We need better perception.
And anti teleport stuff.
And stealth breaking.
So many things....
On the discord after we chatted about it for a bit If said that actually the Owl-Eye Pulse Fylgia trick we have would have got her, he just forgot we had it. This issue has been fixed by just saying she burned a Rewrite to not get noticed by it, as she does have them. So normally we would have got her, and we don't need too much more paranoia stuff.
 
On the discord after we chatted about it for a bit If said that actually the Owl-Eye Pulse Fylgia trick we have would have got her, he just forgot we had it. This issue has been fixed by just saying she burned a Rewrite to not get noticed by it, as she does have them. So normally we would have got her, and we don't need too much more paranoia stuff.

I still want to know how to take people memories like Corpsemaker did.

Also, before leaving the town maybe we should hunt down Lidrun and ask her some very pointed questions.
 
On the discord after we chatted about it for a bit If said that actually the Owl-Eye Pulse Fylgia trick we have would have got her, he just forgot we had it. This issue has been fixed by just saying she burned a Rewrite to not get noticed by it, as she does have them. So normally we would have got her, and we don't need too much more paranoia stuff.
That's great to hear, but better perception is still valuable.
Oh, right, voting.

[X] DeadmanwalkingXI

Plan sounds good. even if i wanted the knowledge looting.... but there is still plenty of chances for it!

Now, onto the other comments!
Lidrun had a bunch of twists going that allowed her to, essentially, 'peak in on' your Eyetalking. Corpsemaker, of course, knew all about her presence—for she was in his hall—and was going to do that to her regardless of what you gave to him as information, simply as a matter of principle.
Yeah, skalds are annoying.
But they are sure as hel look like great loot pinatas!
Same as yours, but also she feels... Weaker? Like if her legs were wooden stumps or something.
oho... thats interesting...
WE CAN CRIPPLE HER WHAHAHAHAHAH!!!!
Ahem, i mean, we are somewhat advantaged, in spiritual combat then.... but she probably has more spirits in her soulscape.
One of the Ironmasks is. You saw him keeping guard of the beach.

Something about him seemed oddly familiar, though you'd never be able to put your finger on exactly what makes you feel that way.
Hm.... went back and checked... no mention of hair or eye color, so not a relative.
Perhaps someone from the Halding?
So, I'm not really sure if you folks have clocked this or not but you're heading off to go complete the latin thrall quest after this vote, so you should decide if you're going to shapecraft or shop or, perhaps, go hunting for that Ironmask.
Thought so, what with next turn being summer 3.
But it's good to get confirmation, thank you!
All three, no fence, no house, no farm.
....
We could overwhelm her Odr well....
Or, you know, just burn everything in there.
Hm... we DO know how to make scornpoles....
We should just learn shapecrafting. Spend the whole time studying what they do. Ask for the most time consuming and difficult crafts. Learn another new art. Apply it to all who join us.

More paths to power! More, more!!
That would be only the bear bones though, and not exactly safe.
Shapecrafting very explicitly literally drives you permanently insane as the sacrifice needed to access it. I'd be fine with learning Skald stuff...we can afford to talk weird (the sacrifice needed there is speaking in poetry) if it gets us power, but not shapecrafting as we can't afford to have our ability to think, reason, and interact with others compromised like that.
This, yeah. I am all for learning shapecrafting, but not with Halla. She has enough on her plate without the insanity.
It would be cool if we could learn shapecrafting but not go insane. Maybe there's a different price possible.
I mean, we know the why of that insanity.
The enemy will cut his loses but it will never, ever settle for a clear loss.
It really depends on the degree of insanity.
I think its more a scope than degree, but yes.
Like, we met Hikkir. No way we would let him work on anyone we care about.
Then, there was the rivalry between Roberk Milk-Fiend and Korr Junk.
"Yeah, shapecrafters tend not to have the most glamourous of kennings." Hall snorts and shakes his head, "Roberk is convinced that milk and dairy products in general are the 'only thing' that 'they' can't 'infest' and Korr refuses to get rid of anything ever."
I think its more of a fixation thing than pure insanity.
"Oh sure," Hall wiggles a hand before him before pausing and squinting slightly, "well, as much as any shapecrafter can be considered 'reliable'. They're rivals, you see, and will put aside their insanity for a chance to one-up the other."
And there are ways around it. Even if those are rare.
My theory, so far, is this: the worse is the shapeshifter, the more widespread the insanity is.
Horra most probably channeled his insanity into his obsession with the revenge on Steinarr.
Basically, he had an outlet for all the whacky things, so he could keep a firmer grip than most others.
Shapecrafter insanity tends heavily towards the 'completely nonfunctional as a normal human being' level. The sanest shapecrafter we ever met was Horra, by a lot, and he had bombs implanted in the heads of almost everyone he knew, a mad scientist lab full of dead bodies, a broadside capable elephant-horror made of human flesh, and an obsession with revenge stronger than even the Norse would consider reasonable. In addition to neglecting his kids to the point they turned on him and being a complete piece of shit, of course.

