Closing vote. Thanks to all who provided discussion and feedback. Dice to follow.
Scheduled vote count started by Karf on Dec 7, 2021 at 4:35 AM, finished with 62 posts and 20 votes.
23
[X] Plan: Transfiguration
-[X][Boon] An especially shiny Galleon
-[X][Training] Transfiguration (x4)
-[X][Social] It is absolutely essential that you see Mandy's little friend again... Err, that you see Mandy again. Yes, you just want to ask her more about pet care, maybe even get a familiar of your own. No ulterior motives here.
--[X] 2 Point
-[X][Social] The only Ravenclaw you haven't properly met yet is Sue Li, and you're determined to fix that. Track her down and gain some insight into the mystery that is Sue.
-[X][Social] The Hogwarts Express rides for London, to let muggleborn students visit their families for a few days. Of course you're on board.
[X] Plan: New Year, New Skills
-[X][Boon] An especially shiny Galleon
-[X][Training] Transfiguration (x4)
-[X][Social] It is absolutely essential that you see Mandy's little friend again... Err, that you see Mandy again. Yes, you just want to ask her more about pet care, maybe even get a familiar of your own. No ulterior motives here.
--[X] 2 Points
-[X][Social] Given how often magical portraits seem to come up in your brief time at Hogwarts, perhaps you should learn more about them. A tiny part of your mind also whispers that it would be cool to bring your doodles to life.
--[X] 1 Point
-[X][Social] The Hogwarts Express rides for London, to let muggleborn students visit their families for a few days. Of course you're on board.
[X] Plan: Classwork
-[X][Boon] An especially shiny Galleon
-[X][Training] Transfiguration (x3)
-[X][Training] Charms (x1)
-[X][Social] You're invited for tea with Lavender Brown - she says it'll be a small gathering, but that it should be fun.
-[X][Social] It is absolutely essential that you see Mandy's little friend again... Err, that you see Mandy again. Yes, you just want to ask her more about pet care, maybe even get a familiar of your own. No ulterior motives here.
--[X] 2 Point
-[X][Social] The Hogwarts Express rides for London, to let muggleborn students visit their families for a few days. Of course you're on board.
[X] Plan: Befriending
-[X][Boon] A wet candle
-[X][Training] Transfiguration (x4)
-[X][Social] The only Ravenclaw you haven't properly met yet is Sue Li, and you're determined to fix that. Track her down and gain some insight into the mystery that is Sue.
-[X][Social] You're invited for tea with Lavender Brown - she says it'll be a small gathering, but that it should be fun.
-[X][Social] Tracey Davis offered to be your friend... or was it the other way around? Regardless, you wouldn't mind another lesson on immortal customs, and her straightforward manner can be refreshing.
[X] Plan More Transfiguration
-[X][Boon] An inky bottle
-[X][Training] Transfiguration (x4)
-[X][Social] You're invited for tea with Lavender Brown - she says it'll be a small gathering, but that it should be fun.
-[X][Social] Terry has heard that you know the secret to accessing the kitchen. He's promised you cookies if you take him and another of his fellow chefs to it, with implications of more bounties if you help them out further.
--[X] Use 2 points
-[X][Social] Given how often magical portraits seem to come up in your brief time at Hogwarts, perhaps you should learn more about them. A tiny part of your mind also whispers that it would be cool to bring your doodles to life.
[X] Plan Plan Plan
-[X][Boon] An especially shiny Galleon
-[X][Training] Transfiguration x2
-[X][Training] Potions
-[X][Social] The only Ravenclaw you haven't properly met yet is Sue Li, and you're determined to fix that. Track her down and gain some insight into the mystery that is Sue.
-[X][Social] Hurricane Chang has decided to spend an afternoon with you, and the topic of the day is obviously going to be Quidditch.
-[X][Social] The Hogwarts Express rides for London, to let muggleborn students visit their families for a few days. Of course you're on board.
