KingCrimson1081 said:
I'm not sure if Edgar would like working with the Chinese either since if I remember my Fallout Lore correctly they are as bad as the FUSA.
zezia said:
There is really nothing we know about China in Fallout except anything from FUSA propaganda. We don't know if they were experimenting on their civilians, forcing them into concentration camps, viruses to wipe out the world. While I am not saying China would be some paragon of virtue we can't compare it to FUSA when we know so little about it.
I'm not sure what might have been said out-of-universe, but yeah, as far as in-universe evidence goes, while we can assume that the American propaganda would paint the PRC as super dystopian
whatever the reality was, there's at least one
strong piece of evidence that it was indeed rather bad, I think: the Shi. Their founders were the crew of a nuclear submarine deployed by a highly ideological state during an active war; I think it can be assumed that the CCP considered them among the most ideologically committed members of the population. ...And that means that, unless the CCP badly,
badly misjudged things there, even a group of some of the
most ideologically committed citizens of the PRC, basically at the first real opportunity, enthusiastically abandoned Communism and raised up an emperor. What does that say about how much the
majority of the population genuinely supports the FPRC, vs. being held at gunpoint -- and what, in turn, does
that say about how well that supposedly Communist government is meeting the needs of the people?
The Bird said:
but when your opponent is the devil himself you don't really get to demand every potential ally be an angel
Yeah, working with them could still be quite useful. They're quite possibly still
less bad than FUSA, and they're unlikely significantly worse (worse in some specific ways, maybe, but probably better in other ones). We also don't have much of an ability to greatly improve postwar China here, whether we work with them or not (well, probably -- but if we do get that ability, it probably
is through initially working with the CCP), but we
can improve things for postwar North America -- and since much of that involves attacking FUSA in the present, that's at the very least a common enemy combined with ideological sympathies.