And every other shapecrafter we've met or heard of is even worse than that (not morally, mind you, but in terms of how functional they are). Horra could put up a good front of seeming normal...he's the only shapecrafter we've seen or heard of thus far who can do that much.

Halla is eccentric and odd, and I don't object to her becoming more so. I object to her becoming so obsessed with weird subjects she neglects her family or so paranoid she tries to put bombs in the heads of her loved ones, and both of those are real worries (Hirkir very much wanted to put bombs in his family's heads). Shapecrafting is not 'does a few weird things' kind of crazy it's clinical paranoia combined with bizarre obsessions and mad scientist tendencies you cannot control. It is a deeply unfun kind of crazy.

Per Blackhand this is inevitable as one becomes a shapecrafter, and IF confirmed it as the sacrifice for their power.
As i said, Hora already had an obsession with revenge, which gave him an outlet. like the rivalry between Milk-fiend and Junk giving them one.
I do agree that that outlet was a very bad one for everyone around him.

Halla on the other hand does NOT have an obsession with revenge. So, that's very much is just fearmongering. If anything, her obsession would be to improve others... which, you know, could be even more frightening.
Good thing that could be satisfied with animal/spirit experiments....
But as i already said, i agree we do not do this with Halla. She will serve as the anchor in Charred Soul that she is to her family in her life. A stable point. And we know how much that helped her from when Blackhand got washed out of her soul.

Edit: typos
 
Last edited:
Whats the blood infusion btw?
If you go back a while, to the Logi vs Steinarr fight we saw, Logi had fire whips that stayed connected between his limbs when they got chopped off, and then pulled them back in. There is also a guy around who is shadowy, and Farbjorn (Abjorn's brother, we met him at the castle raid for King Alfred) who's body seems to be made of Iron and he seems to bleed Odr. Logi and Shadowman both seem to have the budget version (Alloy slot + Shapeshift slot + Substance + Rewrite), and Farbjorn seems to have the proper Odr version. Basically you take in the blood that has magical properties through some method that we think is Hamr based and in Odr cultivation, and it gives you fun magical powers, or you can do it the budget way where it locks you into a Alloy and Shapeshift slot, burns a Rewrite, and probably isn't as powerful.

Anti-Doublepost Edit:
You have dueled and defeated Hooknails, earning you 9 Orthstirr a Year
You have slain the Jotun Heklr, earning you 9 Orthstirr a Year
Separately, IF, is there a behind-the-scenes explanation for these both giving the same amount? This isn't a complaint, just wondering about how the system works. Maybe is it something like we soloed Hooknails in front of hundreds of people, whereas Heklr was in front of much less people and we were helped in it by Careful-Stepper?
 
Last edited:
What did having the house and farm and fence help us with? They made our breaktrough better but in what way?
 
What did having the house and farm and fence help us with? They made our breaktrough better but in what way?
Fence - Became the mountain range around our soulscape, makes it harder for people to get in by just walking
Farm - Became the valley that is now full of those baby spirit wisps
House - Became the massive mountain in the middle of our soul that they farm/house/fence are on, I think the Gate is also up there

Basically they mean that we can continue on cultivating and progressing properly and in a safer way. It also means that we don't have a salt marsh as our soulscape, instead we have mountains, the Hading valley, and Gotland, and a horde of spirits we can feed stuff too to upgrade them.
 
The fence also protected our soul from the water that flooded it when the frozen eitr walls melted iirc. Had we not made a fence, I imagine our soul would be a swamp, like Lidrun's.
And as the soul reflects the mind, so does the mind reflect the soul. The symbolism between her being a treacherous person and her soul being a literal swamp may have implications beyond coincidence.
 