I'm not entirely sure I'm understanding your post correctly, sorry. You speak of the fourth action either like we can decide to use it next turn instead of this (roll 3 times now in order to roll 5 times next turn) or like 4 is the max number of actions you can assign to a single subject across any turns. Both of these are false, but your arguments only make sense if you assume either of those premises.
No matter what, the 4 training actions this turn won't have any benefit beyond 6d20 DC15 rolled 4 times. This fourth action (like any other this turn) will give the same points no matter what subject you assign it to. But if you assign it to Charms, the chances that it accomplishes nothing are higher than if you assign it to Transfiguration (together with the other 3). It's that simple.
This is kinda superfluous now, but part of my reasoning was that we don't want to spend more actions on getting these skills up than we have to. If we assume we only want to spend 4 actions getting to Beginner Transfiguration (Tier 2), then spending 3 actions in the first turn gives us a very good chance of getting Basic Transfig, which means when we spend the 4th action in the turn after those rolls benefit from the +20 to each dice. I'm aware if we want to get to Apprentice overflow isn't necessarily a bad thing, but it's also a fact that overflow doesn't do anything for us in the immediate sense (it just makes it easier to reach the next tier in the long run).
Essentially the 4 action limit was an artificial thing I was imposing as we have other things we want to spend actions on, and 4 was the smallest number of actions I could feasibly see us spending at that point in order to reach the Beginner level.
I see what you meant, now, but for a skill like Transfiguration, which is in my opinion unarguably the one most worth bringing to Apprentice, arbitrarily deciding on a cutting point at Beginner doesn't do us any good.
However, once you've dug through the rest of the gifts, one final little box remains, with a note written in a handwriting you don't recognize. The swirls and loops merely say - 'Use it well.'
Who do you guys think sent us the gift? The first thing that came to mind was canon Dumbledore anonymously giving Harry his father's invisibility cloak, but we don't know enough about our mother to say if this story's Dumbledore would feel a similar urge/obligation/desire. The simple note and the fact it wasn't signed could point towards an authority figure who knows they should not be showing favoritism, or more generally, towards someone who doesn't want their association with us being traced back to them (a Greengrass is the most obvious "culprit", there).
Of course, there are other possibilities, but they are more out there, so to speak.
Someone sympathetic to our mother is what I see it as (admittedly this is the unlikely answer). This way, the Point was used to "allow" the delivery of this gift.
Or (this is the most likely answer) it could be Dumbledore (as Santa) who was impressed with us wanting to spend our Point for our friends.
Charms is one of the skills you can use to pass your end of year examinations, provided you reach the apprentice level. Basic covers the very beginner stuff, beginner has two practical and one theoretical milestone (same as most other skills).
On rereading it looks like I misunderstood the skill progression. We need to get all of these breakpoints just to complete the Beginner level (2 practical and 1 theoretical), and then there's probably another one after that for Apprentice.
I think we should still be able to get it in time, but we might not be able to get other classes up to Basic before we breakthrough.
Tbf, we blitzed a category well, and we only need 2 specializations to pass. If the rolls aren't in our favor when can let certain classes fall behind to focus on what is advancing. No need to rush basic for everything.
This should be correct. The total amount of progress you need to pass at the end of the year is 750 (150 for the first milestone and reaching beginner level, then another 600 total to reach apprentice level). The first milestone is cheaper than the rest to provide some small incentive to experiment, while the next stage of a skill is divided into 200 point chunks to have more consistent rewards (Physical being the exception both because an extra action is, as usual, the best reward, and it directly affects how much I have to write for each update, so I can't be handing them out like candy).
-[X][Social] It is absolutely essential that you see Mandy's little friend again... Err, that you see Mandy again. Yes, you just want to ask her more about pet care, maybe even get a familiar of your own. No ulterior motives here.
--[X] 2 Point
-[X][Social] The only Ravenclaw you haven't properly met yet is Sue Li, and you're determined to fix that. Track her down and gain some insight into the mystery that is Sue.
-[X][Social] The Hogwarts Express rides for London, to let muggleborn students visit their families for a few days. Of course you're on board.
