahara. When this conversation is over, let Goat Face know about it, including your plans to try and get answers - this whole day has left you feeling pretty down and worn out, and dads are supposed to be good at helping you feel better about this kind of stuff, right?

No hugging!
 
[X] Cut the crap! I died and got powers. You think the fact that my zanpakuto is the same as this guy you knew is important? What about the fact that I can never have a normal life!? It's your fault inn the first place! Maybe if you had been better at your job, I would still be alive. Maybe my brother and I would not have to run around killing monsters for you. And now you accuse me of being someone else. Saying that my family is not my family. Screw this.
-[X] Walk up and leave.
 
Edited vote slightly to reflect some stuff Storm said in Discord. Specifically, added

"...let Yuzu and Goat Face know..."

and changed "dads are" to "family is".

[X] As far as I know, before the Hollow attack I was a pretty normal girl from a spiritually sensitive family, but I guess maybe there's more to it. Nejibana said something about how she's my 'birthright', and both she and Hat n Clogs have acted like I should already know a thing or two about shinigami, but she's not answering me right now. I don't know what else to tell you.
-[X] Suggest that you'd be happy to try and get more information from Nejibana and Urahara. When this conversation is over, let Yuzu and Goat Face know about it, including your plans to try and get answers - this whole day has left you feeling pretty down and worn out, and family is supposed to be good at helping you feel better about this kind of stuff, right?
 
[X]Tell her that we got attacked by a hollow trying to protect a ghost, then, next thing we knew, we were talking to Nejibana in our inner world thing about whether or not we wanted to live.
-[X] Maybe he left the sword lying around after he died?
-[X] You don't feel like you're some kind of superghost samurai before you got your powers, but you're pretty sure you've always been a girl. Yuzu could back you up on that!
-[X] If she's still unsatisfied, suggest interrogating Urahara, that guy always seems like he knows something, but odds are he'd just give another mysterious answer.
 
I'm not in the mood to wade through several pages to find the leading vote, so could anyone tell me if the bandwagon mentions the possibility of reincarnation? Because that's the most likely assumption with our IC knowledge.
 
I'm not in the mood to wade through several pages to find the leading vote, so could anyone tell me if the bandwagon mentions the possibility of reincarnation? Because that's the most likely assumption with our IC knowledge.
It doesn't. Partially because I don't think reincarnation has actually come up at any point IC?
 
It doesn't. Partially because I don't think reincarnation has actually come up at any point IC?
The explanation about hollows, pluses and soul society contains it. Soul Society acts as a buffer for souls to wait in until they are reincarnated. Hell, the whole point of that flaming chicken masquerading as a halberd they have sitting on that one hill is that it completely obliterates a soul, preventing it from ever reincarnating again.

So it follows that (with our IC knowledge) if Nejibana, and zanpakuto spirits in general are literally part of their wielder's soul, and our spirit formerly belonged to a now long since dead shinigami, we are the reincarnation of said shinigami. Since it wouldn't make sense for the soul to fragment during reincarnation and for one particular fragment perfectly attaching to another soul without any issues whatsoever. We have proof in the form of extra knowledge and skills we shouldn't have and the fact that we (almost) instantly recognised Nejibana as part of us, with her confirming and consenting to it.
 
Last edited:
The explanation about hollows, pluses and soul society contains it. Soul Society acts as a buffer for souls to wait in until they are reincarnated. Hell, the whole point of that flaming chicken masquerading as a halberd they have sitting on that one hill is that it completely obliterates a soul, preventing it from ever reincarnating again.
Right, but what I'm asking is whether all that actually got brought up in our discussion with Urahara:

What follows is a frankly fantastical tale of death gods, evil spirits, spiritual power and the afterlife – and apparently, you'd just spontaneously become one of these shinigami. Come to think of it, didn't you identify that monster as a Hollow, before?

I suppose we could always just ask. @Stormwhite, was the idea of reincarnation brought up at any point during our discussion(s) about Soul Society, such that Karin might make the jump to that as a hypothesis?
 
[X] As far as I know, before the Hollow attack I was a pretty normal girl from a spiritually sensitive family, but I guess maybe there's more to it. Nejibana said something about how she's my 'birthright', and both she and Hat n Clogs have acted like I should already know a thing or two about shinigami, but she's not answering me right now. I don't know what else to tell you.
-[X] Suggest that you'd be happy to try and get more information from Nejibana and Urahara. When this conversation is over, let Yuzu and Goat Face know about it, including your plans to try and get answers - this whole day has left you feeling pretty down and worn out, and family is supposed to be good at helping you feel better about this kind of stuff, right?
 
[X] I understand why Nejibana is so important to you, if I lost Yuzu, Ichigo, or Goat Chin, I would be crushed; but the only thing I did to bring her out was have a desire to not die. I don't know why it happened I'm just glad it did. You are the expert here, is there any natural way a sword can get a new wielder after they die.
 
Last edited:
[X] As far as I know, before the Hollow attack I was a pretty normal girl from a spiritually sensitive family, but I guess maybe there's more to it. Nejibana said something about how she's my 'birthright', and both she and Hat n Clogs have acted like I should already know a thing or two about shinigami, but she's not answering me right now. I don't know what else to tell you.
-[X] Suggest that you'd be happy to try and get more information from Nejibana and Urahara. When this conversation is over, let Yuzu and Goat Face know about it, including your plans to try and get answers - this whole day has left you feeling pretty down and worn out, and family is supposed to be good at helping you feel better about this kind of stuff, right?
 
Right, but what I'm asking is whether all that actually got brought up in our discussion with Urahara:



I suppose we could always just ask. @Stormwhite, was the idea of reincarnation brought up at any point during our discussion(s) about Soul Society, such that Karin might make the jump to that as a hypothesis?

Hm, Karin is aware of the cycle of reincarnation, but it's a bit of a stretch...

You can include it in the vote if you want, but I may not include it in its entirety.

For the Viewing pleasure of the floor, may I present a rough sketch of Nejibana
Not the cleanest of drawings, but I'm fairly satisfied nonetheless. Honestly, with how rubbish my drawings usually are, I'm quite happy with how this turned out. Perhaps when i return home and have access to my proper coloring pencils I'll give it another go!

Fanart, as always, is that most coveted of gifts! Take 200 XP to assign where you see fit!
 
[X] "I don't know anything about that. I was just a simple tailor 13 year old girl who most certainly did not see spirits until I was killed. Go bug Goatface. If I was the suspicious sort, I'd think something was up between me and Ichigo."
- [X] If she protests, stab her in the heart for power.
 
Back
Top