I feel like we really hate Lidrun here. And I mean she is a terrible person with typical xianxia attitudes to people. But imagine learning things from her perspective after meeting Halla.

Like, objectively she is a dark mirror of Halla, who just pushed even harder against the requirements of her people. She's a woman in Norse society who decided to make her own way. She rejected the norms of family and farm and became a Skald, she traveled the world and learned its secrets, she learned more of the Truth than many others ever had. She is a feminist icon in charting her own path without needing a man or what society says she needs.

And then it turns out by rejecting these norms she has fucked up the secrets she found. That by marrying and having a family and a farm and all that Halla was better at these secrets than her. I bet she's pissed. She went full 'I will find my own way if society frowns on me' but oops, she's in a cultivation system where following cultural moors is actually important to do.

If this quest wasn't an explicitly legacy quest from the beginning I could have seen Halla becoming more like her. Not in calling normal cultivators Livestock and animals, but at least in rejecting society and their expectations more. Not marrying, not having kids, but instead exploring the world and trying to find her own path outside Norse patriarchal expectation.


Edit: My reading of her is probably more charitable than she's meant to be, just to note. But feminist icons are often presented uncharitably. 😉
 
Last edited:
Was that us flying around, or was it the free Fylgia exploring thingy? As if it wasn't the Fylgia, should we send it on a few runs over?

It was us. We could send the fylgja to explore more next turn if that's an available action, yeah.

I feel like we really hate Lidrun here. And I mean she is a terrible person with typical xianxia attitudes to people. But imagine learning things from her perspective after meeting Halla.

Like, objectively she is a dark mirror of Halla, who just pushed even harder against the requirements of her people. She's a woman in Norse society who decided to make her own way. She rejected the norms of family and farm and became a Skald, she traveled the world and learned its secrets, she learned more of the Truth than many others ever had. She is a feminist icon in charting her own path without needing a man or what society says she needs.

And then it turns out by rejecting these norms she has fucked up the secrets she found. That by marrying and having a family and a farm and all that Halla was better at these secrets than her. I bet she's pissed. She went full 'I will find my own way if society frowns on me' but oops, she's in a cultivation system where following cultural moors is actually important to do.

If this quest wasn't an explicitly legacy quest from the beginning I could have seen Halla becoming more like her. Not in calling normal cultivators Livestock and animals, but at least in rejecting society and their expectations more. Not marrying, not having kids, but instead exploring the world and trying to find her own path outside Norse patriarchal expectation.

The thing that makes a lot of this just not quite right, is that having a family is actually irrelevant for cultivation, and having a farm is only relevant in that you must own some sort of property (a ship also works). What you need to do is know how to farm and build a home, and understand the world well enough to duplicate that within your soulscape to make it home-like. You don't actually have to do it in the real world (and, indeed, doing so does nothing for your soulscape at all), you just need the knowledge of how to do it, and the patience to figure out that, in your soulscape, you should.

It was Lidrun's contempt and recklessness that caused this, by leaving her without the skills to farm or make a house for herself and without pausing to think about what her empty soulscape needed before rushing ahead to Stage 2. It is not her refusal to be a normal or conventional person that has damaged her, but her contempt for such people and disregard for the worth of their skills. And, to damage the feminist reading further, the biggest skills involved that she disregards (house and fence building and farming) are actually classically masculine rather than feminine...refusing to learn them isn't defying gender roles, it's just an expression of contempt for those who need to work the land for a living (ie: almost everyone).

So, IMO, even with a charitable reading, it is almost purely her most negative personal qualities that have caused her this problem, not her refusal to be conventional. Add in the comparing people to animals and my sympathy for this situation is low to nonexistent.

And, as alexthealright notes, objectively Lidrun is actually doing quite well, she doesn't need sympathy outside of her poor cultivation choices, so even if she has many positive or sympathetic qualities (and I'm doubtful) her one serious issue is still her own damn fault due to her worse ones.
 
Last edited:
1 I'd be more sympathetic if she didn't think people without Odr were as good as animals

I mean yeah this is a big flaw and why she's not a protagonist of this, and is instead a darker mirror of what our protagonist could have been potentially. Though I wouldn't be surprised if she had a reason to justify it at least partially to herself, beyond just 'I am a bitch'.