1st beginner milestone completed - +30 total to training rolls after this turn
Care of Magical Creatures - rolls: [90, 39] > total: 129/150
From studying the shiny Galleon
It's finally time.
You have an understanding of Qi. Even if it's only about just how far you have to go, you feel like you have a solid base to work off of. Likewise, you know your body has gotten stronger. Perhaps not with the same meteoric rise of your sharpening mind, which has blown most of your classmates out of the water, but stronger all the same. You're more flexible, a walk up a rare stationary staircase no longer makes your pulse climb, stacks of books move as easily as a single page, the whole works.
Thus, you think you're ready for your first technique. Well, you would be, if you had the first inclination about how to go and obtain one.
Thankfully, the library seems to have infinite answers, and from the somewhat infrequent meeting of the study group Tony set up, you also know that Roger Malone has done some research on the topic of transfiguration. You get a list of tomes from him, and blaze through the reading in scant days.
The node of Qi you observed activating in your network following your Quidditch match does indeed match the description of a meridian. While there are specific exercises to coax their opening, what you've experienced is a natural expansion of your abilities, an exceedingly rare occurrence which tends to happen when you fall fully in sync with the Qi of the world. One of the references is a more advanced work which you struggle to wrap your head around, but it does mention that the odds of a natural meridian opening are roughly one in a hundred. It then goes on to detail the conditions, but a lot of that goes over your head.
At least the books Roger recommended are more easily digestible. You find a leaflet about the differences between charms and transfigurations particularly handy. Charms let you change how things are, while your current target lets you alter what they are. There is also a good follow-up hint - apparently everything has inherent aspects.
It's the first time you've come across the term, but it quickly becomes apparent that it forms a cornerstone of all transfiguration. The example you most resonate with is the piercing transformation. It starts with a matchstick, an object which contains very little 'piercing-ness': it's pointy, but not at all meant for stabbing. With the proper application of Qi, however, it's easy to take a similar concept and turn one into the other. A needle is also a tiny rod-shaped utility object, but made of metal, and meant almost solely for piercing. Thus, a common beginner practice technique involves turning a match into a needle, by envisioning the change and working on increasing the piercing aspect of the former.
The book you get it from is meant for beginners, but it does hint at a whole family of sharpening techniques - collectively called a law - with some unexpected uses. The animation of a teacup sliding through a table and leaving a perfectly circular hole behind certainly suggests so. Digging even deeper, you learn that laws are further parts of arts. A fire starting technique might lead to a flame law, which in turn would fall under a heat art.
There are further allusions to the whole field getting more detailed, but you feel confident enough to finally - finally - go for something practical. You're under no illusions about mastering something on your first try, however, so you narrow down the options as much as you humanly can, before you're left with a choice between three different techniques to devote most of the rest of the month to:
-[][Transfiguration] Earthly Cloud Sharpening Law
-??? aspected technique
-??? up to 3 meridians
The First Poke Technique makes whatever it's applied to more readily able to pierce. Considering the ice covering just about every surface outside, you could do with shoes that slice into the slippery stuff and provide you with perfect traction.
-[][Transfiguration] Dollmaker's Petrification Diagram Law
-??? aspected technique
-??? up to 3 meridians
The Total Petrification Technique forces a living target to become stiff and still as a stone statue. While you're fully healed by now, the memory of a troll club slamming into your ribs remains an unpleasant one. If you had the option of freezing the troll, perhaps things would have turned out differently.
-[][Transfiguration] Humble Light Bringer Law
-??? aspected technique
-??? up to 3 meridians
The Light Summoning Technique might not be as fancy, but it's definitely no less useful. The depths of Castle Hogwarts don't have convenient windows or well maintained torches. Several times you've turned away from a dark corridor. Who knows how useful a light you could call on command would be.
For the moment, this choice is more narrative than mechanical. Do you go for the transformation, the petrificus totalus or the lumos. But as hinted, there's more to discover down the road.
