It sounds like we have some very different interpretations of what Order and Chaos mean, so I think it would definitely be nice to have some author-given examples of concrete scenarios and what the different-alignment characters might say about them.
EDIT: And I think "what does this-alignment Annette have to say about the bullying situation" is a nice example to use.
Light / Law Annette: "Alan, you're going to have a talk with your daughter, or I'm going to go talk with my study buddy from my PhD days. The Superintendent of the school district."
Light / Neutral Annette: *Emma gets home, finds Annette in her living room* Emma Marie Barnes, you are going to sit and listen, or so help me - I helped get your mother into position to bring you into this world, I can use that authority to remove you from it temporarily as well.
Light / Chaos Annette: "Anne, darling child of my best friend named after me. Emma has decided to bully Taylor. I need your help. I have 200 lbs of glitter, a large box of feathers, more peanut butter than you can shake a stick at. Do with them what you will."
Law / Light Annette: *Has already spoken to the principal, every teacher, and the superintendent*
Law / Neutral Annette: *transfers Taylor to Arcadia*
Law / Dark Annette: Look at me. I am the Principal now.
Dark / Law Annette: *Blackwell retires in disgrace, every little mistake she ever made shown to the Superintendent*
Dark / Neutral Annette: *Sophia Hess disappears into the Juvie system, Madison transfers schools, somehow Emma ends up alone, everyone treating her as a pariah*
Dark / Chaos Annette: *Emma ends up in the hospital, with a fractured collarbone* She says Fenja did it, but won't look at Annette and won't bully Taylor anymore
Chaos / Light Annette: Right, Taylor. Three months. We're getting you a GED and into college.
Chaos / Neutral Annette: *Winslow is found burned down. Fenja implicated.*
Chaos / Dark Annette: *keeps Taylor home 'sick' for the day. Uber and Leet decide to play Bully at Winslow. Somehow Fenja implicated in paying them, her identity revealed causes a lot of problems because of additional scrutiny brought on the other inner circle members of the Empire *