Recent content by Cookiesndip

Depending on the memories we get, imo, we should talk to Sakura first and foremost at night. Like I said, I want to build an alliance and our relationships in that direction since we have our past history as a solid grounding to it and don't need to rely on our godawful Fellowship to try to...

The thing is, everything you said is 100% reliant on metaknowledge, and also relies on this not having PMMM characters in the mix throwing what we know as 'canon' into chaos. We have zero reason to want to talk to Rin IC, even moreso since we don't even know she is a magus, let anything about...

We don't even know that Rin is a magus IC, let alone her being Second Owner. Nor does Homura have a strong enough IC reason to tell her, especially with what she knows of magi. Really, waiting for a command seal and then waving it around in front of Sakura seems much more sensible, smash down...

Fundamentally, she's been a cannibal for 10 years. Yes, you can hypothetically re-hatch Witches, but how many times has she actually done that? How many times has she quite literally used Sayaka's, Mami's, or Kyoko's grief seeds, or fed them to QB? She probably doesn't think about it. Either...

Incorrect. In Fate, unlike PMMM, the mundane human soul eventually starts to rot after a few hundred years, this isn't unique to Zouken's worm technique, that is just a way to maintain a body, because in Fate, the body grows to reflect the soul (and regardless of the quality of the body, will...

Nah man, we have Sakura right here. Stealing his research doesn't need us to go to him when most of the product of it is right next to us every day. We just need to use Shirou's BS SA on one of Sakura's crest worms, or her heart worm (that is literally Zouken's phylactery). It's not everything...

I disagree, Ruby popping into the story would fuck with the tone of FSN/PMMM way too much and turn it into crack, in my opinion. The thing is insanely broken and was only retroactively added later, even if it didn't make sense that Rin didn't whip it out, say, when it was just her and Shirou...

Is that really the case? I was under the impression that his origin bullets were quite literally made out of his ribs (and thus carries his origin), and that there wasn't anything particularly special about the Contender. How exactly do we go deeper into a tech tree? Do we have to do a few...

What exactly is this? If we want to learn more in this vein, we'd need to pirate it from Shirou, the SA he designed is ridiculous, even if I don't think we'd personally benefit from going that far with it, given chemistry seems like our best utility of it. Projection might still be useful for...

IIRC, he lost interest in the club because he saw no challenge in it - he quite literally never misses (except the one time he did so on purpose). Like we're talking split-every-subsequent-arrow level of bullshit accuracy if he wants here. So that's a lot better than merely decent. He left due...

Ah. Well, that's essential. [X] Do some research. -[X] Sympathetic Magecraft I (Stage 0/1) (DC 15)

What do familiars have anything to do with reinforcement? Not to say it isn't useful to know what leads to it since that's likely the other prereq for Peel Away The World's Skin, but that wasn't the question. https://typemoon.fandom.com/wiki/List_of_Magic_Spells#Reinforcement It's the easiest...

What leads to reinforcement, that is the question? It's a good starting point. We won't be able to pretend we're even vaguely normal. Homura has too much 'how do you do, fellow kids'-energy, and isn't self-aware enough to even try to hide it. Good thing Homura will be in a separate building...

[X] Don't approach her; investigate from the shadows There's a 50/50 chance that Homura would drop all her spaghetti on the ground trying to communicate with Madoka here, and we don't know what to cryptically warn her about either, we're just as in the dark as she is. Better to stalk her.

Ah, but that just makes it more compelling of a house for her to join, though, especially with her association to darker elements (salamanders, Homucifer, suicide, etc). Consider that the majority of Homura's likely talents will need connections to less-than-legal learning materials, and that's...