Similar choices await you at the other milestones, although I might be railroading the very next one to get more exposition out of the way. The above training scene isn't the whole turn, just to the first milestone, as Rei wants to focus on a technique first, and use the following 200 points to reach competency in it. The same pattern will be used in the future: finishing a particular focus at the milestone and locking in the next thing to work towards then, as opposed to choosing what you gain after having already made the progress. While the latter way would be more convenient from a game standpoint (i.e. get skill points to distribute) it makes little sense from a story perspective (why yes, you just spent a month meditating under a waterfall, have a fireball skill).
-[X][Social] The Hogwarts Express rides for London, to let muggleborn students visit their families for a few days. Of course you're on board.
Roll: 9
As the train finally pulls into King's Cross Station, you banish any niggling feelings of wrongness out of your mind. As the hours passed and the untouched wilderness you were pretty sure wasn't on any map of Scotland gave way to the familiar sight of inhabited Britain once more, something had began to chew at you, but now you firmly deny whatever it was any purchase on your mind.
You step out of the portal leading to the mortal part of the station, emerging on the other side of a wide brick pillar, and quickly spot your father in the crowds. As soon as you start rushing towards him, he notices you right back, and spreads his arms with a smile.
You nearly leap into the hug, your old man letting out a whoosh of air on impact as you squeeze him tightly.
'Was he always this thin?' You feel like you could lift him up, instead of the other way around. Still, while no one is paying attention to you in the crowds, drawing notice with impossible feats of strength might change that, so you don't test your hypothesis.
"I missed you, baby," he whispers in your ear before letting you go.
"Me too, dad."
While you're still bursting with energy, the hour is getting rather late, the ride to London taking up most of the day, so the two of you simply hail a taxi and head home. The drive passes in silence, your stories not something meant for those not in the know, and that silence lets the pit in your stomach rear its head once more.
Everything is just a bit... less. Less than you remember. The evening traffic, which would have once been incredibly annoying, is barely background noise as you find yourself instinctively slipping into a light meditation. The lights of the city are hollow and fake, the fluorescence lacking in any warmth. The snow on the pavement is dirty and soggy, trampled under countless feet. Even when you reach the familiar streets of Croydon, the alleys that once held the promise of adventure now simply serve as a place for rubbish bins, and the projects themselves look shoddy, every brick slapped in place haphazardly.
The little garden in front of your home, once a source of inspiration and joy for you, is now revealed to be a simple patch of grass in the suburbia of London, currently bereft of greenery. The sign on the fence reads 'fire ambulances only', the rest of the letters scraped off in an attempt at juvenile humor.
You still have your memories, of course. Nothing can take those from you. But something tells you that you won't be making many new ones here. Not anymore.
Your home is the same as it always has been. A tiny apartment on the fifth floor, with a view of the tracks and a playground. Dad tells you to scamper off while he whips up some dinner, and you head for your room.
The bed is meant for a child, clearly something you would have outgrown in a year or so regardless, but the way it groans as you sit on the blanket makes you glad you hadn't decided to jump on it. Said blanket itself has a pattern of smiley faces and lilies on it, but it feels... not coarse, but certainly not warm or fluffy either. Just a blanket. There's a light layer of dust on the top of the closet, probably there since before you left in September, and you wipe it away while slipping into your old clothes. Everything is a bit surreal - the shirt and dress fit you just fine, but you still feel a bit more constricted, the Qi surrounding them almost listless.
You take a deep breath, pulling more of the ambient energy into yourself. Qi is still all around you - that seems to remain a fact of life - but it doesn't have any personality, no ingrained sense of mischief or curiosity, no ambition or courageous passion, no diligent love of the world it permeates. You catch a whiff of ketchup from the kitchen, no doubt a part of the dish your dad is preparing, but it no longer smells like food, just an academic amalgamation of sugar and tomatoes. You make a little mental note to remain appreciative despite that, spaghetti had been your favorite before, after all.
"Rei, dinner's served!"
Throughout the meal, you distract yourself by telling dad stories about your adventures, now suitably less edited that you're on hand to provide live explanations. In the few letters you'd sent since the first one, he'd always replied with basically the same platitudes, encouragements and well-wishes, his life without you on hand just not very interesting. Still, you carefully downplay the reality of Quidditch, especially the bludgers. You getting smacked with one would likely just stun you, but you fear that a similar hit on him would lead to fractured bones at least.