2 She's doing pretty well for herself in this society, far better than a bunch of other people we know anyway.

Norse society is a patriarchal hell hole that happens to also be a might makes right hell hole. She's great at being in this society from the perspective of being strong, but she fails at every other aspect of the society. She does not want to settle down with family or learn skills related to that. She wants to travel and get strong and not give a fuck about the normal life stuff.

She kinda is like Halla's extended family just worse. The only part of society she has embraced is that power makes her right to take from others. Halla's extended family at least has slaves do farming and see some value in that stuff. Just not the same value they do in strength.

So, IMO, even with a charitable reading, it is almost purely her most negative personal qualities that have caused her this problem, not her refusal to be conventional

See, I disagree here. Building a farm and home and tending to Livestock and stuff ate all parts of a Norse society she wants nothing to do with, because this is the same society that says she should be doing X and never Y. Her contempt for them is understandable under the feminist reading, even if it's traditionally man's work to make a farm, because it's still women's work to makensure the farm functions and to settle down.

We saw it kinda explicitly in this exact quest and have had the conversation about it in regards to our children: men have more freedom to fuck around and go do whatever they want for years. Women are more tied down to land and duties. If we had picked Hallr over Halla, we probably would have had far less push to marry young and start a family.
 
Last edited:
Odr is kinda creativity juice. Not having any might be problematic.
For all we know, everyone without internal cultivation are all p-zombies, or otherwise literally lesser somehow, with Halla only escaping this because of Blackhand shenanigans.
Not very likely, but has it been ruled out?
 
Norse society is a patriarchal hell hole that happens to also be a might makes right hell hole. She's great at being in this society from the perspective of being strong, but she fails at every other aspect of the society. She does not want to settle down with family or learn skills related to that. She wants to travel and get strong and not give a fuck about the normal life stuff.

She kinda is like Halla's extended family just worse. The only part of society she has embraced is that power makes her right to take from others. Halla's extended family at least has slaves do farming and see some value in that stuff. Just not the same value they do in strength.
That's not really incompatible with my point but I have zero interest in getting into a debate about this which is why I removed the second point before you posted this.
 
Odr is kinda creativity juice. Not having any might be problematic.
For all we know, everyone without internal cultivation are all p-zombies, or otherwise literally lesser somehow, with Halla only escaping this because of Blackhand shenanigans.
Not very likely, but has it been ruled out?
Can you provide any evidence for it?

Because if there's any doubt i'd suggest treating people like people instead of P-zombies

Also it would mean that almost none of the characters we know matter and that seems bad from a narrative standpoint.
 
Last edited:
Odr is kinda creativity juice. Not having any might be problematic.
For all we know, everyone without internal cultivation are all p-zombies, or otherwise literally lesser somehow, with Halla only escaping this because of Blackhand shenanigans.
Not very likely, but has it been ruled out?

I mean...yes, yes it has been ruled out. We can literally communicate with them telepathically and interact with their souls in various ways. To say nothing of the non-Norse cultivators and mortals and how they work. Lidrun is just awful.

See, I disagree here. Building a farm and home and tending to Livestock and stuff ate all parts of a Norse society she wants nothing to do with, because this is the same society that says she should be doing X and never Y. Her contempt for them is understandable under the feminist reading, even if it's traditionally man's work to make a farm, because it's still women's work to makensure the farm functions and to settle down.

We saw it kinda explicitly in this exact quest and have had the conversation about it in regards to our children: men have more freedom to fuck around and go do whatever they want for years. Women are more tied down to land and duties. If we had picked Hallr over Halla, we probably would have had far less push to marry young and start a family.

Not wanting to do them is perfectly understandable. Refusing to acknowledge that they have worth when they're what's letting her eat and sleep with a roof over her head is much more problematic. And, when presented with an empty clearing that is her soul, not at least fortifying the place is just kinda dumb. Like, I sort of expected her to not have a farm, which would be defensible with this reasoning I guess, but having neither a house nor fence/walls is much harder to justify.
 
Last edited:
I mean...yes, yes it has been ruled out. We can literally communicate with them telepathically and interact with their souls in various ways. To say nothing of the non-Norse cultivators and mortals and how they work. Lidrun is just awful.
Surprise surprise, the reckless dumbass who rushed Enlightenment knows jack shit about how Reality works! Who could've ever guessed? :V
 
Back
Top