The evening proceeds in a similar fashion as the two of you curl up on the couch watching the telly - some silly gameshow providing a backdrop for you to continue running your mouth at dad, showing him your sketches and the accompanying stories about your school. Eventually, he starts to flag, and you let up, knowing that you'll have all of tomorrow as well before you'll need to get back.
You force yourself to sleep, and naturally rise before the winter dawn, silently padding to the kitchen to get started on breakfast. By the time you're finished with the eggs and bacon, the strong aroma of dark tea has done it's job and revived your father, who ruffles your hair as you set the table, praising you despite your protests about this being barely anything.
The praise doubles after the first bite. "My god, Rei. What did you do to the poor chicken? This is amazing!"
You feared as much, even as you make sure to smile extra wide. "Oh, nothing. Just my lucky day."
You really hadn't done anything special. Just flipping eggs at the right time, moving the pan over the stove at the right moments, letting the grease from the bacon lap perfectly at the edges. Things you knew would make the outcome taste better, but something which no mortal could keep track of. Every tiny detail adding up to a marvelous result. Well, marvelous for mortal standards, you consider yourself a mediocre chef at best, especially when you know what the Hogwarts kitchen could produce, to make no mention of the older students or even Terry.
Your dad has the day off, of course, and two tickets to the zoo. The visit is fun, even if it isn't exactly the best season for it, but not very memorable. When you've seen a daddy-long-legs karate kick a book moth in the library, normal arachnids just don't really measure up. The boa constrictor in the reptile house tracks you somewhat eerily, but the large red sign on the glass of the enclosure warning visitors to stay back means you don't go for a closer look. Then you take a quick lunch break at a nearby diner.
"So, sick of your old man yet?" dad asks, tip-toeing around what he really means - do you have anyone else you'd like to see.
You shake your head. While you hold some tiny spark of curiosity about how Ms. Pearsby, your old art teacher, is doing, you certainly don't need it satisfied badly enough to re-visit your old school. As for the other kids... no, you have no one else you want to meet. Well, there is one stop you have to make, but dad is welcome to come along.
The cemetery is empty, so you get to show off your burgeoning progress with transfiguration, lighting the candle with a snap of your fingers, the fire and warmth aspects right on the cusp of culmination, your Qi bringing them over the edge.
"Hi mom," you say, placing the candle in the snow by the foot of the granite gravestone. "I bet you could have done that too, but it's still kind of new for me, so I want to keep practicing even now."
Dad is far enough behind you to be out of earshot, his face inscrutable and somber, lost in his own thoughts and rituals.
"I bet you know what that's like. That and a thousand other things. Hogwarts is amazing, as I'm sure you agree. I could talk about it for days, but I better keep it brief lest dad catch a cold."
"I'm already in the late realm of Qi Gathering. There's only one other kid that's higher than me, I think. And he's both a Lord and some kind of special chosen one, so he doesn't count. Plus I'm better than him in Defense. Top ten for that as well, for sure. But I'm branching out this month, trying Transfiguration."
You let out a little chuckle, "Still sometimes hard to believe that magic is real. That there's a whole science behind it, shelves and shelves of books. Did anyone ever get crushed by one of those in your time? Don't tell me, I don't want to get scared of the library. That would be a tragedy, I'm a Ravenclaw, after all. That's right, repping the blue and bronze. You were in Slytherin, I looked it up in the records. I wonder what that would be like? Would I be all 'this one' and 'as honored senior sect brother wills it'? Were you like that?"
"Sorry, I shouldn't presume, and it's rude to mock people like that. We're playing them next month in Quidditch. Oh! This one you definitely didn't expect: I'm on the team. Keeper, and we won the first match. My teammates are all pretty great. Duncan and Jason are the funny ones, but especially Duncan is also very protective of me. Don't tell dad, but I think he's kind of cute too. Then there's Randy and Jeremy. Jeremy is the captain, and he really takes it seriously. He's good friends with Randy, and I think they really push each other. Roger is the final chaser, and probably the next captain too. He's got both speed and endurance in spades. Finally there's Morgan. He's a seventh year, so it's understandable that he's focused on other things right now. Still, he's plenty good, just not quite as driven. His replacement though, is a real Quidditch freak. Cho's... intense, but I can definitely appreciate her passion."
You continue like that, detailing your adventures with Lisa in the painted world and sprinkling details about your friend in between - her love of charms and art foremost. Then you come clear about the troll, once more asking her not to tell dad the whole truth, before describing Hermione and her bookish nature. Then Tony, Mandy - and Billy - and the other Ravenclaws, then Tracey and Daphne, and Lavender and Susan and Hannah. By the time you're finished, the snow under your feet has melted, and the sun is starting to set.
"So there you have it," you stand up from your crouch, stretching. Your toes and fingers are feeling numb, but that doesn't really matter. "Thanks for watching over me, eh? Love you."
Then you leave, taking your dads hand in yours. Pretty soon you'll be too old for that, but right now, it's fine.
The evening after is quiet, your dad lost in memories and you in your imagination as you decide to get started on a sketch of him reading a book by the window. The next morning, you're once again praised for breakfast before you're taken back to the station, leaving with another hug. This time, you don't hold back and prove that you can, in fact, lift your father.
However, as you settle into an empty compartment, falling into meditation and cycling Qi once again, you're out of excuses. Being home, and more importantly, away from Hogwarts... wasn't what you expected, and not in a good way. How do you reconcile the fact that the mortal world suddenly feels dull and plain? That you suddenly feel apprehensive about returning to your father for the whole summer?
-[][Home] One day at a time. You'll just not think about it, and do the best you can when the time comes. Your father deserves that much, at least, and hopefully you'll get used to the disappointment eventually.
The next two visits to the mortal world will cost a training action.
-[][Home] Through shut eyes. Metaphorically of course... You believe you can wrap your senses in your own Qi, deadening your perception of the world, at the cost of the clarity you've come to take for granted.
For the next two visits to the mortal world, your pool size is 30% smaller.
-[][Home] Through gritted teeth, you'll prevail over yourself. Your own advice once given to Hermione still rings true - if you're unhappy, either change the circumstance or yourself. Since changing the whole world is a bit beyond you, you'll need to change yourself.
For the next two visits to the mortal world, win a combat encounter against yourself or lose two other social actions.
Pet talk with Mandy, half of your training, meeting Sue.
That was well written, but damn, I wasn't expecting the trip home to have this sense of tragedy about it.
[x][Transfiguration] Humble Light Bringer Law
A reading light is a good thing for a Ravenclaw to have. They all sound cool though.
[x][Home] Through shut eyes. Metaphorically of course... You believe you can wrap your senses in your own Qi, deadening your perception of the world, at the cost of the clarity you've come to take for granted.
I was convinced to seitch to the sharpening technique on the premise that it might branch out into general matter manipulation, which would be amazing for an artist.
Also, the fact that Rei focuses on it so much in the chapter feels like a hint.
[X][Home] Through gritted teeth, you'll prevail over yourself. Your own advice once given to Hermione still rings true - if you're unhappy, either change the circumstance or yourself. Since changing the whole world is a bit beyond you, you'll need to change yourself.
I hate the punishment this one gives but it feels the most in character.
[X][Transfiguration] Humble Light Bringer Law
[X][Home] Through gritted teeth, you'll prevail over yourself. Your own advice once given to Hermione still rings true - if you're unhappy, either change the circumstance or yourself. Since changing the whole world is a bit beyond you, you'll need to change yourself.
[X][Transfiguration] Humble Light Bringer Law
[X][Home] Through shut eyes. Metaphorically of course... You believe you can wrap your senses in your own Qi, deadening your perception of the world, at the cost of the clarity you've come to take for granted.
The boa constrictor in the reptile house tracks you somewhat eerily, but the large red sign on the glass of the enclosure warning visitors to stay back means you don't go for a closer look.
The cemetery is empty, so you get to show off your burgeoning progress with transfiguration, lighting the candle with a snap of your fingers, the fire and warmth aspects right on the cusp of culmination, your Qi bringing them over the edge.
[X][Transfiguration] Humble Light Bringer Law
[X][Home] Through gritted teeth, you'll prevail over yourself. Your own advice once given to Hermione still rings true - if you're unhappy, either change the circumstance or yourself. Since changing the whole world is a bit beyond you, you'll need to change yourself.
[X][Transfiguration] Humble Light Bringer Law
[X][Home] Through gritted teeth, you'll prevail over yourself. Your own advice once given to Hermione still rings true - if you're unhappy, either change the circumstance or yourself. Since changing the whole world is a bit beyond you, you'll need to change yourself.
[x][Home] Through shut eyes. Metaphorically of course... You believe you can wrap your senses in your own Qi, deadening your perception of the world, at the cost of the clarity you've come to take for granted.
This seems like the worst drawback mechanically, but is narratively what I want the most. Difficult choice for a difficult circumstance.
[X][Transfiguration] Humble Light Bringer Law
[X][Home] Through gritted teeth, you'll prevail over yourself. Your own advice once given to Hermione still rings true - if you're unhappy, either change the circumstance or yourself. Since changing the whole world is a bit beyond you, you'll need to change yourself.
I loved the feeling of melancholy of the update. I think it was a clever and elegant solution to us rolling below 10 on this home visit, and beyond that, very well described and handled! Kudos, @Karf !
And while I have you here, could you answer a question?
What would happen to sect points we assigned to one of these actions, if we lost?
Mechanically speaking, 50/50 of losing nothing vs losing 2 social actions isn't bad, only risking two rolls that have the same low chance of creating a bonus and a malus (like this Home one). As for the other options, losing 30% of our pool is already worse than losing a training action, and it will become even worse when we'll have more extra actions thanks to Physical cultivation.
That said, I feel like picking the attitude itself, on the face value of it, is as important as (if not more so than) the math attached to it.
"If you're unhappy, either change the circumstance or yourself" is a pretty healthy outlook, though it lacks a key component like acceptance in the face of failure (hopefully implied?).
"Deadening your perception of the world" sounds bad on its own, but you can draw parallels to medication (or even self-medication), and using it when it's appropriate. It's also kind of a "change yourself" idea put into practice, though to a much milder (but maybe more practical?) point.
"One day at a time" is generally wise, but less so when there is something you can do, otherwise it's just ignoring the problem.
So, overall, my preferred choice is:
[X][Home] Through gritted teeth, you'll prevail over yourself. Your own advice once given to Hermione still rings true - if you're unhappy, either change the circumstance or yourself. Since changing the whole world is a bit beyond you, you'll need to change yourself.
[X][Transfiguration] Humble Light Bringer Law
[X][Home] Through gritted teeth, you'll prevail over yourself. Your own advice once given to Hermione still rings true - if you're unhappy, either change the circumstance or yourself. Since changing the whole world is a bit beyond you, you'll need to change yourself.
I'm under the impression the next time we go back home is the summer holidays, as unless HP had an Easter holiday I forgot or there's an emergency, I wasn't aware we'd be allowed to visit home again earlier than that.
Good update though, and it fits especially considering she's a child and she was already a bit out of place even before Hogwarts.
"I'm already in the late realm of Qi Gathering. There's only one other kid that's higher than me, I think. And he's both a Lord and some kind of special chosen one, so he doesn't count. Plus I'm better than him in Defense. Top ten for that as well, for sure. But I'm branching out this month, trying Transfiguration."
I think I underestimated our progress. I knew we'd be one of the best in Spirit, but not that Early Physical would be enough for Top 10. I guess more of our peers than I'd thought focused on Skills/classwork.
On math I think we rolled 370/800, which is below the 404 average but it was enough for the first Beginner milestone so I'm happy.